Re:Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone
by richard_mcp on Friday April 29, 2016 @12:23PM
(#11596743)
Reviewers work for free for a few reasons reasons. First, it's prestigious to be a reviewer for a top journal and very beneficial for getting tenure. Second, it allows you to create connections with other top researchers. Third, it's giving back to the community by doing a service that needs to be done.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone
by dalke on Saturday April 30, 2016 @06:45AM
(#11601200)
How do people know that I have (or haven't) been a reviewer for a top journal? Do they have a public list of reviewers?
Of the people I meet at a conference, how do I figure out who has been a reviewer for Nature, and how do I verify that claim?
Re:Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone
by mbrundle on Saturday April 30, 2016 @04:13PM
(#11603365)
My thoughts exactly. I've never known a journal to do anything to promote the fact that someone has reviewed for them (eg produce a letter on request that states which articles someone has reviewed for them). It'd be a nice and free way of creating value to reviewers who generally work for free, but I don't know any journal who's ever done this.