News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by onion2k on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:34PM (#11662926)
There's a lot of software out there. Every car, every phone, every plane, computer, TV, washing machine, factory robot, etc - every thing works pretty much flawlessly on a day to day basis. Occasionally things need a reboot or a patch but that's all. The number of times software fails in our daily lives is pretty low considering we interact with it so often. I'd contend that software quality is actually staggeringly high. It could be higher, but there's the law of diminishing returns and all that.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by ssivark on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:01PM (#11663170)
That is not satisfactory. Some instances of software are more crucial than others eg. software running money transfers must have less tolerance for bugs than a game I play on my phone. The question is not whether software works most of the time, but how badly things go wrong when mistakes happen.

Here's an analogy: A weather forecaster can predict "no hurricane" every single day and have a near-perfect success rate. Needless to say, that's next to useless. (False positives and false negatives have wildly different costs in this context.)

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by onion2k on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:17PM (#11663296)
At a guess I'd say that the probability of a fault in a piece of software does approximately match the cost of it failing. A phone game is very likely to have more bugs than a banking system. My point is that both applications actually work really well. In my experience premium phones games crash maybe once in every thousand runs. Bank money transfer software crashes perhaps once in every few billion runs (that's a total guess but we'd hear about it if it was higher and there are a lot of bank transfers every day). I think that's quite good.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by marssaxman on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:19PM (#11663677)
I'd argue the opposite: software quality is generally about as low as it can possibly be while having any value at all. I do my best to interact with as small a quantity of it as I can manage, since it generally frustrates me so much that my life is better if I continue to do most things manually.

A couple decades of work on compilers, dev tools, drivers, firmware, and other sorts of system software may have warped my perceptions somewhat.

(Edit: I don't say that to pretend some kind of superiority; my code is just as buggy as everyone else's. I've just had many occasions to dig around in other people's code and figure out why it stopped working, after we tried to change something that shouldn't have affected it. Hardware, too, you can't trust that either.)

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by ksk on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:12PM (#11663645)
>Every car, every phone, every plane, computer, TV, washing machine, factory robot, etc - every thing works pretty much flawlessly on a day to day basis.

What is your definition of "pretty much"? In my experience none of those things you mentioned have ever worked pretty much flawlessly.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by Retra on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:01PM (#11663934)
"Flawlessly" is definitely not the word I'd use. "Adequate" maybe. But just about every piece of software I use day to day is frustrating to interact with, and those that aren't might be 'upgraded' at any second.