News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ogg objections by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:35AM (#1164284)
I can't help but feel the ffmpeg guys, despite providing a great service to the world, have got a real chip on their shoulder when it comes to all things Ogg and Xiph.

Does he think the ranty tone really helps get his message across? At least it's all written down in one place instead of sniped from the comments every time it could be vaguely thought relevant.

See this recent argument (between DonDiego and Monty) in the comment section of a blog about Google and VP8, which I assume prompted this article:

http://blog.gingertech.net/2010/02/20/googles-challenges-of-...

Re:Ogg objections by DarkShikari on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @01:43PM (#1164764)
I can't help but feel the ffmpeg guys, despite providing a great service to the world, have got a real chip on their shoulder when it comes to all things Ogg and Xiph.

They don't like things that are badly designed. This same chip applies equally to a lot of other stuff, especially proprietary formats, like the utterly atrocious and buggy RealVideo 10.

Xiph gets a double dose, however, because of the methods that Xiph uses to market their bad technology. They have at times posted outright lies about their software and then, once proven wrong, often refuse to recant. Example: the Theora vs x264 PSNR comparison where they "accidentally" performed measurement wrong, making x264 appear 2x worse.

They use the same techniques as many of the more evil commercial companies out there, which annoys the hell out of people who disagree with such techniques. ffmpeg devs believe that open source should be about honesty and good technology, not lies and FUD. Xiph disagrees, believing that "the ends justify the means", creating a practically unbridgeable gulf.

Thus Xiph has spent the last few years spreading absurd amounts of FUD about everyone who they believe opposes them. They have managed to convince a shocking number of people that "ffmpeg is illegal" and that you should use their software instead. Ironically, almost all the FUD in the multimedia space in recent years has come from people who claim to support "free software"! Didn't we spend years criticizing Microsoft for the exact same thing?

And you wonder why people don't like them!

Re:Ogg objections by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @01:55PM (#1164796)
Wasn't that PSNR comparison problem because of an ffmpeg bug?

And what evidence have you that it wasn't done "accidentally" (your scare quotes). You're clearly wrong if you're implying they didn't retract that claim, as they do so here, in an update to the original page:

http://web.mit.edu/xiphmont/Public/theora/demo7.html

You seem to be, in this very post, doing exactly what you accuse them of, spreading FUD and lies about a competitor.

Maybe this feud goes way back, but you're not taking the moral high ground by calling them liars and cheats.

Re:Ogg objections by DarkShikari on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @02:00PM (#1164804)
Wasn't that PSNR comparison problem because of an ffmpeg bug?

It was because of two bugs: an ffmpeg bug (signalling chroma positions wrong) and a bug in their testing tool (which resampled the image, something that a PSNR tester should never do for any reason).

You're clearly wrong if you're implying they didn't retract that claim, as they do so here, in an update to the original page:

Interesting, last time I looked they hadn't, but that's quite welcome then. But of course this pattern has repeated itself a dozen times already.

Re:Ogg objections by aw3c2 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @03:05PM (#1164992)
That page was last updated about 6 months ago.
Re:Ogg objections by youngian on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @11:57AM (#1164504)
This is something that OSS folks in general need to work on. People forget that tone does matter. Speaking your mind is good, but speaking your mind in a caustic fashion doesn't help your cause. Especially when the issue is a complex domain-specific one (like the convoluted world of AV containers and codecs), and the vast majority of people are not going to understand the fine technical nuances of your argument.
Re:Ogg objections by madair on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:52AM (#1164327)
Are you going to bother responding to the specific points, or just the personal attack?
Re:Ogg objections by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @11:02AM (#1164350)
I assume your reply and my edit overlapped, but the link contains the other side of the argument.

Besides that, as I'm not really qualified to comment on the technical arguments, the way they are presented heavily influences my evaluation. On that metric alone ffmpeg is losing this argument badly. If they really care that much (and it appears they really, really do) then they'd do well to take that criticism on board.

Re:Ogg objections by madair on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @02:47PM (#1164941)
Yes, it must have overlapped. (I can't edit my previous comment anymore to recognize that, or I would :)