Re:Requiem for the American Dream – Noam Chomsky
by rdancer on Thursday May 12, 2016 @08:46PM
(#11687867)
The problem with heavy editing of speech is exactly what you say. We find it difficult to dissociate what we see (somebody giving a speech) with what really is happening (editor piecing a narrative together, at the extreme splicing words together phoneme-by-phoneme). I found it edited too heavily, with tedious pacing, and pretentious graphics. Perhaps it's a good first introduction to Chomsky, and I'm happy if that audience finds it a fine movie!
Mr Chomsky gives a lot of interviews. Does he always require a veto power, how would that even work?
Until you pointed it out, I wasn't aware that Chomsky didn't write it himself. I would ordinarily find that troubling, but the script is closely based on Chomsky's previous writing. I'm confident Chomsky would have checked it carefully and would not have agreed to participate if there was anything he was unhappy about.