First of all, their fraud endangered people. People rely on blood diagnostics to save their lives and maintain their health - their fraud is not as simple as failing to clean your home or failing to bring you dinner. Much of the anger I think isn't even from the perspective of Silicon Valley, it's simply being angry at a company that put many people at risk via deep, systemic, and willful fraud.
On a tribal level, their behavior also reflects on us, because we're all part of this Silicon Valley pool. When a member of your "tribe" behaves poorly IMO it's entirely natural to feel anger at them.
On a higher and more pragmatic level, Theranos' behavior to some degree threatens the health of the industry, by inviting more heavy-handed regulation, and bringing more intense scrutiny from both outside and inside (one can argue both these things are justified, though). We've generally operated so far under the idea that everyone (for the most part) is behaving in good faith, that startup failures are honest failures, and don't involve unprecedented, deep, systemic fraud.
There is also anger at investors in general, stemming from a general feeling that they aren't doing enough to police bad behavior from their founders. Startup failures are to be expected - they are core to the SV model - but in general whenever SV companies behave egregiously badly their investors are entirely mute. This is doubly infuriating when, like in Theranos' case, the bad behavior has serious consequences.
Fairly common to raise money on a vision, launch an unfinished product (she used the competitors devices to deliver results?) to gauge customer interest, esp in targetted markets, then go gung-ho on Engineering to deliver. Maybe this doesn't work in Bio-tech? I wouldn't know.
I agree this will bring a whole lot of unwanted attention to a new industry, but would argue that this was because of the litany of borderline clickbait articles that have followed the WSJ expose.
Now if Theranos dies, we'll never know if they were actually full of shit, or if they were actually close to solving the problem but died because they couldn't weather the PR shitstorm.
The use of competitor equipment in this case was a tacit admission of their failure to deliver. The business proposition was "we have blood tests that are superior in every way", not "we want to open blood testing centers in Walmart".
How much VC funding do you think they would have gotten on a pitch of opening retail blood testing centers with conventional equipment? It sounds like a boring, low margin business that no VC would want a part of.
Whether it is appropriate for a biotech company to do so (with actual health information on the line) is another matter. At best, the FDA should have space for this kind of beta testing (clearly marked, always cross-checked etc.).
In the VC system - certainly.
When you have startups offering a real service with real profitability struggling to find cash for expansion, while some well-connected placeholder who is incompetent at best and fraudulent at worst ambles in and gets $400m for hype and promises, a "PR shitstorm" is the least of everyone's worries.
It's good that some people weren't convinced. But enough people were convinced for $400m to change hands.
That's really not a good result for a system that likes to pretend it's good at making smart choices about funding.
Saying that people shouldn't be outraged because they will probably fail and be punished is kind of silly. Do we say don't be mad at a murderer just because they are going to go to jail? Punishment or even resolution of a problem doesn't mitigate the emotional reaction to that problem for most people.
Like I said AFAIK, Theranos hasn't taken money away from any more deserving startup. Though, I agree $400M is A LOT of money gone to a supposed undeserved startup. Maybe that's the source of the rage.
There do exist broader harms, and people's behavior can be so egregious that it "offends the sensibilities".
Start with the least of, yet most salient of your stated issues: did Theranos divert money from other more deserving startups -- 'AFAYK, no specific one of those dollars was kept from another specific deserving startup familiar to you, so it's OK'? Really? Are you saying that all other startups are similarly dishonest and undeserving, or that because because no one can specifically track it to your satisfaction, no one should be PO'd?
Related to your other posts, and as another responder commented, this is not a case of a mere unfinished app with noticeable demand, to which funds and effort are applied until it gets built-out until v1.1 gets rolled out.
This is a case where the "app" is a blood test critical to people's lives, determining drug dosages, treatment courses and outcomes, etc. A failure here can really f*$k up someone's life or kill them, not just inconvenience them because the app failed to load and order their dinner.
Moreover, this is a case where Theranos clearly must have known that the basic technology DID NOT WORK and COULD NOT BE MADE TO WORK with any reasonable effort. The right thing to do after a suitable amount of R&D is to shut it down and return remaining money to investors. Many startups have done this.
Instead, Theranos decided perpetrate a continuing fraud on investors, customers and the public. They used competitor's machines claiming to be using their own machines.
This defrauds everyone, pollutes the investing and entrepreneurial ecosystem, and puts patients at risk. (but AFAYK, this is no reason for anyone to be even a bit annoyed...)
Worse yet, and this is one of the bases for the govt's CRIMINAL investigation, Theranos was using hordes of UNQUALIFIED technicians running both the test equipment, and they even CONTINUED to do so after being previously warned by the govt. WTF?!? This is the most simple, basic management -- no science or engineering here -- just use some of your $400MM to hire people with the required credentials to perform tests upon which people rely for their health and life. And the CEO then said that she didn't know about it? This is just obviously a culture of fraud and corner-cutting, in which the only thing that mattered was the image.
Theranos may indeed have started out as an honest development effort (I hope so). But at some point it obviously became clear internally that the tech did not and would not work. At that point, Theranos decided (explicitly or implicitly) to continue to maintain the facade, and wandered off into fraud.
If you don't understand that this kind of behavior violates social and legal norms in many ways, and that people are normally annoyed at these sorts of violations and failures to uphold the norms that bind us together as a society, then I'm not sure anyone could help you.
And saying that it is OK to lie, cheat, and steal as long as nobody can articulate a specific harm to a specific person puts you on the outside of society, and not in a good way.
OTOH, if you're just trolling, then well played.
There is a whole government agency dedicated to making sure this doesn't happen. The 'app' analogy doesn't work. They have the power to shut all of a companies services. My only point was, let the FDA do its thing. I don't want a company to die just because there is an article written about it multiple times a day (seriously, monitor the frontpage of HN for this). There is no way to tell between actual journalism and clickbait.
I'm sure you would agree, at this point these articles are doing nothing but fulfilling a sense of schadenfreude in us. The government and the FDA are on it.
I HOPE at this point that we are all right and the government takes the company down and shuts it down. If it turns out they didn't do anything illegal and just runs out of money in a couple of years, would that be fair?
The anger I'm sensing in this thread is one to a convicted defrauding case. Which it isn't yet. For now, Holmes is promising to overhaul the company to comply.
I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt and let things play out. If they run out of money, you're right, I'd be pissed. If they have a criminal conviction, I'll gladly join the chorus of anger.
Until then, these articles are just beating a dead horse.
Of course not -- these federal monitoring agencies/police are a necessary burden, and they only marginally prevent crime -- the crimes still happen, and the agencies/police only come in after to investigate and punish. Meanwhile, people's lives are harmed or ended -- by the criminals -- who act with impunity until caught and punished.
Now, are Holmes and the rest of Theranos' mgt criminals? Of course none of us actually know, we have only a preponderance of second-hand evidence from the press and from government actions. If you are saying that we shouldn't trust any of this, that Theranos is really a bunch of upstanding citizens being brought down by a malicious government and press, then say so.
Otherwise, if there is a reason to put some trust in the actions of the govt and the press, then we shouldn't be the slightest bit surprised at the anger, schadenfreude, and impatience to have them taken down.
IMO, based on the public info, Theranos has become a criminally fraudulent enterprise, and my biggest emotions are anger that they got away with it for so long and impatience at wanting to see them taken down sooner (of course, if it turned out to be a malicious govt and press, then I'd be defending Theranos even more strongly than I now despise them, as a malicious govt and press are an even bigger betrayal of our trust).
Re: If they didn't actually do anything illegal and just ran out of money? NO, simply spending down the funds until they are exhausted on a known dead-end project is not fair.
At this point, they've had and years of time with unrestricted access to hundreds of millions of dollars for R&D. They will have either 1) a known path forward with a method that can be engineered into a usable solution, or 2) the knowledge that there is no such path in sight or that they are obstructed by physical limits, or 3) neither of these.
If 1), they should already be engineering it towards success (and not testing it in the field with unqualified techs).
If 2), they should politely shut down and return unspent funds.
If 3), then they have and incompetent R&D effort and should also return the unspent funds.
Simply continuing to spend down the funds in condition 2 or 3 is at the very least dishonest/fraudlent to the investors (or other entrepreneurs who might access those investment funds), since it is now known that there is no realistic chance for success.
What, pray tell, is the appropriate reaction to watching someone fraudulently incinerate 600 million dollars intended to be invested in taking care of people and improving health?
My point remains, at this point if Theranos fails (and TRULY loses $600M) then it'll be because of the media shitstorm. If they naturally died because the company was full of shit (which it would eventually), then we'd have more reason to be angry at the waste of money.
lolz
So the reason the house of cards collapsed is because the WSJ said "Hey guys that thing might be a house of cards over there"?
I don't know really know what WSJ did that wouldn't have otherwise come up in regular FDA proceedings other than telling a bunch of millionaires they were stupid with their money.
P.S: To my point there are two articles on the HN frontpage about Theranos just today. This now seems like click-bait hoarding. The original WSJ piece was obviously warranted (if for anything then as a warning to SV biotech investors).
If Theranos is full of shit, they'll be dead in a year or two, even the dumbest of VC's start asking probing questions at later rounds, DEFINITELY before IPO.
At this point it'll be the PR shitstorm that'll kill Theranos before any attempt to develop actually functioning tech.