News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:22PM (#1165204)
Am I the only one thinking "the hell with privacy"? I understand the need for a certain level of privacy. However people watching these monitors see hundreds if not thousands of people a day... Do you think they care a second about who wears a pacemaker, or a gastric ring? They might notice it, but they will forget it the second after, and most certainly never meet the person again. So tell me, how is it a privacy violation?
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:32PM (#1165246)
?! Not exactly sure why I was down-voted... This was a sincere question. Did I miss something obvious?
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by yalurker on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:41PM (#1165266)
Your post is self-contradictory and illogical. You say to forget about privacy, then acknowledge that some privacy is important, then suggest that privacy invasions don't matter as long as they happen to a lot of people.

Most of us recognize we're more likely to get hit by lightning while winning the lottery than be saved by one of these machines, and as such oppose their use.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by rick888 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:31PM (#1165415)
"Most of us recognize we're more likely to get hit by lightning while winning the lottery than be saved by one of these machines, and as such oppose their use."

Do you actually know how many attacks these machines will prevent? You don't seem to have any facts to back up your statements.

In addition to this, the fact that people know that these machines are in place will prevent some future attempts.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by ErrantX on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:05PM (#1165508)
> Do you actually know how many attacks these machines will prevent?

Consider firstly the number of attacks caught per year. The number of flights per year. And the number of uncaught attacks per year.

I guess in the last year they might have caught one attack (the Xmas day one). In which case think the statement you are replying to is a fair one.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by rick888 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @11:04PM (#1166129)
"Consider firstly the number of attacks caught per year. The number of flights per year. And the number of uncaught attacks per year."

My issue isn't with the low percentage of attacks. It's the consequence of an attack, which is that innocent people die. Not to mention the fact that there might be less attacks because we are so protected.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by ErrantX on Thursday March 04, 2010 @05:26AM (#1166577)
That doesnt make a lot of sense.

> It's the consequence of an attack, which is that innocent people die.

But, they dont. Not all that often anyway. More innocent people die due to careless drivers; why should be concentrate on terrorism (which is one of the minimal risks we face)

> Not to mention the fact that there might be less attacks because we are so protected

There are, generally, no attacks anyway.

As always in these discussions I recommend reading "Risk: The Science and Politics of Fear" which addresses this much better than I can. :)

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by rick888 on Saturday March 06, 2010 @06:00PM (#1172394)
"More innocent people die due to careless drivers"

You can't force every driver to be more careful. I think the only way to fix these types of things would be to have really harsh jail sentences, so people think very carefully before they act. But, I would not want to live in a society like this.

"why should be concentrate on terrorism (which is one of the minimal risks we face)"

If we can prevent innocent people from dying, why not have extra security in place? For the average person, it's just a minor inconvenience.

Airport security is much easier to maintain because it is more of a controlled environment.

"But, they dont. Not all that often anyway. More innocent people die due to careless drivers; why should be concentrate on terrorism (which is one of the minimal risks we face)"

Like I said, if we don't concentrate on these things, we may have even more attacks because criminals/terrorists will know that they can get through security fairly easily. Many plots most likely never happen because of the difficulty of trying to get through security checkpoints.

"There are, generally, no attacks anyway."

Because we have tough security policies in place. Before 9/11, US airport security was lacking and terrorists were able to take advantage of it.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:47PM (#1165285)
Maybe "the hell with privacy" was too strong. I reacted this way because my feeling is privacy is often an over-used excuse not to comply to a security measure.

And actually my point was not that these invasions should happen to a lot of people, but that they are fine as long as the collected information are immediately disposed and have no consequence in the future.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by Esspe on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:43PM (#1165272)
Almost nobody likes Big Brother (even if it supposedly doing something for our own good).
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by marshallp on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:36PM (#1165261)
Do you want some random dude looking at your adult daughter trhough one of these.
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by iloveyouocean on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:52PM (#1165468)
I could not care less if some guy looked at my 'adult daughter' gasp. She has breasts and genitals and a woman's body, just like the other billions of females on the planet. I think people consider themselves to be far more unique and important than they should.

By passing through a scanner, what will be revealed about a person that is truly of any consequence? They have a 'small' penis? They are fat? They have various health problems? Deformities? So basically, the technician may, at worst, have knowledge about a person that is certainly already known by other people. Do you think the technician is going to write this stuff down and blackmail people? I just don't understand what the assumed horrible consequence is.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by marshallp on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:02PM (#1165495)
It's possible to invert the image from the scanners and get a realistic color photo.

Also, you seem to be reducing humans to soulless machines. By your logic it should be possible to swear at any person i encounter on the street. After all, it's just a bunch of sounds.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by DougWebb on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:54PM (#1165307)
Forget about the adult daughters; what about children? Aren't these machines generating child porn every time a child walks through it, and turning the viewers into criminals as soon as they see the image of a child walking through it?

Or do children get to bypass the scanner, giving the terrorists useful mules for carrying forbidden objects onto the plane?

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by ErrantX on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:00PM (#1165489)
> Aren't these machines generating child porn every time a child walks through it

No.

(I did answer this question a couple of times before :))

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:01PM (#1165331)
I don't see how this is different from medical school examination. Should we prosecute all "child doctors" (don't know the exact english term) as criminal as well for seeing naked children every day?
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by WarDekar on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:31PM (#1165417)
"Pornography or porn is the portrayal of explicit sexual subject matter for the purposes of sexual excitement." [1]

Doctors don't take photos (or other media) of naked children, so there is no pornography involved. Obviously if they do take photos, there is a crime. Likewise if they touch a child inappropriately, there is a (different) crime.

In the case of the body scanners, images are taken, thus it is pornography, and a crime.

And of course, MDs are actually screened and have thorough background checks where-as there have been multiple instances [2] of TSA employees not being thoroughly screened.

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography

2. http://boardingarea.com/blogs/flyingwithfish/2010/02/05/tsa-...

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by dagw on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:48PM (#1165455)
What? Are you seriously saying that you consider all photos taken of someone naked and under the age of 18 automatically pornographic and thus a crime? Your opening Wikipedia quote even disagrees with that. If someone is incapable of looking at a picture of a naked child and not find it a sexually explicit subject, then the problem lies very much with them and they really should consider getting help
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by WarDekar on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:58PM (#1165485)
I then went on to show that the TSA doesn't exactly screen their employees that well- how are we to know whether or not all the employees monitoring these things won't be sexually aroused by child pornography?

Seems like it should be a pretty good job to have if one were into that kind of thing- tons of access, not much oversight, and legal to boot!

EDIT: I then went on a Google hunt and found an article from Wired [1] in 2002 that says 'U.S. law defines kiddie porn as depictions of minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct, such as intercourse and masturbation, or that show "lascivious exhibition of the genitals or pubic area."'

By that definition however none of these cell-phone cases would be considered child porn, so apparently the US gov't has changed their stance on the issue in the past 8 years.

1. http://www.wired.com/techbiz/media/news/2002/05/52345

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:42PM (#1165435)
"Pornography or porn is the portrayal of explicit sexual subject matter for the purposes of sexual excitement."

"In the case of the body scanners, images are taken, thus it is pornography, and a crime."

Please read the whole sentence before saying it is a crime, unless you are implying all TSA employees enjoy sexual excitement while watching their screens.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by WarDekar on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:54PM (#1165475)
It has the potential for sexual excitement which is all that really matters. The images are there and can potentially be copied by someone that does have intention of using them for sexual excitement. Unless you've been living under a rock for the past 20 years (or possibly not in the US, I guess), you should know how quick-triggered the US gov't is on potential child pornography and would be in this case if they weren't the ones doing it.

Why don't you try putting an ad in your local paper for random children to pose nude for you, just make sure to keep all the photos on your hard drive for editing purposes.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:10PM (#1165518)
"It has the potential for sexual excitement which is all that really matters"

No it doesn't. Taking pictures with the potential for sexual excitement and taking pictures for the purposes of sexual excitement are two completely different things.

However, may I remind you that my original point (although maybe bad formulated) was that these pictures were fine as long as they were, of course, immediately disposed. Stealing this pictures for one's personal interest is of course a crime, but you cannot assume everyone will do so.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by ErrantX on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:10PM (#1165520)
It has the potential for sexual excitement which is all that really matters.

Nope, its an important factor sure. But not the only factor - or even the most important.

Why don't you try putting an ad in your local paper for random children to pose nude for you

Maybe it wouldn't work in that way exactly; but you can take pictures of children if they have serious artistic value (I cant remember the exact wording).

I wouldn't advise trying it though.

CP laws are, as with all computer crime, all about intent :)

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:38PM (#1165264)
As long as this random dude never meets my daughter again, I don't give a damn.
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by asyazwan on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:47PM (#1165284)
You are assuming the random dude to be purely random which may not be the case...

Plus using your logic you will not mind your daughter strip in a room full of random guys, hoping that will be the first and last encounter.

Meh, adult daughters can decide on their own anyway up to what levels they are willing to make themselves seen.

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by jpatte on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @04:52PM (#1165298)
I'm assuming the dude is a professional and is merely doing his job, like any woman shall assume her gynecologist is a professional doctor and not a peeping tom.
Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by asyazwan on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:19PM (#1165375)
Which makes you wonder what exactly are the requirements to qualify as the dude watching the monitor. First come first serve basis?

It's hard being a specialist but almost anyone can apply for security.

Well in my case if I had to I'd ask for female security officer (or gynecologist for that matter).

Re:Women refuse to go through airport body scanners by masomenos on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:11PM (#1165354)
write us back when TSA & equivalent go through the same selection process as MDs.