News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by blfr on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:04AM (#11619762)
You have been arguing against basic income for years now, and with some really good points[1], but I think you consistently miss the main attraction of the idea to the HN crowd.

Many here believe that if people weren't forced to work for income, they would be doing things that are more valuable but also more difficult to monetize (at least initially but perhaps generally), like open source development. There is an underlying belief that vast creative talents are untapped or wasted because of the need to work for money. It's the intellectual's dream lifestyle. One that used to be possible for writers and academics.

Other reasons are largely an afterthought. That's why basic job for example is not a convincing counterargument despite the numbers. This is not really about helping the poor, that would be an auxiliary benefit at best.

[1] https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/basic_income_vs_basi...

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by robk on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:11AM (#11619814)
Why would anyone clean toilets when they could write/paint/sleep all day?
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by lazypenguin on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:37AM (#11619991)
Because you don't really need a creative outlet, the toilet cleaning job now pays double what it used to and combined with your UBI you can save enough money every few weeks to hit up Vegas, buy a new sports car or fund your wild consumption.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by fucking_tragedy on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:14AM (#11620281)
Because doing those activities in what is still poverty isn't fun or fulfilling.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by Guvante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:06PM (#11623330)
It depends on what it pays, remember even though your basic needs are met that doesn't mean you have zero aspirations.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by gnaritas on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:43AM (#11626635)
You're basically asking why would anyone want to make more than the minimum; if you think about that for 10 seconds, the answer would be obvious to you.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:13AM (#11619834)
Can you do a back of the envelope calculation to figure out how large those "more valuable but also more difficult to monetize" effects would be?

As I noted in the blog post you cited, most of this discussion is just meaningless verbiage. No one even attempts to quantify the the effects they claim are so important. (In the HN comments on that post, many people suggested such effects; the minute you crunch numbers they turn out to be tiny.)

It's the intellectual's dream lifestyle. One that used to be possible for writers and academics.

It still is possible - go live in a rural area, consume very little, and survive with bad internet (still vastly better than the no internet of previous eras). People just don't like to do it because of the low status it entails, and because they've grown used to modern consumption that they'd need to give up.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by blfr on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:28AM (#11619933)
No one even attempts to quantify the the effects they claim are so important.

Perhaps I didn't phrase that strongly enough but growing the economy or making it more efficient is not the point. It's at most a rationalization.

go live in a rural area, consume very little, and survive with bad internet

That's not a realistic advice. It's extremely difficult, puts having a family largely out of reach, and places you away from potential collaborators. Even Joey Hess[1][2] has to resort to crowd funding and grants.

[1] https://joeyh.name/

[2] https://usesthis.com/interviews/joey.hess/

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:44AM (#11620051)
That's not "realistic advice", but that's what people did back in the day.

Also, the only reason it "puts having a family largely out of reach" is due to women's sexual choices - most women prefer a man who lives a higher status lifestyle. Sorry, but you aren't entitled to a wife; if women prefer a different lifestyle, that's their choice.

And again, what fraction of people who stop working in the for-profit economy will actually be as productive as Joey Hess?

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by blfr on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:05AM (#11620214)
No, that's not what people did back in the day. Those who managed lived off advances from their publishers, inheritance, sponsors, or Church sinecures. It's not possible nowadays. You need to promote your works and it became much less socially acceptable.

It's a weird observation that going off the grid would price you out of the dating market. Plenty of "starving artists" and outright bums have more success with women than salarymen.

And again, what fraction of people who stop working in the for-profit economy will actually be as productive as Joey Hess?

That's the direct counterargument to most BI hopes. Of course, it's very difficult to verify empirically and mostly depends on what you already believe about human nature. We don't even know if Joey Hess is more or less productive than he would be otherwise.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by ticviking on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:11PM (#11623808)
Have you ever lived out west?

It's literally how it was done. Go west, steal some land from whatever non-white people are there. Have many babies and bootstrap civilization on the empty land.

yummyfajita's is missing that this isn't possible now because we're out of land to steal, and the state gets pissy about building a log cabin in national forest service land.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by lmm on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:40AM (#11620011)
Non-empirically-validated numbers obscure a lot more than they clarify. The scarmig comment you link to shows that almost all of the effects you included were irrelevant and this whole exercise was worse than useless. Using this much precision at this level of accuracy can only ever mislead.
Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:54AM (#11620142)
It's not about precision, it's about knowing if we are even in the ballpark. And it's an incredibly valuable exercise.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_problem

It's also about knowing what facts need to be true for a BI to work. Then we know what facts we need to verify to determine if it's true, in contrast to all the meaningless verbiage in this thread.

Also, Scarmig's comment was quite valuable. It showed exactly what the driving effect is - that's precisely why you should do a back of the envelope calculation. And as all the non-quantitative comments show, it's also why any comments suggesting an effect but not doing such a calculation are worse than useless.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by lmm on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:18AM (#11620309)
> Also, Scarmig's comment was quite valuable. It showed exactly what the driving effect is - that's precisely why you should do a back of the envelope calculation.

And the driving effect turned out to be a disputed premise that we already knew about from our directional, non-quantitative discussions. The quantitative side is just a meaningless overcomplication (the monte carlo part especially), especially when none of the parameters was empirically validated. You wouldn't value a company you were thinking about investing in that way.

A quantitative examination would be valuable if we agreed on the premises, or if we disagreed on conclusions but weren't sure where the disagreement on premises that was driving this was. Neither of these scenarios is the case for basic income. We know what the questions under dispute are; it's time for empirical experiments.

Re:A Basic Income Should Be the Next Big Thing by yummyfajitas on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:34AM (#11620457)
You wouldn't value a company you were thinking about investing in that way.

That's exactly how you value an early stage company - back of the envelope calculations and monte carlo.