News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by TazeTSchnitzel on Thursday May 12, 2016 @09:39AM (#11683255)
> #bi > #gays > #lesbian

Yet another example of mentions of queer identities being filed as pornography.

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by adekok on Thursday May 12, 2016 @10:00AM (#11683387)
Like:

#italiano #kansas #kickoff

Which presumably show racism towards Italians, a hatred of the midwest, and a dislike of football?

Or maybe Instagram has an automated system which correlated hashtags with reported porn. Tags with greater than X% reported porn get banned.

If that's true (and we have no reason to think it is or isn't true), then the banned tags come out simply because the #bi, etc. people happen to use those tags more for porn than (presumably) #straight people.

I'm wary of waving the racism / sexism / whatism flag. We're not all racist. We're not all sexist.

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by TazeTSchnitzel on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:56AM (#11684322)
> Which presumably show racism towards Italians, a hatred of the midwest, and a dislike of football?

If that was a consistent pattern, maybe, but I am yet to hear of it.

> Or maybe Instagram has an automated system which correlated hashtags with reported porn.

> I'm wary of waving the racism / sexism / whatism flag. We're not all racist. We're not all sexist.

Maybe it's automated, sure. Maybe it's not directly intended. Doesn't change the outcome.

Also, no, everyone is racist and sexist to varying extents, it's not a binary. Humans are imperfect.

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by mjolk on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:42PM (#11684781)
>Also, no, everyone is racist and sexist to varying extents, it's not a binary. Humans are imperfect.

Not everyone and everything is racist and sexist, stop peddling this histrionic narrative. If it's automated, are you claiming that algorithms are racist or sexist? The outcome isn't shaming a sexual orientation any more than x + 3 = 9 is "six shaming."

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by drdeca on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:23PM (#11685594)
Presumably the claim would be that it contributes to a phenomenon which is considered harmful, and that there is an obligation to have it not do that.

Now, I don't know that I agree with that claim (certainly not without reservations at least), but I think that the idea of an algorithm contributing to a harmful phenomenon, and that being bad, is not an obviously wrong idea.

I don't think your argument against theirs is a very good one. Something better than your x + 3 = 9 quip would be needed to refute it.

I'm saying this as someone who also disagrees with the worldview you are arguing against.

/epistemic virtue signaling

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by mjolk on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:59PM (#11685858)
The (management or computer) algorithm is likely designed to cut down on pornography and/or "offensive content"; the correlation of the terms bi, lesbian, or gay as metadata to explicit images is likely to be large on a visual platform. If anything is offensive, it's the quickness to jump to "I'm offended by logical explanations and I refuse to come up with practical solutions." Which is to say, I believe that the claim was infantile and deliberatively obtuse. Obviously it wasn't meant as a slight against sexual identity and if you want things to be better, get to work and stop complaining (which is unlikely to happen because complaining is easy and fixing things is hard).

Sometimes a cute riposte or simple response is all that's needed to defuse absurdity. Debating with someone plainly calling everyone racist and sexist isn't likely to bear fruit.

I wish we could get to a state in which the professionally offended would stop wasting others' time and encouraging this doublespeak-nonsense game -- there's only so many minutes in the day and we both wasted daylight on this.

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by etjossem on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:11PM (#11684473)
TazeTSchnitzel's right. For all we know, users reported posts from proud #bi, #gay, and #lesbian people because they wanted those people off Instagram, not because there was anything wrong with their content.

The result is the same: three very meaningful tags that can't be used.

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by mjolk on Thursday May 12, 2016 @10:11AM (#11683470)
Probably because people were using them to post/promote their pornography using terms they know people would search. Please find something more interesting to feign offense over.
Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by TazeTSchnitzel on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:58AM (#11684342)
I don't care for the cause, I care for the result. And I'm not so much claiming offence as I am pointing out that it's a troubling pattern.
Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by lazzlazzlazz on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:31PM (#11684669)
It isn't troubling. Those tags are primarily used to promote pornography. It makes sense.

Moral outrage isn't justified in this case. Sorry.

Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by kbart on Thursday May 12, 2016 @10:27AM (#11683601)
Open any porn site and I'm sure you will find these tags as top categories. It's not Twitter deciding it's pornographic or not, but users that use them as such, so admins simply have to react (unless you want Twitter to be overflown with gay/lesbian/bi porn).
Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by TazeTSchnitzel on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:59AM (#11684350)
Sure, I understand why this kind of thing tends to happen, but the result is no less insidious for it.
Re:Hashtags Instagram Won’t Let You Search by Kristine1975 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:07PM (#11684423)
>so admins simply have to react

They should react in a fashion that does not involve blocking hashtags with multiple meanings.