Re:TV’s Dwindling Middle Class
by untog on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:52AM
(#11620609)
I think it fell into the TV show trap of being successful and having your actors be in demand, and taking time off from the show or leaving it altogether. They likely should have ended it when Steve Carrell left.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:TV’s Dwindling Middle Class
by jonnathanson on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:35AM
(#11621548)
This.
The Office went through all of its kooky manager plotlines because Steve Carell's career trajectory outpaced the show's initial popularity. The second he got too big for the show, everyone knew it, and much ink was spilled in the writers' room trying to anticipate and/or compensate for his eventual departure.
Jim was given some upward mobility because he's the protagonist, and the audience was rooting for him (and Pam) in a personal way. Nine seasons of Jim's being stuck in a dead-end paper sales job, with no hope of escape, would have been extremely depressing. I realize that's how the UK version chose to play things, but it would have been too bleak by half for the US market.
Re:TV’s Dwindling Middle Class
by icebraining on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:34PM
(#11623537)
The UK version also only has 14 episodes in total (vs 201 in the US). Not that much time to create the feeling of being stuck.
Re:TV’s Dwindling Middle Class
by jonnathanson on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:46PM
(#11623628)
True, but the UK show goes to great lengths to make a point of its protagonists' hopelessness. The Christmas special capping Season 2 pretty explicitly implies: "Just in case you were wondering, nobody wins."