News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by onion2k on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:29PM (#11681131)
...looking to improve your day-to-day communication...

Is there evidence that saying 'umm' and 'ahh' reduces your ability to communicate effectively? Why are they bad? In conversation phonemes tell the listener than you haven't finished speaking but you're thinking about the next thing to say. Without them people would constantly interrupt one another, which would be horrible.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by 0xcde4c3db on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:12AM (#11681277)
I don't know where the research on this would be, but I suspect this sort of thing is about exploiting an ingrained cultural association from leaders reading prepared speeches/sermons. No filler words => commanding/authoritative/confident/powerful.

I agree that it would probably get tiresome very quickly in regular conversation. It reminds me of a comedian who asked "Do you think Jesse Jackson talks like that at the dinner table?", referring to the "Baptist preacher voice" seemingly being Jackson's default voice when he's interviewed on TV/radio.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by chroma on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:42AM (#11681545)
Removing filler words from normal speech gives you clearer speech, not a sermon. Orators use far more tricks than avoiding filler. They speak loudly with exaggerated tones. They exude emotion. Oration is a performance, and for most people it does not come naturally.

It's easy to see the difference with examples. A good example of clear speech is Sam Harris. Even when debating contentious topics, he speaks in calm paragraphs.[1] I could imagine Harris behaving the same in a one-on-one conversation. Contrast that to his opponent, William Lane Craig.[2] If Craig spoke that way in my living room, he would appear insane.

Avoiding filler is necessary for oration, but it's not remotely sufficient. I think this app will improve people's ability to communicate, not bloviate.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqaHXKLRKzg&t=3556

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqaHXKLRKzg&t=4226

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by andrewingram on Thursday May 12, 2016 @05:34AM (#11682303)
I often get the impression that Sam Harris is passively meditating when he speaks.

Though I listened to a 3 1/2 hour train-wreck of a conversation he posted on his podcast with someone who'd reviewed a recent book of his unfairly (in his opinion). He made a very strong effort to keep the conversation on track, and communicated as clearly as ever, but it didn't take long for the frustration to become clear to anyone who listens. My impression is, that as good a communicator as Sam Harris is, there's almost no way to salvage a conversation with a terrible communicator.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by afarrell on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:04AM (#11681635)
I usually have some latency between when someone says something and when I've finished running my "Am I about to say something stupid, pedantic, incorrect, boring, or cruel?" checks on my response. In my experience, removing filler words makes people think that you weren't listening to them or aren't going to bother to responding to what they said. I've had to deliberately practice saying "umm..." before speaking rather than just being silent while I thought about my response.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by seanhunter on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:28PM (#11685189)
I do a lot of public speaking, presenting and demoing to audiences of various sizes, and am considered (by at least some people) quite good at this stuff.

My advice would be just stop and think when you need to. It's completely fine and you will convey the impression that you are a serious and thoughtful individual, which is good. You can show that you were listening and are about to respond entirely through your body language.

If you feel uncomfortable with that, there are a bunch of simple tricks you can use here and saying "umm..." is not a good one. One easy thing is to always ensure you have a glass/bottle of water. If someone asks a tough question and you need time to think, wait until they have finished their question, then take a drink of water. No-one thinks this is even slightly strange and it gives you time to think and make a considered answer.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by huehehue on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:29AM (#11681731)
Forgive the expression, but I usually take a multithreaded approach in those situations. For example, you could (probably) easily rattle off a meaningful but neutral initial response and, while you're doing so, run whatever filters you need to before you arrive at the meat of your response.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by kagamine on Thursday May 12, 2016 @05:22AM (#11682272)
Let me seeeee ... weeeeeeell ... how can I put this? That sort of thing?
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by huehehue on Friday May 13, 2016 @12:18AM (#11688598)
Almost, I failed to mention the reply should contribute something and not just be words for the sake of words though. Purely my personal opinion. Basic example of a borderline canned reply while I think:

Q: "Where should we host our service?" A[instant]: "Well, you have X, Y, and Z." A[afterwards]: "X has these features, but Y might be a better fit for you because..."

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by sp332 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:03PM (#11684998)
An easy one is just acknowledging that you heard the person. Mix and match: oh, ok, huh!, (rephrase what the person just said), I had/hadn't thought of that, cool, interesting, that's an option.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by pgeorgi on Thursday May 12, 2016 @07:37AM (#11682669)
In a Q&A setting: "That's a great question."

It probably wasn't, but that phrase is friendly and buys time to prepare the actual answer.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by melvinmt on Thursday May 12, 2016 @09:18AM (#11683138)
> Removing filler words from normal speech gives you clearer speech, not a sermon. Orators use far more tricks than avoiding filler. They exude emotion. Oration is a performance, and for most people it does not come naturally.

I'm a bit confused. So if I understand you correctly, Sam is the one with clear, calm speech, but Craig is the praised "orator", yet he would appear "insane" in your living room. So which one do you think is the better speaker?

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by cmdrfred on Thursday May 12, 2016 @09:25AM (#11683181)
Take a look at Hitler, he played for the back of the room with not only dramatic (loud) speech but large gestures. He nearly conquered the world with his words. Content aside Craig's speech likely has a larger effect.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by chroma on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:06PM (#11684411)
Oration tends to sway audiences more than plain speech, but I think it's a little dishonest. Hopefully, such tactics will fall out of favor as more people notice them.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by copperx on Saturday May 14, 2016 @01:20AM (#11694652)
>> Hopefully, such tactics will fall out of favor as more people notice them.

Oh you are way too hopeful. I've experienced so many times situations where I think "surely everyone is seeing through the speaker's BS" only to be severely disappointed.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by mkagenius on Thursday May 12, 2016 @04:59AM (#11682204)
I somehow was reading Sam Harris as Arron Harris (YC partner, hosts a podcast related to startups). He also speaks nicely.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by wzdd on Thursday May 12, 2016 @05:45AM (#11682344)
Quite the opposite -- there is some evidence that disfluencies are good. Here is a study hinting that disfluencies improve recall:

Study: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0749596X11...

> these results suggest an attentional orienting account in which fillers direct attention to the speech stream but do not always result in specific predictions about upcoming material.

Article with commentary: http://nautil.us/blog/your-speech-is-packed-with-misundersto...

> They found that hearers remembered plot points better after listening to the disfluent versions, with enhanced memory apparent even for plot points that weren’t preceded by a disfluency. Stripping a speech of ums and uhs, as Toastmasters are intent on doing, appears to be doing listeners no favors.

On the other hand, if you want to give a powerful, short speech you may care less about people remembering specific content details and more about people remembering that you gave a good speech. In that case you may want to spend some time removing the disfluencies in your speech.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by onion2k on Thursday May 12, 2016 @06:39AM (#11682488)
Those are really interesting links. Thanks.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by rtpg on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:44PM (#11681179)
As a perpetual "Like"r/stutterer/"mmm"er...

I've found that when made conscious of it, I'm usually able to slow down my speech just a little bit and that alone gives my brain the time it needs to form thoughts properly and communicate clearly. At worst it's a good exercise in thinking a bit before speaking, especially for us ADHD-types who tend to blurt out the wrong thing at the wrong time quit often.

Our brains seem pretty good at filtering that sort of stuff out, but anecdotally having too many filler words does seem to hurt both comprehension and impressions.

So I think it's more of a pacing thing then a latency thing. Slow down your speech a bit and you'll be in a more comfortable range.

(Side note as a serial interrupter: it's usually nice to let people finish talking)

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by kqr on Thursday May 12, 2016 @03:14AM (#11681878)
Thanks for reminding me about this. I both "umm" too much and speak too fast. I should be able to fix both!
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by deepGem on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:36PM (#11681156)
I don't think there's any evidence. However, in public speaking, using filler words is seen as a negative, in a sense that you don't know your subject very well. In day to day communications, I don't see this as 'room for improvement', as the filler words kind of indicate that you are thinking on the fly.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by ec109685 on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:56PM (#11681221)
There is a good anecdote here: http://firstround.com/review/radical-candor-the-surprising-s...

I think excessive fillers betrays a lack of confidence in what the person is saying, so reducing will help you be a more persuasive speaker.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by lotharbot on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:19AM (#11681292)
That's a great article, and the larger advice is relevant in ordinary relationships -- don't be an enabler; care about people, and be willing to tell them when they're doing something that hurts them or you or the team or the family or whatever. "When you say ummm that much it makes you sound stupid" is much better than ignoring the issue and letting your friend keep sounding like they don't know what they're talking about.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by mc32 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:45AM (#11681368)
It depends on the communication.

If it's with cubemates/rowmates it's okay. If you're a speaker (not just talking) but speaking, then it's noticeable and it becomes distracting. Mostly when you're paying attention and following their train of thought... When you're following someone's train of thought you're filling in in advance, the uhhm, kind of puts a kink in that thought process because it becomes very apparent when a meaningless interruption happens repeatedly.

Now, not being religious it may sound funny for me to say this, but I really appreciate listening to southern Baptist (?) preacher interviews because despite the subject, they are captivating. They pronounce all the syllables, don't cut their words short, don't mix /d/ and /t/ and sound all around pleasant. They are good speakers. Yes, some overdo it and overpronounce and drag out words, I don't mean those.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by princeb on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:46PM (#11681186)
I've never thought about it too much, but once I attempted to avoid filler words. I ended up sounding like William Shatner, I was told, and that is apparently not a good thing.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by gautamnarula on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:37AM (#11681344)
I don't think using filler words is an issue in regular conversations. It is less desirable in speeches, though, because it can become really distracting. The simple technique I've used to cut down on it during speeches is to pause instead of using a filler word. For whatever reason, it ends up being much less distracting.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by BinaryIdiot on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:50PM (#11681200)
> Is there evidence that saying 'umm' and 'ahh' reduces your ability to communicate effectively? Why are they bad?

Hmm I can't find any good research though at least anecdotally it makes it a lot hard for me to pay attention. Take Paul Graham for instance. Smart guy, great speaker but his frequent "umms" ended up taking me out of his talk and then I couldn't concentrate on anything but his "umms". I love reading his essays but I find it hard to concentrate on his speaking.

Granted I don't know if that says something negative about my ability to concentrate, about Paul's speaking ability, or both and it's anecdotal so no idea if my experience is common.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by greyskull on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:03AM (#11681247)
Elon Musk is another popular example. His presentation skills are awful. I appreciate that they do away with corporate ultra-PR presentations, he certainly seems more human, but I have a hard time enjoying watching his reveals; they're too far in the unrefined direction.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by alexroan on Thursday May 12, 2016 @08:38AM (#11682893)
Completely agree. He's not helped by the fact that his audience cheer every 20 seconds. Luckily his products do most of the talking for him.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by pattle on Thursday May 12, 2016 @06:31AM (#11682469)
I don't think removing filler words reduces your ability to communicate effectively but it does make for more eloquent speech.

I'm a stammerer and I'm part of a speech therapy programme. One of the many techniques they teach us is to speak slower and remove filler words as they are often used by stammers to fill the silence when they can't get a word out.

When listening to a talk or lecture I do really notice if the speaker is using fill words and it kind of distracts me from the subject they are talking about.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by 746F7475 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:15AM (#11681674)
Well, it shows in some people's typing as well. They try to imitate their verbal communication and actually type "hmmm" or something like that. Drives me nuts.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by PaulRobinson on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:44AM (#11681794)
Hmmm.

Sorry. :-)

I do this sometimes when in a conversational tone say on Slack or IRC to show I'm actually thinking/confused by the direction the conversation has taken. I think this is better than the person I'm interacting with thinking I've just bailed.

This is not the same as, uhhh, me, uhhh, like, uhhhh, putting filler words into, uhhh, my writing.

It is used to enhance the communication by making it more representative of a good conversation, as opposed to using filler words.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by 746F7475 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @06:13AM (#11682434)
I don't think chat needs stuff like that. It doesn't give anything to the conversation, you could just think in silence
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by pandler on Thursday May 12, 2016 @08:54AM (#11682978)
Sure, but a read receipt (if you even get one) is ambiguous. I can assume that you're thinking about how to respond, but responding immediately with "hmm" is an explicit acknowledgement indicating that you need to need a moment to consider. If it seems weird, I'd chalk it up to the general awkwardness of trying to translate useful, non-verbal aspects of communication into textual analogs.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by qiwudqhwid on Thursday May 12, 2016 @06:16AM (#11682440)
Typing "Hmm" is almost exclusively used for politeness in situations when a) you don't want to contradict someone directly and b) don't want to sound pompous.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by pluma on Thursday May 12, 2016 @08:02AM (#11682754)
Or as a short hand for "I have read your message and I am thinking of a response."
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by Nr7 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:49AM (#11681579)
In my experience only excessive use of 'umm's and 'ahh's is distractive. If a speaker uses them only every now and then to gather their thoughts I don't mind at all. Actually it might even help the listeners to gather their thoughts as well.
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by nickysielicki on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:53AM (#11681397)
> Without them people would constantly interrupt one another, which would be horrible.

If you have a deep and commanding voice, people shut up as soon as you open your mouth, and they don't dare cut you off before you're done. It's primordial.

I noticed this especially a few weeks ago when I was watching presidential debate coverage. Of the six or seven people on screen, two were male. Everyone was talking over each other, except one of the guys who was mostly silent. It was really interesting to watch how he could begin to speak and everyone would be immediately quiet.

"Um", "uh", "well"... It's not that they inherently make you sound weak, it's just that people who take control of rooms don't develop them.

Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by Chris2048 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @08:48AM (#11682938)
Conqueror's haki
Re:Show HN: Speech Coaching App – Stop Saying 'Umm', 'Like',... by yAnonymous on Thursday May 12, 2016 @04:50AM (#11682168)
>Why are they bad?

Because, you know, they're overused like to the point that many Americans, ummmm, don't use them to like "tell the listener that you haven't finished speaking" anymore, you know, but instead they're like thrown randomly into, ahhh, sentences, even when the sentence is expressed fluidly, you know?

Using these phrases all the time has somehow become cool, even though it makes people look like fucking idiots.