News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by notliketherest on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:14PM (#11656235)
When the employees of Facebook collectively ask "What responsibility do we have to stop the election of Donald Trump" at an internal meeting, it gives me Orwellian chills. Today, it's not governments we need to fear the most, it's data hungry, fascist internet corporations.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by mc32 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:21PM (#11656267)
Sometimes people have a hard time decoupling politics from their jobs. They should try how ridiculous it would sound to say "What can we do to stop Bernie Sanders". That should give them pause. As far as I know all the major candidates are operating within the law and thus we ought not try to Stop Them" just because our politics differ.

Or what if instead of national figures FB or anyone else tried to railroad an SF Supe they didn't particularly like because they shot down their proposed development. Or Menlo Park.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by notliketherest on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:29PM (#11656299)
Exactly. The problem is, as a private company, should Facebook choose to manipulate it's news feed algorithm to promote one candidate or the other, or for whatever reason, this would be its prerogative under the First Amendment.

I personally choose to not use Facebook specifically for these reasons. Even though I know many Facebook employees personally, I don't trust it's employees to divorce their own interests and their powerful position as Facebook's curators.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by harmegido on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:32PM (#11657247)
This isn't a new problem. Old media has been doing this for centuries.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by ivanca on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:50PM (#11657312)
Old media usually has had opposition, like there is Fox but there is also MSNBC. Facebook is THE social network, even Twitter is a joke in terms of size against it.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by aorth on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:32AM (#11657815)

  They were also discouraged from mentioning Twitter by name in headlines and summaries, and instead asked to refer to social media in a broader context.
Hah!
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by mc32 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @11:26PM (#11657422)
Indeed. It's not like there is the LA facebook or the NY facebook or the Chicago centinal facebook, etc... This is more like a "Global Times", let alone a "US times".

So anything they might do which appears to be editorialisitc in nature regarding politics would be of concern.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by maxerickson on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:26PM (#11656288)
If they all agree, why shouldn't they collectively act to accomplish some thing or the other?

Which is a completely different thing than manipulating their users, which they shouldn't be doing for any reason.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by tmpanon1234act on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:45PM (#11656604)
Because they're a monopolistic entity with unprecedented control of information flow. Nothing quite like this has ever existed. It's in the public interest that it be regulated precisely because it can control the outcome of elections and other behaviors that are functionally essential in a society.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by forthefuture on Sunday May 08, 2016 @08:50PM (#11656862)
No one is changing their mind about politics after reading something on Facebook.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by jonathankoren on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:38AM (#11657826)
The Facebook echo chamber is a true effect, and echo chambers cause a feedback loop of encouraging radicalization. If you wanted to, you could always run sentiment analysis over comments containing a political candidate, say Donald Trump, and penalizing in feed ranking comments that were pro-Donald or anti-Hillary, thus dampening the echo chamber. Same thing with simply penalizing links from right wing websites. The echos then start to fade, and then perhaps lower the motivation of someone to vote or donate money or something.

In the end though, you're basically just playing at the margins.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by 1337biz on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:48AM (#11658576)
News curators also have the power to “deactivate” (or blacklist) a trending topic—a power that those we spoke to exercised on a daily basis.

This could be already describing what you are suggesting.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by jonathankoren on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:48AM (#11658795)
No. Absolutely not. That's not what is happening at all. I know. I worked on FB trending from the algorithmic side.

The types of trending topics that are blacklisted tend to be low quality trends. Say #FollowFriday, or take examples from the current Twitter trends, #mondaymotivation, #MondayMorning, #DressAFilm, or #MondayBlogs.

They also will blacklist a trend when it's a duplicate of another trend say #GoodWifeFarewll vs #TheGoodWife. In fact, they'd probably try to combine those two if the clustering algorithm failed, and then relabel it "The Good Wife" since it undoubtedly corresponds to a FB page.

The manipulation of the candidate set of trends is there because the trending algorithm and the clustering algorithm is too noisy to publicly surface. The trends you actually see are algorithmically chosen based on your behavior.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by 1337biz on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:34AM (#11660588)
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by jonathankoren on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:59PM (#11661770)
Quoth the former curator: “Every once in awhile a Red State or conservative news source would have a story. But we would have to go and find the same story from a more neutral outlet that wasn’t as biased.”

Well, there you go. Quite frankly there's a neutral editorial voice that FB wants to project. And so the main article has to be from a legitimate unbiased news source. Brietbart, Newsmax, and the like simply aren't.

Having a list of approved sources to highlight is really common I these types of products, because no one wants Stormfront to be on the front page.

Of the topics don't get out of the ghetto of subculture's echo chamber, it's never going to be approved. Even the topics cited are basically just birther conspiracy du jour.

Even if the topic gets approved with a different main link, everything is being shown on the results page, just not with a gold star next to it in the top slot.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by 1337biz on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:33AM (#11666436)
The problem is that "legitimate unbiased news source" is subjective. Unless you only allow direct press agency news - and even here we have often the discussion which words and language is "loaded" - you are define what is neutral and not.

Personally I would regard Breitbart or Newsmax are just on par with HuffPo - for you they probably aren't. That's why pretending to know what others have to perceive as "legitimate unbiased news" is such a delicate issue that should not be done in secrecy.

Non-transparency on blacklisted sites and topics will always lead to distrust and the expectation of one-sided political shilling.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by jonathankoren on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:40AM (#11667024)
Meh. You have editorial control, and you know what type of voice you want. You enforce the voice. There's no point in trying to satisfy everyone because you can't. For example, Wikipedia was seen as a den of communist atheist propaganda and so Conservapedia was created.

Sure you could publicize your approved list of sites, but then you're just going to attract a bunch of people with an agenda to trying to promote their agenda by claiming some sort of slight by not being included. In the end though, the only honest response to this criticism is, "Screw you. Make your own site."

Topics aren't blacklisted except when they duplicate something else. Most topics simply aren't approved for trending. If you want to know what's not approved, look at Twitter trends, it's full of junk. Honestly, that's the best public example of what the trending topics algorithm detects.

You really need to read Tom Stocky's post about this, because that's exactly how it's run. But you don't really have to, because it's exactly what I told you.

Finally, if you actually click on any of the trends, pretty much everything on that page is algorithmic. Find a trend that mentions, Obama, I'm sure you're going to find a racist post on that list, because there's always scummy people.

PS. For the record, I always feel dirty if I visit HuffPo. Gawker on the other hand, I'll own up to reading that tabloid.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by tmpanon1234act on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:01PM (#11656901)
That people mostly still believe Facebook is innocuous is exactly the problem. https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-internet-flips-elections-and-...
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by nemothekid on Monday May 09, 2016 @12:27AM (#11657625)
>No one is changing their mind about politics after reading something on Facebook.

That would imply Facebook's influence doesn't exist, and its $340B valuation is a sham.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by Trundle on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:39PM (#11657037)
What makes Facebook different from tv ads?
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by mc32 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:28PM (#11656297)
The same reason many people believe the citizens united decision was a suboptimal outcome.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by jessriedel on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:46PM (#11656359)
Very much agree, but do you really think it's all that different at the NY Times? I'm sure at FB no one thought they were going to beat Trump by being deceptive or manipulative. No, they would just link to stories they thought were more accurate, had less spin, covered more sides etc. Likewise, I'm sure many NY Times reporters are driven by a feeling of duty to concentrate on issues where they feel they can bring truth/illumination to the campaign and get Trump defeated.

I guess it's plausible to me that a new company like FB lacks some sort of important company culture for reporting that the NY Times has by virtue of its long history, but this seems minor. The real issue is (1) the consolidation in the news industry and (2) its political homogeneity. FB and the NY Times are each examples of both.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by notliketherest on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:01PM (#11656421)
There's a few important differences at play I think. First, the NYT has a few million paid subscribers, whereas Facebook is a free service with a billion and a half members. Just like their technical infrastructure, the sheer scale of their platform and reach is mind-boggling, global and borderless - unlike anything the world has ever seen. We may be fooling ourselves by judging Facebook through the lens of old media - there's been a paradigm shift and it needs to be appreciated and judged as such. Second, the NYT is a media company - which generally leans left. They create content. Facebook is more akin to the printing press company that newspaper companies employee (ROUGH analogy) or cable providers for TV. Remember how much shit Verizon (Comcast?) got itself in when it manipulated internet packets to deliver it's own advertising to its subscribers? Didn't they get sued and have to pay millions? I think Facebook manipulating its news feed algorithm should be as egregious as that behavior.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by rgo on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:48PM (#11656619)
To me the relationship between NYT and FB (or any other content creator and FB) is not very different from that of freelancer content writers and content companies like Demand Media, of eHow and Livestrong fame. The only difference is that content published in FB, either by users or sponsored, gets to keep its branding, whereas content freelancer are ghosts - although most people I know share content in FB with total disregard to the source. It's sad to see how quality content creators like NYT now get to share the wall with unscrupulous ones. To all effects, FB is turning news into a commodity.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by sinemetu11 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:49PM (#11656369)
There was a recent study looking at this possible issue. They called it Search Engine Manipulation Effect [1]:

"The fifth experiment is especially notable in that it was conducted with eligible voters throughout India in the midst of India’s 2014 Lok Sabha elections just before the final votes were cast. The results of these experiments demonstrate that (i) biased search rankings can shift the voting preferences of undecided voters by 20% or more, (ii) the shift can be much higher in some demographic groups, and (iii) search ranking bias can be masked so that people show no awareness of the manipulation."

[1]: http://www.pnas.org/content/112/33/E4512.abstract

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by avivo on Sunday May 08, 2016 @08:51PM (#11656866)
What if the employees at Facebook instead asked "What ethical responsibility do we have to ensure that we, as the primary distributor of news in the world, do some minimal amount of fact checking."

The goal shouldn't be to "stop Trump" — that's not what we want a news distributor to do. I don't want bias against a particular person in my news distributors. What I want is for my news distributors to actually have ethical standards that enable them to serve the public good (and as a by product hopefully prevent lying demagogue's from gaining power).

Is it "bias" to use a standardized method or algorithm (even one that involves humans reading natural language") to filter content by accuracy and provide some interface indication not just for phishing, and for porn, but also for falsehoods?

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by morgante on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:00PM (#11656897)
Realistically, this is exactly how they would go about trying to stop Drumpf. Plausible deniability and all that jazz.

In fact, decisions which Facebook makes this election season will impact the result regardless of the intentionality behind those decisions. Even something as mundane as the mix between links and images impacts different candidates disparately.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by makomk on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:05AM (#11658636)
Realistically, the only way for anyone not to seem like they're going out their way to attack Trump during this election is to completely forget about fact checking, because he lies so repeatedly and shamelessly about things he's already been caught out on: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/03/...
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by roymurdock on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:22PM (#11656507)
While this may be a more direct or open admission of a "moral" attempt to shape political outcomes, I think it's worth remembering that every other major corporation has its hand in the pot, albeit in a less direct fashion, when its board pours money into lobbyists, special interest groups, and media outlets. Sometimes for "moral" reasons, sometimes for economic reasons - but every major corporation is a political player.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by notliketherest on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:28PM (#11656535)
As I mentioned in my other comment, we may be fooling ourselves by judging Facebook through the lens of old media or old corporations - there's been a paradigm shift and it needs to be appreciated and judged as such. A free, borderless and global communications platform and service used by 1.5 billion people simply doesn't fit into our classic models of "free speech" and "corporate personhood". I'm not sure what the best approach will be to ensuring their neutrality when it comes to their algorithms, but I think that assurance should exist, ideally in a trustless, provable fashion.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by kyle8 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:18PM (#11656492)
They are totally oblivious to their own double standards. Some of the smartest people in the world. That's the tragedy.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by downandout on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:52PM (#11656385)
I am no fan of anyone that is currently running for President. Assuming that Clinton, Sanders, or Trump ultimately win, Congress and the Senate will have to be our last line of defense in keeping the "winner" from doing serious damage to the country.

That said, I absolutely think that Facebook and other major media outlets should be held to a form of the Equal Time rule:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal-time_rule

The fact that we don't have an equivalent rule for major websites is a serious problem.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by hermannj314 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:43PM (#11656598)
I would normally disagree on the equal time rule because they are a private company, but Facebook recently built a data center in my town, took all of our municipal water supply, won't pay taxes for several years, and is only creating 4 jobs. And we allowed it because of some weird obsession our town had with having a data center here. Democracy...yeah!!!

Screw 'em. If they want to play the corporate welfare game, they can abide by the equal time rule.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by evgen on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:41AM (#11658547)
What utter BS. Facebook has spent probably close to twenty million on building its Altoona data center (only one built recently so will assume that is the one in question). It did not take the municipal water supply, in fact this particular data center is one of the greenest in the world. It did get a tax break on its water usage, like most large municipal customers do, and according to news articles had an additional water main run to the site, but it does not have any particular water requirements that would necessitate any magic source. If you want to look for water savings in Altoona start at Adventureland and the amount of water being wasted there on a daily basis.

As for taxes, what taxes do you think were going to be assessed on this property? It was an empty piece of land before FB arrived so it was not like the city was losing much property tax to begin with. In return Facebook is paying salaries for forty or so people on site and the thousand or so who worked for over two years building the site. Oh, and because tech firms like it when others do the research and general site selection you will notice that Microsoft is dumping tens of millions into a data center in West Des Moines as well. You're welcome.

You "allowed" it because it was a good deal for a city like Altoona that otherwise was not much more than an amusement park and the last place to get gas on I-80 before you hit Des Moines.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:54PM (#11656647)
> took all of our municipal water supply

Can you expand on this a bit? Do you mean to say when you turn on the tap in the kitchen nothing comes out and that you are no longer able to use the shower or flush the toilet?

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by hermannj314 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @11:31PM (#11657437)
Changed water source from local aquifer to local river. Apparently the data center takes the water and dumps it back into ground. The sourcing change cost more so citizen water prices went up. Guess what Facebook gets, you got it, free water. Not a joke.

It is crazy how much money we just give to profitable companies.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:31PM (#11662903)
Sorry to hear that. Can you link to any news, or other, sources about this? I don't use facebook so I'm glad to not be contributing to this, but maybe there are other data centres in your town I do use, who knows.

Progress hey, it's tricky.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by kristianc on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:27PM (#11656289)
I don't remember this being a point of discussion when Reddit did an AMA with Obama.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by arcticfox on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:38PM (#11656331)
Doesn't Reddit do AMAs with almost anyone? I'm missing something.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by kristianc on Sunday May 08, 2016 @06:45PM (#11656355)
It was considered a big deal at the time, though you could consider going from the sitting President answering questions on Reddit to shoveling large amounts of money to Facebook to ensure your message gets seen a retrograde step that's happened since.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by SapphireSun on Sunday May 08, 2016 @08:16PM (#11656736)
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by puranjay on Monday May 09, 2016 @03:31AM (#11658137)
I'm just amazed at how happy and ignorant people seem to be about giving away Facebook more and more signals about their likes/dislikes

They started the profile badges thing and folks thought that was so cool.

I had to explain to them that this is one more data point for Facebook - if I change my profile badge to a Manchester United logo, it probably means that I really, really care about Manchester United.

I can then be targeted by an advertiser that wants to sell merchandise to Manchester United fans

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by esailija on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:24AM (#11658469)
> I can then be targeted by an advertiser that wants to sell merchandise to Manchester United fans

And why is this itself a bad thing?

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by mwfunk on Sunday May 08, 2016 @08:09PM (#11656717)
I agree with you 100%. At the same time, in this specific situation I can't help but still be even more disturbed at the thought of a Trump presidency than I am by a data hungry, Orwellian, fascist Internet corporation. Not defending the Facebook employee(s) who asked that question by any stretch, just marveling at how screwed up our political system is. :(
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by krapp on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:19PM (#11656958)
There's nothing wrong with asking the question. In a free society, it should be perfectly acceptable to do so without consequence. It would be Orwellian if the question were never even asked.
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by ivanca on Sunday May 08, 2016 @07:57PM (#11656668)
Just think how unresonable sounds to say "What responsability do we have to stop Hitler?

Poe's law or whatever, but I can't even imagine a worst possible candidate than Trump, even Eric Cartman would be a better president than this Daily-mail-esque cartoon of human being.

Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by ivanca on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:47PM (#11657305)
Downvote all you want, still, it's interesting how no-one took the time to answer the question, if facebook existed back then and had tried to stop Hitler getting to power would that have been Orwellian? It is our duty to always defend democracy even when we strongly presume it will bring destruction and misery?
Re:What Happened When Facebook Hired Some Journalists by rpgmaker on Sunday May 08, 2016 @08:40PM (#11656823)
Trump is a proto-fascist asshole, no doubt about that but when it comes down to it he shared his worst aspects with every major candidate that ran for the GOP nomination this season. The only difference is that Trump didn't play the game how he was supposed to so the media branded him as being particularly evil when he really is embodying the beliefs of the party that he now represents (and that all other candidates paid lip service to in one form or another).