News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by coldtea on Sunday May 01, 2016 @05:20PM (#11607902)
>The world population at 500BCE is estimated to have been 100 million; in the year 2000, it was 6.1 billion, over sixty times greater. Thus if we randomly selected people from those born since the ‘start’ of western philosophy, they would generally be born close to the present day. Yet when it comes to ‘greatest philosophers’, they were generally born much further in the past than one would expect by chance.

That's why those older philosophers were great thinkers.

Because at those times, while they could be off in physical sciences (although they made great headstarts into that too), at least they didn't trivialize their thinking with such crude quantity based analysis...

He also says "it is difficult to think of many factors which favor Plato’s time versus our own", when even in what he counts, the fact for example that the quantity of the work might not merely a factor of population, but depend on things such as a society (and an era) encouraging such inquiry from individuals, or even giving them the necessary leisure to pursuit it, doesn't seem to cross his mind.

Of course there are a lot more possible explanations (including the combination of all of them) that the three lame ones given, starting with some simple ones:

(1) The modern era has less individuals with the leisure time required for philosophy.

(2) Even for those with leisure, there are too many distractions in the modern era.

(3) Philosophy getting out of of favor in certain eras, including ours. Even in a place such as France, it was much more favorable (in vogue) to being a philosopher in the early-mid 20th century than it has been after the nineties.

(4) He conveniently forgets the whole backslash against philosophy in favor of theology that last most of the 3 to 15th century.

(5) There's the "low hanging fruit" thing, in which, the most basic and core inquiries are made by the first (or near) that examine a given field, and the rest are just "footnotes to Plato" (as Whitehead IIRC put it). That's not 100% accurate, of close, but it's close to what happened.

(6) Philosophy, like poetry, does not sell. And the modern era is all about selling stuff and making a profession out of everything. Modern "philosophers" are academic careerists with a degree in philosophy.

And lots of others beside.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by mannykannot on Sunday May 01, 2016 @07:51PM (#11608408)
The author does make the low hanging fruit point, and he does offer justifications for his view of the opportunity issue that, FWIW, I find plausible. I am inclined to believe that in the past, the distractions of scratching a living diminished many peoples' time for musing, especially those who were slaves. The two-day weekend is a modern development.

I don't think you are being entirely consistent when you say both that the modern era has fewer individuals with the leisure time for philosophy, and that modern philosophers are academic careerists: the modern opportunity provided by academic careers seems to have benefitted science, for example, by giving a lot of time to people who would otherwise never have the leisure for it.

While enumerating those times when philosophy has been out of favor, the execution of Socrates comes to mind, as do the events that forced Aristotle to flee Athens.

I think your point 4 is insightful. From that era, only Aquinas makes the cut. That time, however, belongs to the 'then', rather than the 'now' of vastly larger population. Also, the theological backlash occurred primarily or only in christian Europe and the Levant, which points to another bias in this list...

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by coldtea on Sunday May 01, 2016 @11:59PM (#11609132)
Academic philosophy is more preoccupied with forwarding a career, and is tied to too much peer-group-think, paper-publishing rituals and formalities to be as potent as independent philosophy. It's not really the province of the independent thinker -- which, historically, is what most major philosophers have been.

For science, this scheme works, because science is a collaborative effort (so more working on the same thing, the better), and it also has practical results which are pursued and compensated because they can be worth millions and billions.

Whereas a philosophical grant can be given equally well to a great pioneering work or to some tired derivative mumbling, and it's even more convenient to give grants to the latter, as those who write those works don't make waves and keep everybody happy.

>* While enumerating those times when philosophy has been out of favor, the execution of Socrates comes to mind, as do the events that forced Aristotle to flee Athens.*

I'd say that those were rather philosophers that went out of favor (as opposed to philosophy, which the polis valued still).

That is, it wasn't some widespread disinterest in philosophy, nor a widespread persecution of philosophers -- numerous others carried over at the same time Socrates was executed, including Socrates own student, Plato (and Xenophon), and later Plato's students, including Aristotle.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by skissane on Sunday May 01, 2016 @10:31PM (#11608896)
(4) isn't really true. Mediaevals saw philosophy and theology as distinct (yet intertwined) disciplines, and had great respect for philosophy. Look at how much respect Thomas Aquinas had for Aristotle. Aquinas was also heavily influenced by Averroes and Maimonides. And surely the list of significant mediaeval philosophers is longer than that – what about nominalists such as Wiliam of Ockham?
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by coldtea on Sunday May 01, 2016 @11:48PM (#11609100)
>Look at how much respect Thomas Aquinas had for Aristotle. Aquinas was also heavily influenced by Averroes and Maimonides. And surely the list of significant mediaeval philosophers is longer than that – what about nominalists such as Wiliam of Ockham?

There were exceptions to the rule, but the rule was that theology ruled the day. William of Ockham was a theologian himself (and not a "top" philosopher anyway).

Regarding the respect for Aristotle by a large number of medieval philosophers, too much of it was another thing that held philosophy back at the time -- scholasticism didn't move the field as forward as it was moving in ancient Greek centuries.