If a teacher gave students a grammar-checking tool to check their writing, they might assume that the tool knew better than they did, which is only sometimes true.
"Learn the rules like a pro, so you can break them like an artist."
-Picaso
"And that quote is almost certainly made up."
- Willem Shakespere
With then-innovated art like Cubism, which in some sense broke earlier rules, the point is that those artists, like Picasso, were able to do representative art in correct proportions -- they were just going beyond that.
This is a nontrivial issue, because there are always students who think they can skip learning boring mundane old fashioned art and go straight to something like cubism, but in 99% of cases that doesn't work well at all compared with learning "the rules" first.
With writing, many great writers have broken "the rules" with punctuation, spelling, grammar, etc. But the important thing is that they do so on purpose.
Whereas if one doesn't know the rules in the first place, one doesn't have the choice of whether to follow them or break them.
Such a person will always break those rules they don't know (subconscious knowledge counts btw) -- but not for aesthetic reasons, only out of ignorance.
If you listen to it without paying attention to the text (based on a poem by Goethe by the same name; both the German text and an English translation is found at [1]), parts of it sounds like horrible jammering and poor harmonies and it's easy to write it off as not sounding very nice.
Here's [2] a much clearer rendition (two singers, with much stronger delineation of the three different characters) than the one linked from Britannica.
If you do pay attention to the text, it is very clear that the unpleasant parts are very deliberate:
The singer(s) switches between the role of a father, his sick dying child, and the Erl-king that occurs in the hallucinations of the child while the father is riding to bring the child to a doctor.
The big difference between the unpleasant-sounding parts of this song and a bad composer is the clear intent and delineation - Schubert made things sound bad intentionally explicitly at the points he wanted to illustrate pain and fear, rather than because he didn't know how to make things sound pleasant when he wanted to.
The song clearly proves this by setting the childs jammering and the fathers fearful attempts to soothe him up against much more pleasant segments where the Erl-king speaks and tries to seduce the child to come with him.
You only get that clear separation if you know how to evoke each effect precisely. Arguably a bad particularly composer wouldn't even know how to make things sound bad the "right way" - there's a big difference between random bad sounds and making things evoke a child in pain.
I've heard great painters say that the only thing that matters is that you paint. Plenty of wonderful painters did not study their predecessors in depth.
I'm assuming that your 99% number is fabricated? Incidentally 99% of statistics are made up.
And come to think of it, isn't there a saying: Did stupidity require smart computers or did smart computers allow for stupidity?
An intelligent software (or one that pretends to be intelligent) might allow for any unqualified bloke to be in a position where they can teach.
Visiting noredink.com now ... I can't actually figure out what it is the site offers from a cursory glance, so I can't even begin to figure out whether it matches my idea and what issues it may have had that excluded it from her classroom.
I'll bounce grammarly off her later though, in case that's new.
As an aside, I don't think this is the optimal way to teach people how to write. What were the ideas in those papers? How were they organized? Do the student's arguments make sense? I think that's what most students spend most of their time thinking about when writing an essay, and it can be a bit demoralizing to see the teacher care just as much about whether the grammar was right. Most students can fix grammar mistakes relatively easily once they notice them anyway.
You would be surprised! Especially with people whose first languages aren't English. Having something to provide feedback on grammar problems early on would be really useful. Of course, once they get grammar down, the next step is rhythm and flow, as well as reducing redundancy, and the biggest problem, as you say, is always the story, but you have to peel through lots of grammar problems before you get to that point. I edit a lot of research papers for my Chinese peers (most have PhDs, I work in a China-based research lab, so that isn't weird), so I'm pretty clear on the problems.
[0]: http://grammarly.com
EDIT: but sure, this is only the first step and semantic parsing is far from solved
> This suggests that we are approaching human performance—but only on well-formed text.
It may fall down on exactly the bad writing you want to process. GIGO?
The problem is that while I have knowledge and experience in the computer vision side of machine learning, I lack experience in NLP. And to the best of my knowledge NLP as a field has not come as far as vision, to the extent that such an automated editor would have too many mistakes. To be student facing it would need to be really accurate. On top of that it wouldn't be dealing with well formed input. The input by definition is adversarial. So unlike SyntaxNet which is built to deal with comprehensible sentences, this tool would need to deal with incomprehensible sentences. According to the link, SyntaxNet only gets 90% accuracy on random sentences from the web.
That said, I might give SyntaxNet a try. The idea would be to use SyntaxNet to extract meaning from a broken sentence, and then work backwards from the meaning to identify how the sentence can be modified to better match that meaning.
Thank you Google for contributing this tool to the community at large.