Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great?
by coldtea on Sunday May 01, 2016 @11:59PM
(#11609132)
Academic philosophy is more preoccupied with forwarding a career, and is tied to too much peer-group-think, paper-publishing rituals and formalities to be as potent as independent philosophy. It's not really the province of the independent thinker -- which, historically, is what most major philosophers have been.
For science, this scheme works, because science is a collaborative effort (so more working on the same thing, the better), and it also has practical results which are pursued and compensated because they can be worth millions and billions.
Whereas a philosophical grant can be given equally well to a great pioneering work or to some tired derivative mumbling, and it's even more convenient to give grants to the latter, as those who write those works don't make waves and keep everybody happy.
>* While enumerating those times when philosophy has been out of favor, the execution of Socrates comes to mind, as do the events that forced Aristotle to flee Athens.*
I'd say that those were rather philosophers that went out of favor (as opposed to philosophy, which the polis valued still).
That is, it wasn't some widespread disinterest in philosophy, nor a widespread persecution of philosophers -- numerous others carried over at the same time Socrates was executed, including Socrates own student, Plato (and Xenophon), and later Plato's students, including Aristotle.
For science, this scheme works, because science is a collaborative effort (so more working on the same thing, the better), and it also has practical results which are pursued and compensated because they can be worth millions and billions.
Whereas a philosophical grant can be given equally well to a great pioneering work or to some tired derivative mumbling, and it's even more convenient to give grants to the latter, as those who write those works don't make waves and keep everybody happy.
>* While enumerating those times when philosophy has been out of favor, the execution of Socrates comes to mind, as do the events that forced Aristotle to flee Athens.*
I'd say that those were rather philosophers that went out of favor (as opposed to philosophy, which the polis valued still).
That is, it wasn't some widespread disinterest in philosophy, nor a widespread persecution of philosophers -- numerous others carried over at the same time Socrates was executed, including Socrates own student, Plato (and Xenophon), and later Plato's students, including Aristotle.