News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear NoSQL: "SQL-isn't-scalable" is a lie by rmorrison on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @09:22PM (#1163170)
I'm curious how services like Amazon's RDS will change this perception.

A SQL database may be difficult to scale, but it is something that can be largely encapsulated and outsourced. If Amazon RDS, or some other product, handles the hardware and software configuration, then the developers can just focus on the application portion of it.

This isn't to say that scalability is guaranteed, it's still important to optimize queries and the data structure. Also, there are problems where NoSQL is simply the better and/or cheaper option.

But if these services can encapsulate a lot of the difficult part of scaling SQL, it still makes SQL a very attractive and powerful option for most(?) problems.

Re:Dear NoSQL: "SQL-isn't-scalable" is a lie by wmf on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @09:36PM (#1163202)
RDS doesn't scale at all. The performance of RDS won't exceed that of MySQL running on a "Quadruple Extra Large" instance (because that's what RDS is).
Re:Dear NoSQL: "SQL-isn't-scalable" is a lie by rmorrison on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @01:17AM (#1163543)
Ok, but how about a service taking whatever scalable SQL systems the financial or pharmaceutical industry use, even Oracle, Postgres, or Microsoft SQL server, and then selling it as a service similar to RDS?

My point is, I think there is an opportunity providing enterprise-level SQL scalability on a per-use basis. It won't replace NoSQL systems, because there are some problems where they're clearly better, but it could be done and provide relatively-affordable, scalable SQL access to startups.

Re:Dear NoSQL: "SQL-isn't-scalable" is a lie by wmf on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @01:28AM (#1163559)
Enterprisey databases are just too expensive for the HN crowd; making them into a service can't fix that.

Azure might come close, but I don't know what performance it can provide.

Re:Dear NoSQL: "SQL-isn't-scalable" is a lie by gaius on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @08:45AM (#1164041)
Azure doesn't run a lot of SQL Server functionality.
Re:Dear NoSQL: "SQL-isn't-scalable" is a lie by jbellis on Tuesday March 02, 2010 @09:35PM (#1163199)
> I'm curious how services like Amazon's RDS will change this perception.

It won't. It's just hosted MySQL.