News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by abhi3 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:03PM (#11589842)
My suggestion:

1) Filter out troll applications and applications with fake votes and other ineligible applications.

2) From the sanitized list find out the top 10

3) Start a poll where users can choose from the top 10 (but don't rank them in the poll, randomize the placements and don't show live voting stats to prevent bias)

4) Give every applicant on the poll the opportunity to post why one should vote for within a short word limit. As we have seen from low engagement after the first few days, extremely few users will read 10 complete threads and make their choice.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by vishalkgupta on Thursday April 28, 2016 @05:54PM (#11592193)
Hey HN! I'm Vishal. One of the team members behind WedWell(https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11441020).

We're somewhere in the top group of entries with 43 points. I wanted to say that regardless of whether or not we get selected, we really appreciated the ideas and exposure that came from our discussions on HN. A handful of our first clients named HN as the reason why they came to us! Some of the ideas discussed are already being planned for our service. We applied to YC the regular way, and didn't get in. This way we got a bunch of feedback and some traction. Net positive for us.

Dang asked above how best to sift through the applications to give the community final say. I was reading through some of the ideas posted here on how to do that, the one that seem to resonate here with me was the one abhi3 posted above. I'm just worried that a public vote is easily gamed.

Another way to do this is to select the top 10, and get the YC partners (or some trusted groups within YC - perhaps the last group of YC alum?) to vote on the list of 10. I think it would be nice to see what the end vote looks like (release the vote count), and have select YC partners provide some quick feedback for those who are voted on.

Thanks again.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by ryderj on Thursday April 28, 2016 @06:35PM (#11592385)
Jack from wantobuy here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11477823 - also somewhere on the first page - I agree with you Vishal and abhi3.

Moreover, we were rejected the standard YC way too but have got some really great feedback from the HN community which we're implementing already!

I just think the whole Apply HN buzz fizzled out, favouring those that got in on day 1..we were about a week late..

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by theuttick on Friday April 29, 2016 @06:46PM (#11599236)
I am curious as to why you may have been rejected. Seems like a decent idea and you guys are programmers. Do you have a MVP yet?
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by abhi3 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @06:25PM (#11592335)
I think limiting voting to accounts with say, minimum 10 karma will get rid of almost all fake voting.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by vishalkgupta on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:53PM (#11593286)
My gut feeling is that YC wouldn't want to some how alienate those with low karma points, but they could do something like only allow those to vote who have commented on Apply HN posts (or something along those lines).
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by miguelrochefort on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:21PM (#11589957)
> 1) Filter out troll applications and applications with fake votes and other ineligible applications.

How exactly do you identify "troll" applications? The most important ideas are often the most likely to be perceived as an act of trolling.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by mtmail on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:38PM (#11590099)
I've seen very low quality submissions in the /new queue. Basically a single sentence, no information about team, no contact information in the profiles and no upvotes either. Looking through the 300 submission in the /applyhn queue I can't find an example so they could have been filtered already or flagged at one point or another. With more than one submission I thought "you have 2000(?) characters to present, why didn't you invest some time?", again I see that as low quality, not trolling.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by brudgers on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:29PM (#11590520)
Since "Apply HN" is for fellowships and the idea of fellowships is that the business is not necessarily ready to go into business mode, I'm not sure that application polish is an ideal metric. It measures application quality rather than something more meaningful like potential impact multiplied by potential execution.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by biot on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:57PM (#11590265)
You can often tell when someone is being a wise guy in their application. Sometimes their application contains a virtual sarcasm tag when they self-identify as being a wise guy.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by minimaxir on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:31PM (#11590036)
Note that OP is being very coy and is not disclosing the fact that the proposed rules benefit his own Apply HN submission.

The OP is referring to Pinboard which was a joke submission.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by idlewords on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:12PM (#11590386)
What basis do you have for claiming it's a joke?
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by minimaxir on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:18PM (#11590439)
Pinboard is not eligible for the YCF because it is not an early-stage startup.

Otherwise the submission is perfectly fine. :p

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by idlewords on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:28PM (#11590508)
From https://fellowship.ycombinator.com/faq/:

"The only restrictions on acceptable teams are founders must be willing to work on their ideas full-time, and teams can’t have previously taken money from investors."

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by minimaxir on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:00PM (#11590723)
Huh. It appears I have been lawyered.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by abhi3 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:16PM (#11590844)
From the same page:

What if we haven’t yet received investment, but we have a ton of traction, users, revenue, etc.?

We want YC Fellowship to really help teams that are just starting off, or have been struggling to get traction. If you’re doing really well, we’ll likely ask you to apply for the next batch of Y Combinator.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by idlewords on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:32PM (#11590964)
This says nothing about eligibility. It only suggests that such teams—which are allowed to apply—are unlikely to be selected.

In this case, the normal selection process has been changed by throwing the decision to Hacker News. And the people have spoken!

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by CameronBanga on Thursday April 28, 2016 @03:58PM (#11591515)
What are you using as a basis to say that Pinboard's submission was a joke?
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by tdaltonc on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:24PM (#11589974)
Any examples?
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by abhi3 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:28PM (#11590013)
Pinboard McPinboardface
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by idlewords on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:03PM (#11590315)
I met the stated criteria and dominated the voting. I want my twenty grand.

Accusing me of trolling is not just dismissive, but implies I'm acting in bad faith. That's a pretty serious thing to say about someone.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by Alex3917 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:00PM (#11590719)
> Accusing me of trolling [...] implies I'm acting in bad faith.

Not necessarily. I troll people all the time by saying things that are true but sound wrong to the average person, and never in bad faith. PG and Zed Shaw frequently do the same thing, albeit in different ways, and I wouldn't say that they're acting in bad faith either.

To the extent the book Made To Stick is correct that people are much more likely to become engaged with and ultimately remember things that seem wrong or counterintuitive at first, trolling at it's best is just a highly effective didactic technique.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by tptacek on Thursday April 28, 2016 @04:21PM (#11591631)
I think he just said he wasn't trolling.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN applications now closed, let's discuss ... by neurotech1 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:11PM (#11590380)
How about having users post their "Top 10" picks and aggregate the results.

One issue with having a single poll is that there is the possibility that a good startup will miss out due to statistic abnormality.