It's obviously not the same as a real pin; I've yet to find a PC game that simulates nudging to my satisfaction.
One interesting data point is that my 10 year old son is more interested VR pinball than either regular PC pinball or real life pinball. I think it's because of: - the novelty of VR - the animations on and around the table (these can be either fun or distracting) - the tables are easy for a beginner - the fact he's taller in VR. At an arcade he's either not tall enough or has to stand on a stool, but in VR he can look down on the table as if he's 6 feet tall.
Pinball Arcade is working on VR version, so I'm interested to see their take on it. They mentioned it in passing for their AC/DC table kickstarter (since cancelled but still under development).
Not being able to look at the ball/table is a key part of pinball I find missing from the digital experience, and while VR takes care of this I think I would still miss the physical experience of the controller.
I see someone made a pinball table controller to use with Oculus as soon as it came out[1]; this controller doesn't look heavy enough to have fun tilting properly, but it certainly got me excited to try some VR pinball.
[1]: http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/1/11345624/pinsim-pinball-fx-...