News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by Scramblejams on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:04PM (#11597523)
FWIW, my experience disagrees with this. I was overweight, started running (starting around 9mi/wk, when I got bored and stopped I was up around 24mi/wk), and started losing weight quickly, lost a ton of it over a year, after which I was at a very good weight for me. Now, as the piece touches on, that exercise did change my eating, but the outcome of that isn't clear to me -- I stopped eating/snacking for a few hours before a run so I wouldn't cramp. But I also started eating a lot more outside of those exercise windows, as running so much made me quite ravenous at times. Ate anything and everything I wanted and I just kept dropping weight as long as I kept running.

Haven't looked at the data cited in the article, but my guess is that these studies are looking mostly at what's often defined as "moderate" exercisers, that is, people who walk an hour every day or something similarly unintensive. Which is vastly better than nothing, but it isn't exactly a hard workout like what I was engaging in, and I wouldn't expect to drop much weight if that's all I was doing.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by fattylite on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:57PM (#11597931)
It's just a bad title. The title should have been "Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight without changing your diet". If you eat the same amount as you did before, assuming that was maintenance calories, you will lose weight if you begin exercising. The problem is when you're intaking 1500 more calories than necessary before you start exercising. You can't burn that off to the point of a deficit with exercise alone.
Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by curun1r on Friday April 29, 2016 @04:00PM (#11598351)
The problem with your line of reasoning is the counterintuitive results mentioned in the article that came from examining primitive cultures that lead a much more active lifestyle. Despite engaging in activities that were far more active, they didn't burn more calories.

This is one of the many problems with the calorie in, calorie out line of reasoning that seeks to treat the human body like an automobile that uses fuel solely based on pressing the accelerator. What we're finding is that this isn't the case. For one, the body isn't 100% efficient, so a lot of calories in are lost in ways that aren't "burned." It's also likely that the body of a sedentary person is burning calories fairly inefficiently, so a change to being more active without altering diet will just cause that body to be more efficient in how it burns calories rather that burning fat or muscle reserves.

Calories in, calories out is an attractive concept, especially to scientifically-minded people who love the simplicity of deriving the answer by applying a fundamental law of thermodynamics. But the more we dig into the subject, the more we're realizing that it's a wrong-headed approach. The body is much more complex than that. We need a much more nuanced approach to nutrition, though "carbs are bad" seems to be a pretty good approximation of it.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by Scramblejams on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:31PM (#11598172)
Except I didn't eat the same as before. I ate more, way, way more.
Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by dpark on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:52PM (#11599512)
I bet you didn't, and this is the problem with anecdotal evidence. People are terrible at tracking their actual caloric intake and expenditures.

24 miles a week is a decent bit, but it isn't that much. If you add 24 miles a week but eat a lot more, you will gain weight.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by Scramblejams on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @11:22AM (#11621432)
No, it's not that much. But they were very high intensity miles. My typical routine was to do a half mile walking warmup, then over the course of 5-8 minutes of running, gradually adjust my pace so my breathing was very close to my sustainable max. Then I'd continue adjusting my speed to keep my breathing there for the rest of the run. (All those running guides that say you should be able to carry on a conversation while you're running? Yeah, that wasn't me at all. I was huffing and puffing like mad the entire time.) I accumulated that mileage over 3 runs/week, no more than one hour total each time, so that distance was done in a 3 hour period.

And about the food? Umm, it wasn't even close. Before the running, my idea of a snack was a little piece of cheese or a yogurt. After I started running, a snack was a Carl's Jr. Famous Star cheeseburger. Sometimes I'd order two. I became notable among my football player brothers-in-law for my capacity, regularly demonstrated, for out-eating them. My wife still talks about a particularly memorable restaurant visit where I basically ate 3 large, complete entrees. My calorie intake was ridiiiiiculous. Eating like that was both enjoyable and entertaining, and it didn't seem to interfere with my fitness, so I did it all the time.

And still I lost weight. Crazy. The body is a strange machine.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by pjlegato on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:59PM (#11597943)
I'd bet there is some exercise intensity threshold step function at work.

The article says exercise is, "only around 10 to 30 percent [of total energy expenditure] depending on the person (and excluding professional athletes that workout as a job)," implying that when you are doing lots and lots of hardcore exercise almost every day, it will use up a greater percentage of calories.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by Scramblejams on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:23PM (#11598119)
Yeah, I've wondered the same.

I recall another study -- no idea where I'd find it now -- which did body scans of runners. They found that runners which averaged 11mi/wk had substantial interior fat deposits. Runners that averaged 17mi/wk had very little.

Actually, did a bit of Googling, looks like it might have been a study by Dr. Uwe Schütz published in 2009, found a mention of it here: http://www.runnersworld.co.uk/weight-loss/running-the-life-s...

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by jacorreia on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:54PM (#11597905)
It's literally just calories in vs. calories out. If 400 calories/day meets your weight loss goals, all you have to do is make sure that the calories you expend + the calories you no longer intake = 400. The ratio of those two factors completely varies from person to person on what their motivation levels are going to be, but as long as it works for you it will result in the same amount of weight loss as any other ratio
Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by pjlegato on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:01PM (#11597961)
The whole point of the article is that the traditional "calories in/calories out" model is wrong.

"Based on the research, Pontzer has proposed a new model that upends the the old "calories in, calories out" approach to exercise... He calls this the "constrained model" of energy expenditure, which shows that the effect of more physical activity on the human body is not linear."

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by jacorreia on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:11PM (#11598041)
Followed by a paragraph describing that it's just a hypothesis and they'll have to reconcile with studies that show that you burn more energy with exercise. I didn't say that doing 400 calories of exercise in a day was easy, or that it wouldn't make you way more hungry and prone to eating more, which are the main points of this article.

That's why I said that you have to find some compromise that works for yourself, I didn't say where that balance lay for most people.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by yummyfajitas on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:23PM (#11598122)
The constrained model doesn't contradict cals in/cals out. All it says that the calories out will be sublinear in the amount of exercise added.

Furthermore, the graph of energy expenditure over time (in section 10) directly agrees with what calories in/calories out predicts. See, for example, how perfectly the "very low calorie diet" agrees with the exponential decay predicted by theory.

https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2011/weight_stability.htm...

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by fattylite on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:07PM (#11598002)
The conclusion is:

"10) So what actually works for weight loss?

At the individual level, some very good research on what works for weight loss comes from the National Weight Control Registry, a study that has parsed the traits, habits, and behaviors of adults who have lost at least 30 pounds and kept it off for a minimum of one year. They currently have more than 10,000 members enrolled in the study, and these folks respond to annual questionnaires about how they've managed to keep their weight down.

The researchers behind the study found that people who have had success losing weight share a few things in common: They weigh themselves at least once a week. They restrict their calorie intake, stay away from high-fat foods, and watch their portion sizes. They also exercise regularly.

But note: These folks use physical activity in addition to calorie counting and other behavioral changes. Every reliable expert I've ever spoken to on weight loss says the most important thing a person can do is to limit calories in a way they like and can sustain, and focus on eating more healthfully.

In general, diet with exercise can work better than calorie cutting alone, but with only marginal additional weight-loss benefits. "

It doesn't upend it, it basically just says "Don't count calorie expenditures as part of your caloric deficit", which has been standard advice for every resource I've used for quite some time.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by pjlegato on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:24PM (#11598127)
The theory says that as you do additional exercise, you get diminishing returns in terms of the number of calories you burn. As your exercise level increases, you have to do ever more exercise to burn the same number of calories, because the body has various compensatory mechanisms designed to avoid weight loss.

The traditional model proposes a much simpler linear relationship: do an additional unit of exercise and you will burn X more calories, forever. He says that is incorrect and you actually get diminishing returns, where additional units of exercise burn ever fewer calories rather than just a constant.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by fattylite on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:30PM (#11598165)
I understand that. My point was that I've never seen a plan where people tell you to eat as much as you want as long as you do x hours of activity per day. The only plans I've seen like that are for strong men competitors or where the Rock ate like $300 worth of food every day and worked out for six hours daily.
Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by pjlegato on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:37PM (#11598212)
That is exactly the nutrition advice that has been promoted in various government and school health programs for decades: eat what you like, just do X amount of exercise and you'll be fine. Calories in, calories out.

The article goes into some detail about this, mentioning that a great deal of that research was funded by companies that make sugary drinks and other high-calorie food.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by dpark on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:57PM (#11599532)
That is not the advice that's been given by health programs. Everyone has said "diet and exercise" for decades.
Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by fattylite on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:55PM (#11598321)
Everything I've ever seen has had more emphasis on the calories in portion. It feels like they're searching for a boogeyman that isn't there.

http://health.gov/paguidelines/guidelines/chapter2.aspx

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by alva on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:25PM (#11598141)
> The whole point of the article is that the traditional "calories in/calories out" model is wrong.

I think what they mean by this is that the "calories out" portion is what is mostly wrong (or at least, misunderstood ), not that "calories in" are probably the most significant factor when it comes to fat loss. They don't seem to dispute this.

Re:Why you shouldn't exercise to lose weight by Scramblejams on Friday April 29, 2016 @03:27PM (#11598153)
I (despite the article) am mostly in agreement with you, but I think that calories out is a very complex subject. For example, when I calculated how many calories I was burning on my longer runs, it ended up being around 3000 calories/week. However, as I said before, my intake went up. Way up. I ate like an idiot. Donuts? Yeah. Cheeseburgers? Sometimes ordered two. Dr. Pepper? Bring the two liter! I absolutely added more than 3000 calories to my diet after I started running. And yet despite all that, I just kept dropping weight.

The human body is a very complex, non-linear thing. Discerning operating principles by looking solely at inputs and outputs is a hard problem.