News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by StavrosK on Thursday April 28, 2016 @07:35AM (#11587990)
I was really surprised that the announcement that Steam may support Bitcoin made waves a while ago, yet the announcement that it actually does did not.

I used it to buy a (horrible) game last night, and it worked beautifully. Contrast with PayPal, with which Steam is always confused about where I am and whether it should charge me in GBP or EUR. I'm never not using Bitcoin again.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by flatline on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:32AM (#11588647)
They don't accept bitcoin directly, they instead accept fiat from Bitpay on behalf of people who wish to pay in bitcoin. It is an important distinction. On the one hand this makes a lot of sense for Steam, it reduces the up-front overhead and risk of accepting digital currencies and I would imagine it offloads the onus of AML/KYC compliance to Bitpay. On the other hand it is hardly a ringing endorsement of bitcoin itself.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by aedron on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:42AM (#11588732)
It doesn't matter. I can pay with bitcoin on Steam. It makes bitcoin more fungible and thus viable as a currency.

And for what it's worth, I find the bitcoin payment process immensely superior to credit cards: Just pull out the phone and scan the QR code on the screen. Screen updates to show payment was made. Love it. (Now, acquiring the bitcoins in the first place though...)

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by hartpuff on Thursday April 28, 2016 @10:38AM (#11589166)
> It doesn't matter. I can pay with bitcoin on Steam.

I can pay with Dogecoin with one additional step.

>It makes bitcoin more fungible and thus viable as a currency.

Isn't using Bitpay just a way of exchanging bitcoin for dollars, while kidding yourself that's not what you're doing?

> And for what it's worth, I find the bitcoin payment process immensely superior to credit cards: Just pull out the phone and scan the QR code on the screen. Screen updates to show payment was made.

All that's left is to wait countless tedious hours for the funds to appear in the, for example, Namesilo account. It is easy (so is using a credit card), but it's almost uselessly slow (unlike credit cards).

Edit: maybe this explains anti-Bitcoin sentiment. The fundamentalists can't handle any factual comments that aren't entirely about how game changing it is.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by azernik on Thursday April 28, 2016 @07:15PM (#11592587)
> Isn't using Bitpay just a way of exchanging bitcoin for dollars, while kidding yourself that's not what you're doing?

That's fungibility. That's liquidity. A big marker of stability and legitimacy for a normal currency is that it's freely convertible.

A parallel example: you can pay for stuff "in euros" on Paypal, but Steam likely only gets dollars. That's still good for the viability of the euro as a currency, because it can be easily exchanged for goods and services, even with a middleman.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by hartpuff on Friday April 29, 2016 @06:52AM (#11594866)
The point is, unlike with Bitcoin, people with Euros do not have any significant ideological opposition towards dollars, or acquire Euros because they believe it is superior to or will one day replace dollars.

> That's still good for the viability of the euro as a currency, because it can be easily exchanged for goods and services, even with a middleman.

So it's good for Bitcoin in exactly the same way that it's good for Dogecoin, and other popular alts.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by azernik on Friday April 29, 2016 @07:42AM (#11595023)
> The point is, unlike with Bitcoin, people with Euros do not have any significant ideological opposition towards dollars, or acquire Euros because they believe it is superior to or will one day replace dollars.

And that's why it's a bit silly to have ideological positions about currencies :-P I'm just arguing that it is actually good for Bitcoin the currency, not that it's good for the bitcoiner ideology.

> So it's good for Bitcoin in exactly the same way that it's good for Dogecoin, and other popular alts.

Oh yeah, totally. It's good for the viability of blockchain currencies in general.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by hartpuff on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:27AM (#11595228)
> And that's why it's a bit silly to have ideological positions about currencies

Indeed. I think Bitcoin would be given the time of day by a lot more people if there was a lot less political whackjobbery surrounding it, and more sane, informed discussion from people such as yourself.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanlol on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:01AM (#11589348)
>All that's left is to wait countless tedious hours for the funds to appear in the, for example, Namesilo account. It is easy (so is using a credit card), but it's almost uselessly slow (unlike credit cards).

This is not a bitcoin problem.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by hartpuff on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:32PM (#11590049)
Then why does it only happen using bitcoin?

Actually, scratch that, because it doesn't even matter. Wherever you want to lay the blame (anywhere but bitcoin) it's a problem for anyone using bitcoin, making it more useless than (not "immensely superior" to, as claimed) using a credit card or Paypal, which makes it a problem for bitcoin.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanl0l on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:02PM (#11590306)
>Then why does it only happen using bitcoin?

Because some people insist on waiting for the payment to settle before actually providing the services, although it's not nearly as common as it used to be.

This is just completely unrealistic with credit cards where settlement times are far longer than with bitcoin, days or months.

>Wherever you want to lay the blame (anywhere but bitcoin) it's a problem for anyone using bitcoin, making it more useless than (not "immensely superior" to, as claimed) using a credit card or Paypal, which makes it a problem for bitcoin.

I don't know, I use bitcoins to pay for things regularly and pretty much everyone accepts zero-confirmation transactions nowadays (which is pretty much the same as accepting credit card payments, except the settlement will most likely take less than an hour).

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ChemicalWarfare on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:56PM (#11593672)
Credit card payment is a '2 phase' process. The second phase you are referring to as settlement - moving funds from the issuing bank to merchant's bank does take days.

The first phase of the process - authorization, when successful not only makes sure the customer has enough credit on their account, it also reduces their buying power by the grand total of the auth thus guaranteeing the funds to the merchant. And it takes 2-4 seconds.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanlol on Friday April 29, 2016 @01:51AM (#11593970)
Bitcoin works exactly the same, except settlement times are significantly shorter.

You authorize (sign) a transaction, broadcast it and the network confirms it.

Signing a transaction takes only a fractions of a second, and to the merchant it's a significantly stronger guarantee of settlement than a credit card authorization.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ChemicalWarfare on Friday April 29, 2016 @08:59AM (#11595402)
Credit Card authorization guarantees the funds to the merchant. Signing a bitcoin transaction and broadcasting it to the blockchain does not. Successful confirmation of the tx on the blockchain does, and to be on the safe side the rule of thumb is to wait for 6 confs on the bitcoin blockchain before considering the funds to be guaranteed.

Tx confirmation times are a known problem with BTC in terms of the payment acceptance flow, this is one of the hurdles preventing wider merchant adoption of BTC acceptance.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanlol on Sunday May 01, 2016 @08:34AM (#11605937)
>Credit Card authorization guarantees the funds to the merchant.

It absolutely does not. Even if the customer isn't actively trying to screw you it's still possible for the hold to expire before settlement.

>Signing a bitcoin transaction and broadcasting it to the blockchain does not.

With a reasonable fee it's a far stronger guarantee of settlement than a cc authorization as it's way harder for the customer to reliably cheat you.

>Successful confirmation of the tx on the blockchain does, and to be on the safe side the rule of thumb is to wait for 6 confs on the bitcoin blockchain before considering the funds to be guaranteed.

6 confirmations makes sense if you're selling a house, surely you wouldn't just rely on a cc auth if you were doing that.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ChemicalWarfare on Sunday May 01, 2016 @02:52PM (#11607378)
Successful auth is the issuing bank telling the merchant - 'yes, the customer has the funds and the money is yours for the taking via the capture request against this auth.' Which is a GUARANTEE. Yes, as a means of customer protection it expires if the merchant did not request the capture within a certain timeframe which is at least 2 weeks, 4 weeks in most cases.

For digital goods (and POS) this is a non-issue since the capture request is combined with the auth request. For physical goods - well if I'm a customer and the merchant hasn't shipped in 2+ weeks it's fair to me to get the hold removed from the funds my bank GUARANTEED to the merchant.

6 conf is a rule of thumb bitpay (and other bitcoin payment processors that I'm aware of) are following before GUARANTEEING the funds to the merchant. sure, if this is a P2P transaction and I was personally selling you $10 worth of merchandise I'd be ok with 1 conf, when talking 'industrial' scale payment acceptance things work just a little bit different.

So now in this particular case - steam can revoke the license if the payment eventually fails which is precisely why I think this sort of market is perfect for BTC (I commented on this in this thread).

And finally since you're claiming high tx fees are 'a far stronger guarantee of settlement than a cc authorization as it's way harder for the customer to reliably cheat you' - how would you cheat the merchant after the auth (let alone auth/capture) went through?

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanlol on Sunday May 01, 2016 @04:05PM (#11607645)
>Successful auth is the issuing bank telling the merchant - 'yes, the customer has the funds and the money is yours for the taking via the capture request against this auth.' Which is a GUARANTEE. Yes, as a means of customer protection it expires if the merchant did not request the capture within a certain timeframe which is at least 2 weeks, 4 weeks in most cases.

That's a pretty shitty guarantee when the bank can deny settlement anyways, and FWIW mine seem to expire in 5 days.

>6 conf is a rule of thumb bitpay (and other bitcoin payment processors that I'm aware of) are following before GUARANTEEING the funds to the merchant. sure, if this is a P2P transaction and I was personally selling you $10 worth of merchandise I'd be ok with 1 conf, when talking 'industrial' scale payment acceptance things work just a little bit different.

Unless you're talking about transactions worth tens of thousands of dollars it's simply not worth it for an attacker to even attempt such an attack (not that it'd be very likely work anyway).

And last I checked bitpay is just fine with 1 conf transactions and will happily tank the risk for you. I'd assume the risk is quite small since I haven't ever heard of such an attack actually happening.

>And finally since you're claiming high tx fees are 'a far stronger guarantee of settlement than a cc authorization as it's way harder for the customer to reliably cheat you' - how would you cheat the merchant after the auth (let alone auth/capture) went through?

I could just claim that the transaction was fraudulent. I could contact my bank and forward them a fake email from you claiming that the auth was an accident (done this before, although not with a fake email).

Oh, and most shockingly... I could just use a stolen card!

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ChemicalWarfare on Sunday May 01, 2016 @06:40PM (#11608181)
Even if the auth expires (5 days is probably the limit imposed by your payment processor although it's probably sufficient in most cases) - when you are ready to ship and do a capture against it, it'll fail so you know the guarantee provided to you when the original auth went through is no longer there.

bitpay - even if they were happy with 1 conf it would still mean 10 or so minutes before you are guaranteed your funds as a merchant. They are not, however - "When an invoice is complete, it means that BitPay.com has credited the merchant’s account for the invoice. Currently, 6 confirmation blocks on the bitcoin network are required for an invoice to be complete." (https://bitpay.com/docs/invoice-states) Although the merchants can take the risk of course, and if they are controlling the product after the sale (which is the case with Steam) - they are free to dispatch the goods when they please.

Fraud - sure, you're talking good ol' chargebacks and yes not having to deal with chargebacks is a good selling point for btc payment acceptance. These happen AFTER the settlement however. If the customer convinced their bank to remove the auth hold, then the capture the merchant performs before shipping would fail so you know that the guarantee the issuing bank provided is no longer there.

Again, bitcoin does have it's strengths in terms of being attractive to both the merchant and the buyer, transaction confirmation times is probably the single biggest weakness here especially compared to the way CC processing works.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by Natanael_L on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:21AM (#11595498)
Credit card chargeback fraud isn't that rare, and the merchants usually take the hit.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ChemicalWarfare on Friday April 29, 2016 @09:32AM (#11595574)
Yup, and that is one of the selling points of bitcoin from the merchant's perspective. I was specifically talking about funding confirmation times, to claim that CC processing is slower than bitcoin because it takes longer to settle is misleading.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by aianus on Thursday April 28, 2016 @12:26PM (#11589986)
"They don't accept CNY directly, they instead accept USD from their merchant bank on behalf of people who wish to pay in CNY"

This is a pointless distinction.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by wallacoloo on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:11PM (#11590812)
No, it is a meaningful distinction for some. For those of us hoping to avoid the overhead of payment processors by using bitcoin, it puts the two methods on equal footing instead - there's still a middleman taking a (likely nontrivial) cut from our purchases.

Also, I imagine CNY -> USD conversion is probably done on an exchange instead of through a company like BitPay, so the comparison might not be very accurate.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by aianus on Thursday April 28, 2016 @04:25PM (#11591661)
> Also, I imagine CNY -> USD conversion is probably done on an exchange instead of through a company like BitPay, so the comparison might not be very accurate.

There is no such thing as a Forex exchange, it is done through banks who hedge their exposure to other market participants over-the-counter and take a cut just the same.

There is absolutely no reason (in the long term) that Bitcoin would cost more to exchange for merchants than any foreign fiat currency does today.

And even today, a ~1% Bitcoin processing fee is approximately 1/3 to 1/2 of what credit cards cost to process.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by jzwinck on Friday April 29, 2016 @02:40AM (#11594126)
If there is no such thing as a forex exchange, what is this?

http://www.hotspotfx.com/products/the_hotspot_ecn.jsp

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ThatPlayer on Thursday April 28, 2016 @05:55PM (#11592199)
BitPay also has the option to give you Bitcoins instead of fiat. (Or a percentage of each). We have no clue how much Steam is keeping in Bitcoins.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by Grue3 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @07:50AM (#11588063)
What about refunds? With Paypal you know you're getting the same amount back, in the same currency, as if you haven't bought anything at all. Given the fluctuating nature of Bitcoin, surely that's not possible?
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by StavrosK on Thursday April 28, 2016 @07:59AM (#11588129)
I just asked for a refund, because the game was terrible. I asked for the refund to be sent to my wallet, there was an option to get Bitcoin back. I think that, for the wallet, they refund you the game's store price.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by chii on Thursday April 28, 2016 @08:50AM (#11588392)
this seems like a good way to launder bitcoins. Unless if you got back _the same_ coins you spent - i guess steam holding on to your coins for 2hrs~ isn't that big of a risk, rather than immediately swapping it out for cash.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by mbmott on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:02AM (#11588464)
Not the case. The bitcoin you paid in and the bitcoin refunded to you are tied directly to your real identity, so I'm not sure what value "laundering" would have. There are no dirty bitcoins--see the U.S. Gov sale of the Silk Road coins as proof of this.

Bitcoin does have mixing services that would "launder" or obfuscate the link between bitcoin and your real identity, which does provide value for some users.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by Fogest on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:26AM (#11588605)
But you don't have to have valid data on your steam account?
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by mbmott on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:44AM (#11588745)
As far as I know you can't make a purchase without having valid payment data. There might be a work around, but probably not via Bitcoin payments. Bitpay is definitely subject to KYC / AML compliance.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanlol on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:03AM (#11589364)
> As far as I know you can't make a purchase without having valid payment data.

What is "valid payment data"? How do they validate this data?

>Bitpay is definitely subject to KYC / AML compliance.

Why is that relevant?

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by mbmott on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:09PM (#11590803)
What is "valid payment data"? How do they validate this data?

You need to have a valid payment method. I'm not sure how better to explain this... a credit card or paypal account etc. It's validated when the payment clears. Both of these have strong identity data linked to them.

KYC (Know your customer) / AML (Anti Money Laundering) compliance means validating the identities of those you do business with. That means, using Steam to launder money isn't possible. This should be pretty obvious.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanlol on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:24PM (#11590901)
>You need to have a valid payment method. I'm not sure how better to explain this... a credit card or paypal account etc. It's validated when the payment clears. Both of these have strong identity data linked to them.

No, paypal doesn't do ANY identity verification for customers beyond fraud scoring and AVS.

For cards, you can just get a prepaid. And most cards outside of the US don't even support AVS, so there's no way for valve to validate any of the information you give them besides the PAN and CVV.

>KYC (Know your customer) / AML (Anti Money Laundering) compliance means validating the identities of those you do business with. That means, using Steam to launder money isn't possible. This should be pretty obvious.

I don't think Valve is covered (or considers themselves to be covered) by either of those, and they certainly don't appear to be doing any of the typical KYC stuff.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by matt4077 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @01:34PM (#11590546)
Steam uses Bitpay. "KYC" means "know your customer". "Customer" is the guy/gal trying to use Steam to launder bitcoin. Relevance elucidated?
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by ryanlol on Thursday April 28, 2016 @02:14PM (#11590838)
No, Valve software is bitpays "customer". The guy/gal trying to use Steam to launder bitcoin is a customer of Valve Software.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by jandrese on Thursday April 28, 2016 @10:45AM (#11589224)
Seems like there are easier ways to launder bitcoins. Tumblers are still around I think.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by cloudjacker on Thursday April 28, 2016 @10:57AM (#11589322)
it isn't a good way to launder bitcoins.

there are good ways, this isn't one of them. Stick with Shapeshift.io

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by VMG on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:47AM (#11588768)
Steam isn't holding coins in any case, it's Bitpay. They have probably figured this out.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by csense on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:24AM (#11589524)
See here: https://help.bitpay.com/15596-payments-refunds/how-do-i-refu...

It seems that BitPay (the payment provider used Steam and many other merchants who accept Bitcoins) gets a dollar valued refund amount from the merchant (so you can do partial refunds). Then they calculate the Bitcoin value of the refund amount at the current exchange rate and send that much bitcoin back to the user. There's an extra Bitcoin transaction fee involved. I'm sure BitPay keeps a few thousand dollars worth of Bitcoin on hand to pay refunds, and I'm sure refunds are rare enough that any frictional costs are much smaller than what they bring in through their own fees.

So basically the user is taking on the exchange rate risk -- if you buy a game, Bitcoins go up 20% overnight and then you request a refund, your refund amount will be less Bitcoins than you originally paid. If they did it any other way then it would be subject to abuses that would allow users and merchants to collude to extract money from BitPay (BitPay would essentially be writing options which would allow users to buy back bitcoins that were sold on their behalf in the past at the same price they were sold, even if that's substantially different from the current market price).

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by Shalle135 on Thursday April 28, 2016 @08:21AM (#11588230)
I read another article about this previously, and steam themselves never touch the bitcoin they use some 3rd party. And there for they probably can't refund it in BTC and the fluctuation wont matter.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by VMG on Thursday April 28, 2016 @07:55AM (#11588093)
Why not? You just calculate the refund amount based on the USDBTC rate.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by fjidodhofjf on Thursday April 28, 2016 @08:18PM (#11592903)
Another example of how economicly illiterate anti Bitcoin Advocates are.

Go look at USD/YEN movement, 1-3% movements occur daily, if you were to purchase YEN with USd and later refund to USd you could end up significantly up or down.

But the wealth YEN represents is many many magnitudes greater than Bitcoin. When YEN appreciates by 2% that influences hundreds of millions of people and business, and guess who is pulling that lever, a small cabal of corrupt bankers.

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by kentt on Thursday April 28, 2016 @11:08AM (#11589406)
There is the same sort of issue with any foreign currency. As a Canadian, I'm often buying things with USD. I don't expect to covered for fluctuations in the CAD/USD if I'm refunded.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by Scirra_Tom on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:26AM (#11588602)
I imagine you'd get the refund of the USD (or whatever your currency is) equivalent at time of purchase in your Steam wallet.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by krisdol on Thursday April 28, 2016 @07:57AM (#11588117)
Can you ever take money out of steam?
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by Ntrails on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:09AM (#11588495)
Buy hats with steam credit, sell on a third party marketplace. Lose n% in fees and price differentials.

It is done completely legitimately - you're just not getting money from steam

Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by MLR on Thursday April 28, 2016 @10:32AM (#11589107)
You buy items from the marketplace (normally keys) and then sell them on a third party site or arrange a deal with a private buyer, I think it normally nets you around 70-80% of the original amount but I'm not up to date with it.
Re:Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases by nxzero on Thursday April 28, 2016 @09:52AM (#11588819)
Your use "never not" is confusing; meaning to me, "I'm always going to use Bitcoin in the future, and never going to use anything else to buy on Steam." - would be more clear.