News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by gaur on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:12PM (#11631866)
I bet if you look at polls from the 1990s about the internet, you'll find a lot of people saying they're just fine without it, thank you very much, and they prefer the warm, personal experience of calling up a real human to book their plane tickets or whatever instead of punching their credit card number into some newfangled machine.

But in the end, people went ahead and developed more and more infrastructure for the internet regardless, and now most people couldn't live without it.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by steego on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:34PM (#11632056)
You don't have to go back that far. In 2007-2008, I remember polling friends and coworkers about smart phones. Just as you suggest, most said they were fine without it and didn't want to carry around a computer.

I'd just read Kurzweil's book and I remember saying they'll probably have one by 2010-2011 because smart phones will be the free phones by then. I was right for one simple reason: Most people tend to dismiss new tech right up to when it stops becoming a luxury item. As soon as people find value in something and they can afford it, adoption is practically inevitable.

I hope my self driving car has a nice sleeper option so I can take long road trips and wake up at my destination.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by junto on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:42PM (#11632136)
And in the same vein, "who on earth is going to buy a tablet"? The iPad is going to be a dud. Nobody needs or wants tablets.

People don't know what they want, so we'll make them want it.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by steego on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @10:00PM (#11633444)
Clearly tablet sales performed better than critics expected, but they never matched the phone because owning a phone significantly diminishes the value proposition of a tablet. Sales may get better as manufacturers figure out new ways to add value for the consumer or to successfully absorb the PC market.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by fucking_tragedy on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:29PM (#11632813)
I was under the impression iPad sales were dropping.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by Normal_gaussian on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:46PM (#11632890)
You are correct [0]. For both iPad's and general tablet sales [1].

Of course this does not confirm that tablets are falling out of favour - they could simply have reached their saturation point. Does anybody know if saturation sales are expected to look like this normalish (gaussianish) graph?

[0] http://www.statista.com/statistics/269915/global-apple-ipad-...

[1] http://www.statista.com/statistics/272070/global-tablet-ship...

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by MawNicker on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:35PM (#11633118)
Yup. That looks like the first derivative of bounded growth. The integral of that graph would look like a logistic function [1]. It's often used to model population growth.

1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logistic_function

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by dpark on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:38PM (#11632855)
iPad sales may be dropping for any number of reasons. The number of tablets in the average home is climbing, regardless.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by trhway on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:19PM (#11633046)
> In 2007-2008, I remember polling friends and coworkers about smart phones. Just as you suggest, most said they were fine without it and didn't want to carry around a computer.

things changed when a computer appeared that people really liked to carry. The same wait is here - for the iPhone of autonomous cars. What right now drives around in Mountain View seems to be more like HP Treo.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by jxdjsks on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:26PM (#11633075)
You really think people will prefer driving themselves to work rather than kicking back and doing whatever they fancy on the way? Driving a long distance? Punch in the destination and get some sleep, glorious

This does not need any shiny packaging to be a no brainer. It's a drop dead delicious invention.

That some even entertain the notion that they don't want one goes to show how clueless people are. They are just saying what they think everyone else thinks, without engaging thier brain.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by duaneb on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:35PM (#11632071)
> I bet if you look at polls from the 1990s about the internet, you'll find a lot of people saying they're just fine without it, thank you very much, and they prefer the warm, personal experience of calling up a real human to book their plane tickets or whatever instead of punching their credit card number into some newfangled machine.

The enjoyment of driving is not about human warmth, it's about control and adrenaline. I don't think the comparison makes sense. I'd be more excited about autonomous cars if I could turn it off in the country (as some cars today allow) for recreation.

I definitely agree with what you're saying—I know I'm probably in the minority for enjoying driving at all—but I frankly can't imagine anyone enjoying reading their credit card over the phone.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by dsjoerg on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:51PM (#11632199)
"On average, Americans drive 29.2 miles per day, making two trips with an average total duration of 46 minutes."[1]

For how many of those 46 minutes do you think they are enjoying control and adrenaline? I would guess approximately zero, and once you tell them that they can spend that time instead surfing the internet, or eating breakfast, or videochatting with their family, they will.

[1] http://newsroom.aaa.com/2015/04/new-study-reveals-much-motor...

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by gambiting on Thursday May 05, 2016 @05:12AM (#11634761)
Personally? Probably 40 minutes out of those 46. Every acceleration is a thrill, I enjoy every second of driving.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by riprowan on Thursday May 05, 2016 @10:39AM (#11636457)
At what price?

When autonomous cars are ubiquitous, the price of insuring your thrill ride will be roughly equivalent to the hourly price of an amusement park.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by gambiting on Thursday May 05, 2016 @11:19AM (#11636854)
That's a nice guess, and I guess it's meant to scare me from driving in the future, but it won't really.

Long before "automonous cars are ubiquitous" something else is going to happen - automatic collision detection and prevention will become ubiquitous, long before all cars are fully automatic. So even if I drive the car myself, it will be very difficult to crash, therefore the insurance will have no reason to increase.

Either way, I am sure fully automatic cars won't become ubiquitous in our lifetimes no matter what manufacturers say, so I'm not too worried.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by stoozer on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:00PM (#11632277)
It's far more likely that for many people it will just mean working on your commute to work. Personally I would rather be driving.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by hexagonc on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:55PM (#11632631)
I think there's a lot of things I'd rather be doing on a commute than drive or do work. For on thing, with a self-driving car, I could do things that many people are already doing while driving, albeit unsafely. Things like eating breakfast, talking on the phone, and fiddling with the radio. Hell, if the commute was long, I might use the time to catch up on sleep.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by duaneb on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:04PM (#11632688)
You can already do this on public transit; why wait for self-driving cars?
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:23PM (#11632784)
Where does your public transit system get its funding? Does it really provide you the same level of privacy?

Any transit system I've ever used was:

Over crowded.

Purposefully designed so no-one could sleep. Also, I really wouldn't want to sleep on an artificially created publicly shared surface.

Frowned upon to talk on your cell phone, or eat a meal.

I definitely couldn't get any work done, even if I tried.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by cvwright on Thursday May 05, 2016 @01:55AM (#11634244)
I took public transit to work for three years. It had its ups and downs. Then, within the span of about a week, (a) somebody peed in their seat about 12 feet from me, and then (b) somebody threw up all over the floor about 3 feet from me. After that it was goodbye Trimet, hello Honda.

The bus is not a great place to do any of the things mentioned above.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by duaneb on Thursday May 05, 2016 @02:52AM (#11634429)
I personally love the bus, but it can vary greatly from place to place (and even from bus line to bus line).

But this is a great illustration of self-driving cars: it's public transit for the upper-middle class. (The middle class can't afford a reliable car for the whole household; the rich have chauffeurs.)

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by industriousthou on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @11:01PM (#11633728)
Yeah, I could get a solid four to five hours of sleep if I took public transit to work since it would take so long. And then the bus system in my area is shut down by the time I get out of work...

This is exactly what makes autonomous vehicles so great - they eliminate the public transportation problem.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by jdbernard on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:52PM (#11632917)
Because driving takes me 15 minutes and public transit takes an hour.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by 0xcde4c3db on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @09:20PM (#11633284)
In my city, you're lucky if public transit only takes an hour (I'm lucky, so I still ride). Also, the bike racks only take two bikes; if there are already two on there, you might as well just ride the rest of the way because your other option is to wait an hour for the next bus.

(hi; I live in a city run by "fiscal conservatives")

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by Can_Not on Thursday May 05, 2016 @08:52AM (#11635602)
Yeah, I've had several bus drivers go by the drive-through so I can get breakfast and let me fiddle the radio on behalf of all passengers while also being on the phone the whole time.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by pteredactyl on Thursday May 05, 2016 @06:00AM (#11634886)
I'd rather be on a train.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by duaneb on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:57PM (#11632253)
What part of what I said are you disagreeing with? EDIT: ...or replying to?
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by dragontamer on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:07PM (#11632312)
Obviously, whenever someone responds to you, they're ALWAYS against you. Because people never agree with you. Never ever ever in the history of communication.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by helloworld12345 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:50PM (#11632192)
I'm sure someone said the same thing about horses. They love the experience of riding a horse.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by spc476 on Thursday May 05, 2016 @01:45AM (#11634213)
The thing about a horse though, is that it knows the way home. You might think that this means you can get drunk and still have a way to "ride" home. I mean, that has to be better than driving drunk, right?

The US laws are crazy: http://duiwise.com/dui-dwi-answers/can-you-get-a-dui-dwi-on-...

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by duaneb on Thursday May 05, 2016 @03:35AM (#11634532)
There are many roads you can still ride a horse on. Will that be true with self driving cars on the road?
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by qbrass on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @11:35PM (#11633869)
If someone had invented self-driving horses, we could have skipped the whole car thing.

Is Waze for horses patentable?

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by zardo on Thursday May 05, 2016 @12:06PM (#11637279)
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by qbrass on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @11:27PM (#11633841)
>...they prefer the warm, personal experience of calling up a real human to book their plane tickets or whatever instead of punching their credit card number into some newfangled machine.

That was before they turned calling up a company into an audio version of the 90's internet.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday May 05, 2016 @11:00AM (#11636660)
For me 100% of the enjoyment of driving is from getting somewhere that I want to be. If I could get away with never touching a steering wheel again, I would.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by zyxley on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:44PM (#11632556)
> I'd be more excited about autonomous cars if I could turn it off in the country (as some cars today allow) for recreation.

Why assume that you won't be able to? Even the most elaborately "uncarlike" self-driving car concepts have a steering wheel hidden somewhere, for the simple reason that there's always the chance of some extreme conditions that a self-driving car can't navigate.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by tropo on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:29PM (#11633090)
This isn't the right way. An in-car steering wheel will always require a licensed driver. Several better ways:

1. For minor uncertainty, the car could ask what to do. For example, the user might confirm that an object blocking the road is harmless and can be run over or bumped out of the way. This is not real-time; the car only asks after it comes to a stop.

2. The above can be done by remote humans.

3. When the car is really confused, you should get power assistance while you stand outside and push. It should be possible to push the car up any San Francisco hill with just one person. Put your hands on the bumper, press hard, and the car responds to the pressure. Unlike traditional car pushing, the steering should respond. You should be able to parallel park, park on grass, force the car up onto the sidewalk a bit, go the wrong direction, and so on.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by duaneb on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @08:33PM (#11633110)
> Why assume that you won't be able to?

Because the attractive argument for driverless cars that makes sense (to me) is that they're safer than human drivers. Presumably at some point humans will not be allowed to drive anymore.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by oconnore on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:04PM (#11632682)
Honestly I would still rather call a real human to book plane tickets. In fact I would pay a premium for it.

This stopped happening because humans are expensive, not because typing numbers into a 2 inch touchscreen keyboard is actually a better experience.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by grahamburger on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:19PM (#11632760)
I'm sure you recognize this, but your opinion is far from universal. I have a few friends who share your opinion and it's certainly valid, but I have many more friends who are much happier to book a flight / pay a bill / shop for insurance etc. on a higher bandwidth medium than a phone call. (Myself included) There are still instance where the company really screws up their UX to the point where a phone call is preferable but it's becoming much less common in my experience.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by ams6110 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:24PM (#11632788)
I think what GP is referring to is calling someone and saying "book me through to San Francisco on the 20th. I need to be there by 11:00am. Bye."

That's what we mean by "calling someone to book a flight" i.e. an agent who will take your request and do the legwork. Not simply talking to someone at a call center and dictating everything you'd otherwise be typing into an online form.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by dpark on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:41PM (#11632867)
That service is available. You can get virtual assistants to do this. You can get a credit card that offers this kind of concierge service. If you claim that this is the experience you want and that you are willing to pay for it, but you're still booking your flights on Expedia, then either you're lying to yourself or you're just not willing to pay enough.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by jdbernard on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:50PM (#11632909)
I've had access to this kind of service in the past and even then often I prefer to do it online myself, especially if I'm paying for the tickets.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @07:14PM (#11632742)
You dismiss the notion that price is "part of the user experience".

If I can do something myself, in 5 mins, inconveniently, for free.

Or spend 5 mins on a phone call, waiting for a human to do the same thing, for $10.

I would call the latter a poor user experience.

Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by spacehome on Thursday May 05, 2016 @05:48AM (#11634851)
Call me. I'll book your flights for a premium.
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by antisthenes on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:28PM (#11632451)
"If you asked people what they want, they'd ask for a faster horse"
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by xkcd-sucks on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @09:08PM (#11633245)
If you asked people what they want, they'd ask for cloud-connected thermostats that fail ungracefully and stop working when their manufacturers get acquired
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by notJim on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @06:41PM (#11632533)
Re:Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous... by tpeo on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @05:46PM (#11632169)
Well, each of those things created new unforeseen problems, such as cyber-crime (and, I believe, a decline of quality in journalism). On the other hand, none of them actually presented the possibility of direct physical harm, which might occur with failure in autonomous vehicles. And which is something people are wary about.

In my own opinion, being a passenger in a self-driving vehicle wouldn't be riskier than being a passenger in a normal vehicle. On the contrary, I think it's safer. But there's the issue of how human drivers might behave or be forced to behave once self-driving cars become widespread.

What if human drivers' become more trusting of other cars' behavior and start paying less attention? Human drivers might become involved in worse crashes between themselves.

What if there's an adverse selection effect? If the public is convinced that self-driving cars are safer for individual passengers, then the most risk-averse drivers might be more likely to join in, leaving less risk-averse (and prone to accident) drivers on the road.

How would human drivers interact with platoons? What if a human driver is stuck in a suddenly decelerating platoon? Would he panic and swerve? Would he crash?

My point is that there might be all kinds of unforeseen consequences. Maybe good, maybe bad. That's reason why I'm not particularly enthusiastic about self-driving cars (or anything else for that matter): we'll only know whether it's good or bad in hindsight.