News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by mgberlin on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:24AM (#11589523)
The headline is clickbait. It's a huge stretch to say that the volunteers engaged in 1 minute of hard exercise. The workout was:

"[they] warmed up for two minutes on stationary bicycles, then pedaled as hard as possible for 20 seconds; rode at a very slow pace for two minutes, sprinted all-out again for 20 seconds; recovered with slow riding for another two minutes; pedaled all-out for a final 20 seconds; then cooled down for three minutes."

Sure, the exertions total to one minute, but the recovery periods and cooldown are a very important aspect of the workout. Muscles are still burning glucose and oxygen, clearing lactic acid, and generally doing all the things that exercise is good for during this time.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by wbhart on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:01PM (#11590299)
Something has definitely gone wrong in either the study, the journalism, or with the person who wrote the headline. From the reporting here, there is nothing whatsoever that makes me believe the one minute of strenuous exertion had anything to do with the result.

Why on earth didn't they have a control group that did 10 minutes of slow cycling instead of a bunch of couch potatoes that did nothing? For all we know, the people who actually turned up for the study regularly to do the actual rides walked far further to get to and from the study than the people who did nothing. And for all we know, 10 minutes of slow cycling has the same measurable effect as 45 minutes of cycling.

What on earth is wrong with medical science/science journalism, that this is the end result of however many dollars of public money? Are they worried that if they actually do a really large, robust study that all future funding will have dried up?

Surely there is a massive public interest in such research. Why doesn't someone just do the sodding research and find out once and for all?

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by CWuestefeld on Thursday April 28, 2016 @04:42PM (#11591762)
Why on earth didn't they have a control group that did 10 minutes of slow cycling instead of a bunch of couch potatoes that did nothing?

It's the journalism that failed you. If you go to a quality site like mensfitness rather than NYT, you'll find:

"To prove it, the researchers put 27 sedentary men to the test. For 12 weeks, nine of the men were asked to perform three weekly sessions of intense sprint interval training on stationary bikes, 10 were assigned to moderate-intensity continuous training (also on bikes), and six served as the control group, completing no exercise. ...

"After three months, all the athletes exhibited similar results and health benefits—even though the moderate-intensity continuous training involved five times as much exercise and a five-fold greater time commitment."

http://www.mensfitness.com/training/workout-routines/10-minu...

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by cpeterso on Thursday April 28, 2016 @05:08PM (#11591893)
I believe wbhart is saying the control group should be 10 minutes of low-intensity cycling, not 45 minutes or 0 minutes. Or the control group could even just come to the lab to sit on the bike without pedaling! This study has too many variables.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by ASpring on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:44AM (#11589698)
Exactly. Let alone the fact that they are using completely untrained individuals, where doing any amount exercise will result in the adaptations they check for.

Wish there was a third group that simply did 10 minutes exercise at the same exertion as the endurance group.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by pascal1usa on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:46AM (#11589716)
It's awfully convenient how they left that obvious third group out. I'm willing to bet that the 45 m group never reached their target heart rate
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by mozumder on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:50PM (#11590201)
For my marathon training, between my long runs, I did spend one day a week to just do one 5-10 minute sprint, at 95-105% max heart rate. ("Oh god I'm going to die..")

The days after I did those, were the clearest, most relaxed days of all.

I ended up with a resting heart rate in the 30s.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by Ensorceled on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:31PM (#11590533)
How did you do 105% of your max heart rate ...
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by Jtsummers on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:37PM (#11590576)
http://www.heart.org/HEARTORG/HealthyLiving/PhysicalActivity...

It's not the literal maximum (the maximum you can achieve), it's the average based on age. So you find the maximum for your age in the chart (or calculate it) and set target zones when exercising.

http://www.runnersworld.com/ask-the-sports-doc/what-is-my-ma... - another discussion about it.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by Ensorceled on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:07AM (#11595126)
Ah, I was wondering, as a runner you should get a HR monitor and calculate your real maximum. The charts are crap; as a 51 year old runner, I routinuely hit 185+BPM when hill or interval training (at about 95% effort) so I'm also doing 105-110% of my chart "max".
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by Jtsummers on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:04AM (#11595426)
That's a good point. I'd treat it like BMI. It's a good guideline, but it's a heuristic and won't fit everyone. In this case, if you've been a longtime runner, you'll almost certainly have a healthier heart than your age-wise peers (not guaranteed, but as a general rule).
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by hondo77 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @05:15PM (#11591942)
If you did it for ten minutes, it wasn't a sprint.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by _Codemonkeyism on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:57AM (#11589801)
The article says

“But if you are someone, like me, who just wants to boost health and fitness and you don’t have 45 minutes or an hour to work out, our data show that you can get big benefits from even a single minute of intense exercise.”

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by _Codemonkeyism on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:46AM (#11589713)
So it's 10 minutes, where 9 minutes are slow riding.

The comparison group which achieved the same results did 45 min exercises.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by Alex3917 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:47AM (#11589721)
> It's a huge stretch to say that the volunteers engaged in 1 minute of hard exercise.

Active recovery just means staying in some sort of minimal motion to keep your blood circulating and let your heart rate come down a little more gently. It's usually nowhere near the intensity of regular base cardio, so I think the headline is reasonably accurate.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by Retric on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:58AM (#11589814)
They could not sustain this rate over 1 minute. So, it's 10 minutes of interval training with 1 minute of high intensity. Not, 1 minute of working out.

They also did not check to see if people 'capped out' sooner.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by ttkeil on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:48AM (#11589728)
NYT seems to have a number of highly similar articles extolling the benefits of HIIT, but this[0] one reads a bit more honest than the one posted, IMO.

Specifically, the author delves into 10-20-30 training, which I've personally started in the past few weeks. It definitely kicks my ass, but I feel great afterwards and it requires significantly less time than moderate exercise.

[0]: http://mobile.nytimes.com/blogs/well/2015/07/29/a-way-to-get...

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by mindcrime on Thursday April 28, 2016 @05:25PM (#11592017)
"[they] warmed up for two minutes on stationary bicycles, then pedaled as hard as possible for 20 seconds; rode at a very slow pace for two minutes, sprinted all-out again for 20 seconds; recovered with slow riding for another two minutes; pedaled all-out for a final 20 seconds; then cooled down for three minutes."

Sounds very similar to the Tabata interval protocol, with the difference being the extended rest period between the "sprint" sections. I have done a variation of this in my own training in the past. It works really well on an elliptical trainer. My subjective feeling is that training this way works pretty well for building endurance and burning fat.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by Bartweiss on Thursday April 28, 2016 @03:10PM (#11591221)
At a quick glance, everything here is totally consistent with "exercise is good" and "HIIT can get you benefits faster than steady-pace exercise". Both of which seem way more obvious and evidence-backed than the claims actually made here.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by mathattack on Thursday April 28, 2016 @08:32PM (#11592973)
For all the complaints on methodology, I think the biggest issue is sample size. 25 people?
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by jobigoud on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:16PM (#11589918)
> the recovery periods and cooldown are a very important aspect of the workout

I would say the warm-up is as well, because if you start a full sprint out of nowhere you are likely going to tear a muscle one day or the other.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by epimetheus on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:22PM (#11589958)
I don't think this is true at all. My experience of years of sprinting has given zero such injuries, and usually it's first thing in the morning, and the only warm up I have is walking to the car, driving to the track, walking from the car to the track.

I've also never did more than a few incremental warm up sets before lifting (relatively heavy) and have never had a pull or a tear.

Warming up is one of those seemingly agreed upon myths in which the scientific evidence is minimal and typically shows the contrary.

edit: for example: http://healthland.time.com/2013/04/08/why-stretching-may-not...

And to add to this, it doesn't even make sense from an evolutionary standpoint. Having a physiology that requires warming up muscles before needing to escape a threat would be weeded out pretty quickly. A predator attacking a camp of humans, for instance, would allow those that can run fast without their "muscles pulling or tearing" to escape leaving those without such an advantage laying about groaning in pain while the predator gets their fill.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by klue07 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:08PM (#11590352)
I wouldn't entirely agree. If you aren't lifting any relatively heavy, extra weights, e.g. running or something, warming up isn't as important. However, when lifting relatively heavy weights, I think warming up is pretty important.

Warming up has the benefit of lubing up your joints. I think we've all had the instance where our body are relatively stiff and if we do, say, a push up, our joints pop or make cracking sounds. I remember squatting once when I didn't fully warm up. My knee wanted to pop during the squat and it felt extremely uncomfortable trying to exert force on that leg. When there isn't any extra weight, merely extending your leg with a pop wouldn't bother anybody, but exerting a lot of force and doing so slowly sure wasn't a pleasant experience. What are the chances of serious injury? I don't know, but it hurt enough for me to not want to find out.

Another thing warming up helps with is to acclimate you to your working set weight. I know the first set of my bench press usually ends in a grinder and is the roughest out of all my sets. I'm not sure if it's just my mind acclimating to the weight or a physiological thing like more blood getting pumped to my muscles. Either way, I'm fairly certain (but do not have any sources) injury rates would be increased if you tried to deadlift your max without properly warming up.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by epimetheus on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:44PM (#11591043)
I think you missed that stated I do a few warmup sets for all of my main lifts and that I lift heavy (5 rep max, sometimes 3rm and 1rm depending on lift and day). However, I believe most people do too many warmup sets which limits their working set and slows progress and gains. Doing 3-4 working sets in reasonable increments is just fine. I know people that do 20 total sets per "body part", only 3-5 of them that are working sets (because that's what the bodybuilding magazine reported <today's Mr. Universe candidate) said they lift).

The running thing seems less likely to be true though. I wouldn't put my bed in a field, sleep 8 hours, hop out and go full out on a sprint, but I'm not going to do 20 minutes of stretching or ride a bike before doing a few sets of sprints.

Long distance warm ups seem even less likely to be needed than Sprints.

And, for what it's worth, I've done "max effort" deadlifts without warming up once or twice. Mostly to show off, but I had lifted those weights before (that day in one case, a couple days back in the other), and didn't have any issues. I could have been hurt, I guess, so my 'anecdata' is no evidence, but even so, not warming up isn't a guarantee of injury either.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by klue07 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @03:01PM (#11591158)
I have a feeling that your true 1rm is higher than you think it is if you can pull it off without acclimating to that weight.

I never said you will for sure get injured, merely the chances increase. And I agree that some people have warm ups that are too intense.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by duderific on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:36PM (#11590075)
Upvoted for the evolutionary perspective. One thing to add though: ancient humans were undoubtedly in better overall fitness than the average modern person, so maybe that would lead to it being unlikely that they would suffer sprinting-related injuries in general -- in other words they were more "warmed up" at any given time than the modern human.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by rileymat2 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:00PM (#11590290)
> ancient humans were undoubtedly in better overall fitness than the average modern person

Is this true? I mean we have different nutrition now. Ancient humans could have had problems putting on muscle mass and fat. Maybe they exercised more, maybe not. When I watch documentaries with hunter/gatherers they sit around quite a bit.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by bwooceli on Thursday April 28, 2016 @04:01PM (#11591527)
Count me in the category that would definitely get weeded out for not having a warmup time before fleeing from the bear.

Sample size of one: I just started to "get fit" after 10 years of sitting on my ass. I'm running every morning when I wake up (I always wake up about 5am, but usually I just go back to sleep until the 7am alarm). So I open eyes, put on clothes, and hit the road within 5 minutes of waking up. I have to start at a slow jog, and I'm not able to go much faster than a speedy walk for about 10 minutes before I can actually jog. So for 10 minutes I'm pacing for a 15 minute mile. I can literally feel the moment at which I can comfortably jog, and then I'm able to do 10 minute miles for the duration of the run.

When I started this at the beginning of April, I could only do 30 minutes at a time and was hitting about 2.25 miles. This week I ran 5.5 miles in 60 minutes, still have to take my slow start.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by ngdndvvcx on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:08PM (#11593129)
> Sample size of one: I just started to "get fit" after 10 years of sitting on my ass.

As a contrast, I've been fit all my life (two sport college athlete, resting heart rate in the 30s) and I absolutely cannot imagine sprinting without a warmup.

GP, how fast are you? 100m time? I have never, ever seen a coach or trainer recommend anything other than a long slow warmup. As someone who has a chronic hamstring injury, warmup is crucial to any exercise that I do.

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by rifung on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:42PM (#11591028)
Interesting.. I feel like I've definitely injured myself from not warming up enough. I actually don't even see how you can sprint at 100% when you are cold.

That's not to say I don't believe but that I wonder if there is something more nuanced which explains the differences in our experiences.

If you don't mind me asking, what kinds of sprinting do you do and how fast/fit/flexible are you?

Your evolutionary point makes sense but for example, my cats do stretch whenever they wake up. I imagine it's not necessary for them to stretch before moving but by stretching every time they remain very flexible. Kids for example don't really need to warm up and seem to have no trouble running right away, but they also are way more flexible than adults typically are so I wonder if that has something to do with it..

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by enraged_camel on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:47PM (#11591068)
>>And to add to this, it doesn't even make sense from an evolutionary standpoint.

You aren't thinking it through. Humans evolved to be long distance runners, not sprinters. Early hunters were all about patiently chasing prey at a very moderate speed over miles and miles until the prey literally collapsed out of exhaustion.

In stark contrast, you have felines such as lions, which are all about short bursts of incredible speed and agility. Their entire bodies are designed for quick acceleration to very high speeds, but if they couldn't catch their prey during that short interval they would be screwed.

Edit: your scenario of "a predator attacking a camp of humans" is not realistic. Most predators are afraid of fire, and even fewer would attack groups of other predators (which humans are).

Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by eagsalazar2 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:47PM (#11591067)
Also upvoted for the involuntary visual of giant cave bear rampaging through paleolithic camp while people get cramps and groin pulls from running away without stretching first. lol.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by eyeJam on Thursday April 28, 2016 @05:26PM (#11592021)
if warming up is just a myth, i dare you to deep-squat two plates without any warmup or mobility exercises. even better, try it after a day at the office sitting for 8 hours. i'll have the wheelchair ready to wheel you out when you slip a disc.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by pc86 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:49PM (#11590188)
That's not how muscles work.
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by ngdndvvcx on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:25PM (#11593201)
Evidence?
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by collinmanderson on Saturday April 30, 2016 @04:01PM (#11603322)
So actually longer than the "7 minute workout". :)
Re:Benefits of 1 Minute of All-Out Effort during Exercise by sametmax on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:51AM (#11589744)
It also ignore the side effect of unbalanced exercice. It may be better than no exercice though, but you still have to consider it.