News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Current State of Spycraft by ovi256 on Sunday February 28, 2010 @09:50AM (#1156930)
It should glad me that everyone seems to discuss this with objective detachment. However, I am shocked that no one cared to touch the moral core of the matter : assassination of civil or political leaders is a crime.

Can you remember the outrage when Rabin was assassinated ? Can you imagine the outrage if Palestine assassinated an Israeli statesman ? What the Mossad did is no different.

Re:The Current State of Spycraft by tokenadult on Sunday February 28, 2010 @09:55AM (#1156933)
assassination of civil or political leaders is a crime

Taking your wording as my guide to the morality of the situation, I'll note that the Hamas person who was assassinated was not an elected political leader, but rather a gun runner and apparent assassin himself. He wasn't traveling under his real name in Dubai, it appears, nor was he traveling with a diplomatic or official (that is, government official's) passport.

Re:The Current State of Spycraft by rdtsc on Sunday February 28, 2010 @11:40AM (#1157098)
Alright, here is a better 'morality guide':

   Assassinating someone is a crime.
Re:The Current State of Spycraft by cema on Sunday February 28, 2010 @12:41PM (#1157190)
Rabin was assassinated for political reasons, as part of internal (Israel's) political discourse. This guy was assassinated for completely different reasons, as part of an ongoing war (or, if you prefer, anti-terrorist operation).

"Can you imagine the outrage if Palestine assassinated an Israeli statesman?" It has happened in the past (Rehavam Zeevi), however the perpetrators were not PA officials, so the answer too was not directed at PA but at the people who had done it.

Finally, calling the guy killed in Dubai a Palestinian statesman is preposterous. A very different situation, both in legal and moral aspects.

Re:The Current State of Spycraft by Enra2 on Sunday February 28, 2010 @10:44AM (#1157008)
I don't like deontological ethics, I especially don't like this sloppy kind. It seems extremely implausible that the moral benefits of a crime could never outweigh its cost. The US has assassinated A LOT of al Qaeda and Taliban members in the "war on terror", is it more permissible if they do it with a drone (even if it does cause more collateral damage) because it just "seems more like war" than the James Bond stuff Mossad has been up to?
Re:The Current State of Spycraft by rdtsc on Sunday February 28, 2010 @11:48AM (#1157109)
> The US has assassinated A LOT of al Qaeda and Taliban members in the "war on terror",

I don't like the "if we do it, it's ok" ethics though. So if US does and does it A LOT (sic) then it's ok?

Re:The Current State of Spycraft by Enra2 on Sunday February 28, 2010 @11:53PM (#1158080)
I'm not american. Not a big fan of US foreign policy either. My point is that being upset about assassination of foreign leaders because it is "a crime" looks pretty silly unless you are a full blown pacifist (and thus not OK with any of the killing states at war have done). In that case you look pretty silly anyway.