News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by andkon on Sunday May 01, 2016 @04:25PM (#11607712)
Honestly, I don't think this is the right path for inquiry. Philosophy isn't just the accumulation of arguments and scholarship; it's a discipline, and by that measure, some folks are better or worse, absolutely.

When it comes to Plato specifically, I did a lot of pre-Socratic and later Plato work in my philosophy degree, and you can basically watch Plato go from reiterating Socrates to becoming a truly great philosopher in his own right. He does it by learning, as we all must, to do good philosophy: to take seriously his forebears on their own terms, and then communicate carefully and thoroughly what's inadequate.

It's funny, because the tools he has are very weak. Logic isn't well developed; they just started grappling with basic concepts like what-is and what-is-not. But eventually, as any truly great philosopher must, Plato builds out his own positive program. The Parmenides is a great example; he finds a way to reconcile the paradoxes the pre-Socratics were obsessed with, and comes out with a richer toolkit and a stronger ontology as a result. Oh, and it's just as rigorous as any modern work of philosophy.

This article, though, seems kinda narrowly concerned about impact and exposure and all that stuff. Like in tech, you don't get to decide your impact, but you can become a really great philosopher by doing just what Plato did back then.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by n0us on Sunday May 01, 2016 @04:37PM (#11607755)
Completely agree on the early/late Plato stuff. I took a Nietzsche class during my degree. Although he has a reputation as a cliche/hipster philosopher it's really interesting to read his early, middle, and late works just to see the evolution of his thinking. Personally I am more a fan of his earlier stuff, particularly Birth of Tragedy.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by slantaclaus on Sunday May 01, 2016 @05:11PM (#11607881)
Nietzsche is a very, very notable member of a category of philosophers I've come up with called "atheist sons of ministers"
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by Bluestrike2 on Sunday May 01, 2016 @05:51PM (#11608022)
Generally speaking, I don't think he has that sort of reputation. Some of the people who fetishize quotes ripped from his work certainly do, but that's confusing the follower with the author. In his own words, he bade his readers to "learn to read me well!" The people you're thinking of largely never bothered to read him, let alone read him well:

> Nowadays it is not only my habit, it is also to my taste—a malicious taste, perhaps?—no longer to write anything which does not reduce to despair every sort of man who is “in a hurry.” For philology is that venerable art which demands of its votaries one thing above all: to go aside, to take time, to become still, to become slow—it is a goldsmith’s art and connoisseurship of the word which has nothing but delicate, cautious work to do and achieves nothing if it does not achieve it lento. But for precisely this reason it is more necessary than ever today, by precisely this means does it entice and enchant us the most, in the midst of an age of “work,” that is to say, of hurry, of indecent and perspiring haste, which wants to “get everything done” at once, including every old or new book: this art does not so easily get anything done, it teaches to read well, that is to say, to read slowly, deeply, looking cautiously before and aft, with reservations, with doors left open, with delicate eyes and fingers . . . My patient friends, this book desires for itself only perfect readers and philologists: learn to read me well!

But his reputation was battered for years after his death through no fault of his own. That's nothing new. More than anyone, his proto-Nazi horror of a sister can be blamed for that: she ripped through his writings like a whirlwind, editing and rewriting them to support her own anti-semitism and political beliefs. His work was twisted for a purpose that he abhorred, and railed against in his later life. But that's what Nazis ideologues did: by manipulating the works of others, they were able to use them to give themselves a degree of falsified credibility they never would have had otherwise. With Nietzsche dead, it wasn't like he was going to challenge them on it.

Had he survived longer, there is no doubt that he would have used his every breath to fight against the sickening ideology that arose in Germany and its deliberate manipulations of his work to lend their beliefs credibility. Given the regime that was to come, that would have meant a bullet in the head. But for Nietzsche, that wouldn't have been stopped him from standing the "anti-Semitic canaille." In The Gay Science, he posits a demon who declares "[t]his life as you now live it and have lived it, you will have to live once more and innumerable times more." A paralyzing, heavy burden, his idea of the eternal return would require no less for him. In Ecce Homo, he states that his "formula for greatness in a human being is amor fati: that one wants nothing to be different, not forward, not backward, not in all eternity. Not merely bear what is necessary, still less conceal it—all idealism is mendacity in the face of what is necessary—but love it." Amor fati.

In any case, it took decades to repair his reputation. There's a certain popularity to Nietzsche quotes online--what you call the hipster readings--but I think that's largely because Nietzsche's work is life-affirming. There's something incredibly appealing in the challenge that's implicit to his eternal return: to live a good life, one that you would be content to re-live throughout eternity.

Most of the people who blindly quote Nietzsche haven't really engaged his work, but even from that disability, I think it can be argued that they glimpse something appealing to them. Thus the popularity of those tiny quotations. Not to mention that much of his writing style lends itself well to that, even though he'd be apoplectic at the idea of it. One of my favorite professors was Patrick Miller, whose work on Nietzsche really opened a door that I'd left closed for many of the same reasons that most ignore or reject Nietzsche.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by igravious on Sunday May 01, 2016 @06:54PM (#11608217)
I both agree and disagree.

Philosophy _is_ a disciple, but it is an unusual one in that the answers to philosophical questions contain the seeds of other disciplines. It is kind of a meta-discipline.

Like any other human practice some are better at it and some are worse, agreed.

Logic is no more central to philosophy than it is to any other human activity. What is central to philosophy is _abstraction_. From that vantage point it more closely resembles software engineering than any other human activity and, I would argue, and this distinction is going to blur over time as the use of computers becomes habitual, as it must, within the activity of philosophy.

I think the counter-argument to this article is -- these great philosophers must be in our midst so why is it that we do not recognise them? That is the question that should have been asked. But to finish with a bit of snark, apologies in advance, the ability to ask that question takes a certain philosophical mindset.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by omaranto on Sunday May 01, 2016 @10:39PM (#11608918)
> What is central to philosophy is _abstraction_. From that vantage point it more closely resembles software engineering than any other human activity...

That probably made a bunch of mathematicians smile.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by kijin on Sunday May 01, 2016 @11:10PM (#11609018)
One might say that mathematics is almost pure abstraction, whereas philosophy has a much greater emphasis on going back and forth between abstractions and the real world to fit them together.

Ethics and political philosophy have contributed to wars and revolutions, and in turn were shaped by them. Epistemology and metaphysics similarly influenced, and were influenced by, the cultural milieu of their times. A philosophical theory that does not respond to the very real needs and sentiments of its listeners is unlikely to gain acceptance at that time, no matter how elegant or self-consistent it might be.

Likewise, in software engineering, you usually don't abstract away in a vacuum. The relationship between entities in your CRUD app must have at least some semblance of the actual things they represent, or your app will become a UX nightmare.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by woodman on Sunday May 01, 2016 @07:08PM (#11608249)
> Logic is no more central to philosophy than...

I filled my mandatory philosophy credit hours many years ago, so this might be a very silly question: what happens when a product of philosophy can be demonstrated to logically not follow? It was my impression that such a product would be discarded, making logic extremely important in philosophy - unlike, unfortunately, many other human endeavors.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by igravious on Sunday May 01, 2016 @07:47PM (#11608391)
Good point.

I see it this way. Logic is a method. It is one of the ways _how_ philosophy does what it does. (You could argue it is the only way, and many would not disagree with you.) However, consider what other disciplines do not require logically coherent inferences. Most, no? Art is one of the few which does not. Therefore logic is not central to philosophy because it is central to practically all disciplines! What is central to philosophy is, as I said, _abstraction_. The willingness to go meta-, to stand back from what you're looking at and questions the conditions of its possibilities. Do you see where I'm coming from? To make a stronger point, and to not at the same time denigrate your position, philosophers go astray when they focus on logic. :)

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by woodman on Sunday May 01, 2016 @08:16PM (#11608498)
I see, I think we are pretty close to the point of debating how true a truth is. I think the real difference between the disciplines, in the application of logic, is highlighted by your use of "coherent". While an engineer will work mostly to build upon a set of precepts, philosophy is charged with the responsibility of deconstruction. Of the two, who is spending time wondering about the abstract concept of the number one? I think that focus on local coherence is what led philosophers in the dark ages to debate whether Adam had a navel, as the premise was left unchecked. So I'd say that philosophers go astray when they do not focus on logic.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by Retric on Sunday May 01, 2016 @09:47PM (#11608753)
Logic has little value in philosophy because the terms have no specific inherent meaning. The solution seems to be to fix specific meaning to terms, but your stuck using meaningless terms to do so. Queue a recursive waste of time.

Though people are used to ambiguity and love extracting meaning from arbitrary stories, so it's not all that obvious of an issue. At its core philosophy is not about extracting meaning through analysis it's about conveying what someone has already desided to be true.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by woodman on Sunday May 01, 2016 @10:31PM (#11608895)
> ...it's about conveying what someone has already desided to be true.

I think the field strives for a little more than that, at the very least discussion is preferred to rote learning. Logic provides a common language for that discussion.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by jwatte on Sunday May 01, 2016 @11:54PM (#11609117)
Why do you think logic is taught as part of the philosophy department in US universities, not the math or comp sci department?

Personally, I think the means of abstraction and logical reasoning we take for granted today are the direct result of thousands of years of philosophy!

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by Retric on Monday May 02, 2016 @10:18AM (#11611542)
A) Depends on the school. But, it is commonly set up this way so people can satisfy general ED requirements without 'wasting' a class. If you read through this list there are logic class from several departments. (Mathematics, Computer Science, and Philosophy) http://logic.harvard.edu/courses.php

B) Randomly trying things for thousands of years is likely to produce some interesting results. That does not mean doing so is a good idea.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by 78666cdc on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:13AM (#11609161)
Logic is taught exactly in mathematics and computer science programs as a mandatory topic. Philosophy programs place far less emphasis, often providing it only as an elective.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by mathattack on Sunday May 01, 2016 @07:11PM (#11608261)
To your point of meta-fields, many of the smartest people I've known across many fields are Philosophy and X, with X being Physics, Economics, Political Science and Computer Science amongst others.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by igravious on Sunday May 01, 2016 @07:51PM (#11608406)
I think this is very perceptive of you. Could you name one or two? I think that if you could these people would provide a counter-argument to this article.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by mathattack on Monday May 02, 2016 @02:56PM (#11614373)
Thanks! I don't want to name personal friends publicly without asking first.

In terms of public figures, I enjoyed a Ted Talk from Janna Levin who holds a Philosophy concentration amongst her physics credentials. I believe that Paul Graham may have been a philosophy major too.

[0] https://www.ted.com/speakers/janna_levin

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by personjerry on Sunday May 01, 2016 @07:04PM (#11608242)
Because most forms of media we have emphasize day-to-day thoughts and useless information, rather than act as a forum for discussion with likeminded people.
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by igravious on Sunday May 01, 2016 @07:53PM (#11608413)
That was more cynical than what I was aiming for :) What is the alternative would you say?
Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by personjerry on Monday May 02, 2016 @07:05AM (#11610470)
I think we just need something like a platform where the goal isn't to just "add everyone you know " and "share everything you do". Something like a social blogging site where you only write thoughts of decent quality and only add people you actually tend to talk to? I'd say maybe something like Tumblr, but Tumblr users just seem to emulate Facebook using Tumblr.

Also, the above ideals make the platform difficult for any investor to support, because it is in contrast to the normal "grow!!!!!!!" direction that most startups want to take.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by ktRolster on Monday May 02, 2016 @03:07AM (#11609626)
What is the alternative would you say?

Hacker news, of course :)

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by maxerickson on Sunday May 01, 2016 @05:20PM (#11607901)
A high school class might do better avoiding working from a historical survey.

I think an interesting way to structure a book would be a moderate sized section on ideas and then a larger accompanying manual explaining where the ideas come from.

It would certainly be weird to study in the way you speak of while ignoring history.

Re:Are History’s “Greatest Philosophers” All That Great? by joe_the_user on Monday May 02, 2016 @12:15AM (#11609167)
Philosophy isn't just the accumulation of arguments and scholarship; it's a discipline, and by that measure, some folks are better or worse, absolutely.

I'd say philosophy is more than either an accumulation of argument or discipline. It something like a dialogue with history.

The rightness or wrongness of Marx, Nietzsche, Wittgenstein, Popper or similar figures is still "in play" given that the development of our society is far from over.

One can say a given philosopher is a great exemplar of a given historical current (capitalism, socialism, Christianity, etc) but absolute greatness is going to depend on the fate of that current.