News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by vaporstun on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @09:18AM (#1164110)
I wish more people would read the actual patent claims before coming to conclusions about them based solely on their titles. It seems that many news organizations have articles claiming this is a ridiculous lawsuit based on the titles which they claim are overly broad. If however they took the time to read the patent claims, they would see that they are relatively specific. For example: http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=L-IeAAAAEBAJ&dq=5...

Now I'm not saying that software patents are necessarily right, but I am growing weary of people making broad generalizations based on the titles of these patents and having them perpetuated. That is somewhat like a book review discussing the book's title and deciding whether or not it's a good book without having read the book or having any knowledge of its contents.

In other words, leave it to the lawyers. If you went to LN (Lawyer News - doesn't exist, but let's pretend for my analogy) and there was a lawyer claiming that Javascript is stupid because it has the word Java in it and therefore must have all the attributes of Java and he hates Java, we'd all cringe at his lack of knowledge of the subject and wish he'd leave it up to the Hackers who actually know what they're talking about to criticize.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by sern on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @09:39AM (#1164151)
That patent is on NeXTSTEP's NSDistributedNotificationCenter [1], which admittedly might actually be enforceable (I'm not sure of any prior art in this regard).

That said, after reading the claims of a lot of the other patents Apple is citing it is apparent that they are complete rubbish, for example [2] (the observer pattern applied to a desktop environment), [3] (generic proxy objects for IPC/RPC - Smalltalk/CORBA did it), and [4] (WTF???????).

1. http://developer.apple.com/mac/library/documentation/Cocoa/C...

2. http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=zIwLAAAAEBAJ

3. http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=7d4aAAAAEBAJ

4. http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=HrobAAAAEBAJ

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by protomyth on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @12:17PM (#1164554)
When you say "rubish", are you going off the description or the actual patent claim? Descriptions are always written in broad strokes and never really seem enforceable.
Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by markkanof on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @09:50AM (#1164177)
Sure, broad generalizations are always a problem, but in this particular case I'm not sure that it matters. The patent description that you linked to doesn't really seem specific enough to make it unique. It seems to be talking about eventing systems in an operating system (as opposed to a language). The idea that there isn't prior art seems dubious.

Also, I think leaving it to the lawyers is part of what got us into this situation in the first place. We have a bunch of lawyers and patent clerks that don't understand the technology so we end up with a lot of silly patents that shouldn't exist.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by roc on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:27AM (#1164259)
Your general point is extremely important and deserves to be underlined in every patent discussion: summaries and abstracts are irrelevant. The patent is the claims.

However, in this case, some of these patents are still quite broad. Almost offensively so.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by jhancock on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @02:51PM (#1164956)
I have just read the claims of the patent you linked. The first 3 claims [1] describe events (basic MVC stuff) as has been used in the wild since at least 1979!!!

The patent has a filing date of May 13, 1994. I had written Smalltalk code in use at Fortune 100 clients using these very same techniques for several years prior to this filing date. At the time, I was clear I did not invent these techniques.

Its my understanding there are penalties for an inventor listed in a patent fraudulently claiming they created the invention. Perhaps its time we started enforcing these penalties. I find it impossible to believe that any engineer at Next or Apple did not understand they were not the original inventor of what is claimed in this patent.

[1] first 3 claims from http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=L-IeAAAAEBAJ&dq=5...

1. In a computer including at least one event producer for detecting that an event has occurred in the computer and generating an event and at least one event consumer which needs to be informed when events occur in the computer, a system for distributing events comprising:

storing means for storing a specific set of events of which said at least one event consumer is to be informed; event manager control means for receiving the event from the event producer, comparing the received event to the stored set of events, and distributing an appropriate event to an appropriate event consumer; and distributor means for receiving the event from the control means and directing said control means to distribute an appropriate event to an appropriate event consumer. 2. The system according to claim 1, wherein said distributor means comprises a distributor module for each kind of event possible in the computer.

3. The system according to claim 1, wherein a plurality of event consumers are included in the computer and the plurality of consumers comprise:

broadcast consumers having no relationship with other consumers, the broadcast consumers operating independently of other consumers and of the order in which consumers are informed of the event; and sequential consumers having relationships with other consumers, the sequential consumers requiring that no other consumer be told about an event while they themselves are processing the event and having an ability to influence when they receive the event relative to the other consumers.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by GHFigs on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @03:41PM (#1165094)
The first three claims are establishing the basis for claims 4 through 9. Likewise claims 11 through 17 depend on claim 10 and claims 19 through 24 depend on claim 18. Though they are written linearly, patents have a hierarchical structure.

What you appear to be doing is mistaking each claim for an independent claim of invention, which is a common mistake, but a mistake nonetheless. When the claim says "the system according to claim x", it is growing more specific as to what is actually being claimed as the invention. With that in mind it is not surprising that the independent claims (1, 10, 18) would not be novel. You have to read as far as the tail end of each thread to understand what is actually being claimed as the invention.

I can't speak to the content of this patent when read correctly, but I suggest re-examining it with this in mind.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by jhancock on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:13PM (#1165361)
Thanks for the pointers. I have written a few patents. Well, I wrote the invention part and paid supposedly good patent attorneys to clean it up and write the claims and educate me on the process.

I "thought" my lawyers told me the first few claims (1-3?) have to stand on their own and the rest can build on the invention. Meaning, if the first few are not unique inventions, the whole thing fell apart. More info would be useful.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by GHFigs on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @08:16PM (#1165782)
I wouldn't doubt your lawyers! They were probably right in a context that does not generalize exactly.

I am not a lawyer and speak from no authority but curiosity, so I could be completely wrong or misleadingly close to being right, but I think the main point is confirmed by this, from the "Claims" section of the first result for "how to read a patent" (http://www.bpmlegal.com/howtopat5.html): "Each dependent claim must be narrower than the claim upon which it depends." The full example is too long to quote, but I encourage you to read it.

The obvious problem with this is that it is an implicit convention in an otherwise very explicit kind of document. It's no wonder at all that it is not widely understood.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by raganwald on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:39AM (#1164289)
In other words, leave it to the lawyers.

Perhaps I really shouldn't discuss patents, intellectual property law, or lawsuits here. Even if I read the whole thing, I'm not a lawyer and I don't understand the specialized language being used. I don't know the specifics of the law in different jurisdictions. I really shouldn't have said anything.

What it amounts to is this: The text of an article is insufficient information for discussion, you need expertise to comment on it.

Now that I put it that way, why are any of these articles discussed here on HN? Who is actually qualified to come to conclusions or espouse an opinion about economics, politics, or law? Why do we tolerate discussion about intellectual property law, anti-terrorism laws, or economics by unqualified persons?

It's quite disturbing how little any of us know about things that affect our livelihood.

Re:Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android by ynniv on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:04AM (#1164208)
I can't upvote this enough. Making any conclusion about a patent without concentrating on the claims (at least the independent ones) is ignorant. I admit that I used to do the same, but once you understand the mechanics of a patent (just like any technical system), you are immediately put off when someone is angry over a summary.