Re:Why didn't Common Lisp fix the world?
by thiht on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @07:53AM
(#11712801)
You took the examples where the number of parentheses is the same. Here is a more honest example:
That's a simple expression and I'm not even sure I managed to match the () correctly
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I agree it's hard to write lisp without a proper editor. Having seen the light I just can't go back now. The power, ease, and simplicity are not something I've experienced with non lisps.
I don't know much about Lisp, but at ILC 2014 [1] there were about 40 participants. In a show of hands, absolutely all of them used Emacs to write their Lisp. I've never seen Emacs unanimity anywhere else.
--
Incedentally I also use Emacs for editing lisp. (emacs lisp and Clojure.) Learning the hotkeys/concepts behind structural editing of lisp code was life changing metamorphasis, but quite difficult overall. There's been some fantastic work done by the Parinfer [1] team to bring the awesomeness of structural editing of lisp to the masses. The basic idea is that your parenthesis should infer where they belong by way of your indentation.
I installed Parinfer it on my project: CLJSFiddle[2], and it's not what I'm used to and doesn't have everything but for a novice it is highly usable - check it out!
[1] https://shaunlebron.github.io/parinfer/ [2] http://cljsfiddle.com
Your example is also misleading. The `a` and `expr` are written as variables in the left example, but as function calls in the Lisp version. More correctly it would be either
if (a && !b) { expr } => (if (and a (not b)) expr)
Or if (a() && !b) { expr() } => (if (and (a) (not b)) (expr))
Now the amount of parentheses is either 4/6 or 8/10 which is not a very big difference (and caused only by the syntactic sugar for `not`), especially considering that the left example uses `!`, `&&` and two kinds of parentheses (perhaps a `;` as well).You're absolutely right, I didn't know the difference between "a" and "(a)", sorry.
My point was more about the two extra parentheses for each && or ||. Imagine converting
if (a && b && c && d || e)
to a LISP.
Re:Why didn't Common Lisp fix the world?
by likeclockwork on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @09:23AM
(#11713385)
if (a && b && c && d || e) {
doSomething();
}
becomes (if (or (and a b c d) e)
(doSomething))
It's just a little more explicit because operator associativity and precedence aren't worked out for you. (For better or for worse.)EDIT: I think you were imagining something like this:
(if (or (and a (and b (and c (and d)))) e)
(doSomething))
..which is definitely not the art.Adding to this, in a real situation those variables are probably not going to be nice single letter variables. With longer names the Lisp syntax with unambiguous structure/order of precedence becomes much nicer.
(if (or (and foobar
(some-predicate-p quux)
(= qwerty 432))
(a-long-function-call-with-two-args bar ytr))
...)
Compared to something like: if (foobar &&
somePredicate(quux) &&
(qwerty == 432) ||
aLongFunctionCallWithTwoArgs(bar, ytr)) {
...
}