If people are the cause of climate change, then fewer people seems like the best solution, no?
It's the 'dead great-grandfather principle' [0]:
"He’s much greener than you, you cannot compete with that. If you move into a smaller apartment, your grandfather is in a very, very small apartment. It’s underground, there’s no lighting, there’s no heating, he doesn’t have any broadband."
I don't disagree with you or the parent comment at all, I absolutely believe that we should be limiting our carbon emissions. But at its core this is a philosophical problem as much as a scientific one. To what extent do we have the 'right' to change the climate? Should we have a per-person carbon allowance? A global one child policy?
[0] http://www.wired.com/2011/02/transcript-of-reboot-11-speech-...
It may not be a very novel question. What right do we have to pollute our environment? I can't emit lead from my car, or toxic vapors from my home or workplace. Greenhouse gasses are just more gassous pollutants among many others.
I think this needs to be approached as a matter of degree, not a blanket statement. Some flying saves lives directly: Medical evacs, the military, etc. Some is worthwhile. The question is, where do we draw the line?
Is it worth it for climate scientists to fly to a conference that will accelerate progress on climate change? Is it worth it for someone to fly to see their elderly parents? To woo someone they are likely to marry, providing a lifetime bond for two people, and possibly making new people? To fly to the Olympics as a spectator? For what purposes is telepresence a sufficient substitute?
I think the threshold should be raised much higher and climate change needs to be addressed as a crisis. Even people who believe the science seem to not quite embrace the changes that need to be made; there is a lack of leadership setting new standards and telling people the hard facts: When is flying worthwhile? This study of this question, and many others like it, should be mature and well-known and not a relatively novel idea on HN.