News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by atonse on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:25AM (#11564811)
> Similarly, unmanned vehicles might proceed at speed through an intersection where a stop sign has been removed by college students or knocked down the night before by an impaired human.

But so would human drivers. In fact, a self-driving car may actually do better in this scenario because it would have metadata stating that the last 3,000 times a car encountered this intersection, there was a stop sign here.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by mikeash on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:57AM (#11565082)
It seems to be really hard to get people to compare driverless cars with real humans, and not imaginary perfect drivers.

For another example, there's the nigh ubiquitous question of how to handle ethical dilemmas, like a crash where you have a choice between crushing a nun and crushing a baby carriage. Nobody ever seems to consider the fact that human drivers will almost never consider the ethics of the situation when choosing an outcome, and in fact probably won't deliberately choose any outcome at all, but will merely brake and steer by reflex.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by bryanlarsen on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:26PM (#11565323)
If you're ever driving in a situation where it is possible for a nun or baby carriage to jump in front of your car without any warning, you should be driving at 30km/h (20mph) or less. This gives you a stopping distance of approximately 1 car length, so stopping is always a better option than trying to steer around an obstacle. It also means that any collision with a pedestrian is highly unlikely to be fatal.

Of course, having automated cars driving at 30km/h through the suburbs is going to piss everybody off, but that's better than dead babies.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by themartorana on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:28PM (#11565346)
Grew up on a road where your choice is more likely to be one kid vs. another kid. Nobody drove 20 mph on that road. At least driverless cars will respect the speed limit. Human drivers do no such thing. While texting.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by nathanlied on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:32PM (#11565387)
I'd wager a driverless car can afford to go a little faster, given its reaction speed is likelier much, much faster than anything a human can put out.

In fact, a driverless car may be capable of estimating its own stopping distance given road conditions and other measurements, account for some margin of error, and then use that to calculate how fast it can go down a road, while still adhering to the posted speed limits.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by lallysingh on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:40PM (#11565450)
If the human in the car isn't impatiently driving it, they'll probably be happier with a slower, safer, and more comfortable ride while they fiddle with their phone or do work on their laptop. Speed has no business, frankly, on residential drives. I don't think it even helps you get anywhere much faster -- it's more about venting schedule anxiety onto your gas pedal.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by Ntrails on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:36AM (#11570271)
Porsche shoots past at 30mph over speed limit.

"He won't get there any faster"

(Yes, he will. It's pretty simple to work out exactly how much faster actually)

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by lallysingh on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @11:02AM (#11572448)
55 in a residenial zone? WTF?
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by bryanlarsen on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:51PM (#11565521)
It's not just about reaction time; 30 km/h is the limit where you can collide with a pedestrian and be fairly assured that the pedestrian will live. Above that speed survival rates drop dramatically.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by maxerickson on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:35PM (#11565407)
Passenger comfort is a bigger issue than the precise stopping distance.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by germanier on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:29PM (#11565364)
The point of that often quoted ethical dilemma is that a human driver can't choose at all. With driverless cars at one point someone has to make a deliberate decision on how to act in these situations. Not in a split-second but rather in a long process. This results in different ethical considerations.

Sure, a human driver doesn't take any of the relevant factors into account. But a driverless car does and that's the difference.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by mikeash on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:04PM (#11565613)
That's my point. People's expectations for driverless cars are vastly higher for no particularly good reason. Sure, a driverless car could potentially do a lot better than a human, but if it merely does as well as a human then it's already good enough here. You can slice the gordian knot of the ethical dilemma by saying "when presented with two bad choices, we'll pick whichever one is closer to the car's path" and it's fine. But people talk about it as a difficult problem to overcome because they're unwilling to accept human-level performance.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by jfoster on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:03PM (#11565609)
It's usually presented as a "problem" with autonomous vehicles.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by jimbokun on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:56PM (#11565986)
"It seems to be really hard to get people to compare driverless cars with real humans, and not imaginary perfect drivers."

I think this responsibility falls squarely on the manufacturers of autonomous vehicles.

I think only the people creating the technology really understand the strengths and weaknesses of software drivers compared to human drivers, and are responsible for educating law makers and the general public if they want their products to be accommodated in our laws, road ways, and market places.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by mikeash on Monday April 25, 2016 @02:04PM (#11566051)
I think journalists are responsible for understanding the facts and implications of what they discuss, regardless of how good the various players are at explaining it.

Yes, the manufacturers have a much stronger foundation from which to figure this stuff out, but that doesn't mean the rest of us can't stop doing silly things like acting as if human drivers were perfect when talking about potential autonomous vehicle systems.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by jimbokun on Monday April 25, 2016 @02:56PM (#11566419)
I think it's very difficult, though, to know what state of the art software driven vehicles are good at and not so good at, though. Maybe the missing-stop-sign-intersection was a problem in version 0.7.1 but fixed in patch 0.7.1.4.

Any good articles by engineers describing where current autonomous cars are still worse than humans? And which issues are just "bug that hasn't been fixed yet" vs. "we're still not sure how to solve this one in principle".

Agree, though, that a journalist should be interviewing real engineers and trying to summarize, paraphrase, and edit what he hears to the best of his or her ability, instead of just speculating.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by anexprogrammer on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:28PM (#11565342)
Humans would also improve with removed signage. There's quite a bit of research now that accident rates go down the more you remove street furniture and lines. Same with traffic lights - see the caution people use when the lights are out of order.

I'd hope that a self-driving car has the meta data on board rather than just relying on seeing the sign. I'd also hope that they're designed to treat all junctions with caution, not just those with missing signage.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by stormbrew on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:30AM (#11564841)
I was just about to comment on the same section. This kind of poorly thought out assertion throws a lot of shade on the rest of the article.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by jfoster on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:05PM (#11565631)
There's a lot of clicks & eyeballs associated with FUD articles about next-gen cars at the moment. (autonomous, electric, or both)

If you want to draw in a techie audience with clickbait, there's not much better you can do at the moment than writing about how Tesla has some sort of unforeseen flaw whereby both their electric & autonomous tech is doomed to failure.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by gambiting on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:39AM (#11564916)
I don't think it does. Sure, a car would know that a stop sign was there the last time it drove through that intersection, but you can always order the car to go someplace new. And I don't believe the dream that "oh, automatic cars will just have 100% accurate street data for every road in the civilized world". First of all because we don't have this data, and even if we did, I can't imagine a car hauling several terabytes of data with it(and how would you even update it, given that our internet connections seem to be getting worse, not better every year, with new data and speed caps being introduced?). It has to be able to decide autonomously, and since it has to be programmed to do something, it's a really hard problem. A human can just "use best judgement", but a computer can't - it either follows the rules or it doesn't. And roads are not a computer simulation - they are dynamic, they change, they require the sort of input that computers are horrible at, visual recognition is dreadful, our best, cream of the top software can't tell a difference between a zebra and a sofa in a zebra print, and yet most people just wave their hand at the problems facing automatic cars saying "oh, we will just use a machine learning algorithm to watch how humans drive and then follow that". Sure. But it doesn't magically solve the problems of responsibility where a computer does something it shouldn't have.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by harshalizee on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:01PM (#11565111)
I don't think you seem to understand how self driving cars work, or even how computers work. Firstly, the car itself need not have traversed the same road for it to have full information. It can be gathered from collective data from all the self driving cars. That means even if one car went through that intersection, it has some relevant data on it. Secondly, you're handwaving that humans are better with the "use best judgement", which is pretty much unquantifiable. Not to mention humans have "used best judgement" and still managed to crash into things. How are you sure that the algorithmic path taken by the onboard computer isn't far superior to best judgement? We already know that computers outclass us in terms of reaction times, why not this? Thirdly, you don't need to store terabytes of data to do anything in the same way you don't need to download the entire database of HN to browse the front page. Localized data would be sufficient. Even if everything is offline, the car would most likely just revert to its learning mode .. which is how most of the Google cars that are on the streets currently started off. Lastly, you're right we aren't 100% there when it comes to distinguishing zebras and couches. But for self driving cars, we don't need that. What we need is object detection, its velocity relative to us, and data on where its heading. All of which we have become pretty good at.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by gambiting on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:12PM (#11565201)
Regarding your last point - we sort of do need accurate detection. What if there is a balloon on the road? I wouldn't swerve to avoid hitting a balloon, but an automatic car is going to see a round, rather large object. It might as well be a 100kg rock, hitting which would be disastrous. What is the car going to do? Stop and tell you to investigate? How about piles of leaves, cardboard boxes, large soda bottles. If you live anywhere with wind you are going to get those on the road.

As for the "best judgement" part - if a human is about to get into an accident, they are going to do what feels best. It's not necessarily the best option, but no court would ever tell you "our simulation tells us that if you reacted 0.1s earlier you could have turned the wheels 30 degrees and hit a car with two occupants instead of four, who had better survival chances". A computer is going to make an algorithmic choice, and that's what the article was about - who makes the choice as to how the car should react? The owner? The manufacturer? The police? The insurer? Should it prioritize its owner life at the potential cost of other lives? Or minimise the damage to protect the interests of its insurers?

We don't think about cars in those categories because we don't(and I would say we can't) make those choices when we drive. But computers will have to be programmed in some way. A lack of stop sign is a specific type of intersection in itself(where anyone going from the right has priority but anyone coming from the left has to yield) - so the car would need to observe and learn. I'm not saying it's impossible, but it's very hard to do.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by Retric on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:47PM (#11565497)
If something can enter the road and you can't stop in time then you have already failed. Driver-less cars should never drive at a speed where they can't stop in time.

In terms of edge cases. Lidar gives a 3d image so a floating balloon is going to show up like a bird and not something to be dodged. Same is true of balls and other small fast moving objects, they are not going to ping as kids. An object on the road is going be detected in plenty of time to slow down and stop or just avoid it without hitting any thing. Or, more likely just driven over the wheels are the only contact point and clearance is high enough for many objects in the roadway.

Driver-less cars have vastly shorter stopping distances at all speeds so they can be safe at speeds humans can't. They also rarely need to hard break because they can start slowing down sooner. Dodging might be considered if traction is good and there is open space to move to.

PS: If human drivers where not killing 20,000 Americans a year then we might debate perfection. Until then, self driving cars that kill 1,000 people per month would be a massive improvement end of story.

PPS: Remember google's self driving car from last month is worse than whatever they end up putting into production. The first production cars are also going to be worse than whatever most people end up using.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by gambiting on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:57PM (#11565995)
"PS: If human drivers where not killing 20,000 Americans a year then we might debate perfection. Until then, self driving cars that kill 1,000 people per month would be a massive improvement end of story."

This is the biggest faulty argument in this entire discussion.

Imagine a radiotherapy machine. Statistically, due to operator errors, it delivers lethal dose of radiation to 1 patient every 10k patients. Then someone brings out a radiotherapy machine that doesn't need an operator, but statistically delivers a lethal dose of radiation every 100k patients. That machine would be banned faster than you can say litigation, even though statistically it saves lives vs. manually operated machines.

As soon as an automatic car kills the first person(be it due to faulty programming or mechanical breakdown) the manufacturer will recall all of them and the backlash will be huge, even if an average, they are still thousand times safer than manual cars.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by Retric on Monday April 25, 2016 @02:12PM (#11566121)
You might think that, but if you look at say the early history of cars society decided it was perfectly OK for them to kill pedestrians. As a nation we really don't care about small numbers of people being killed if we can get something from it.

Early on flying was incredibly dangerous and that hardly stopped anything. Hell, the general public gets killed at an air show and it's a non story.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by gambiting on Monday April 25, 2016 @05:19PM (#11567450)
Introduction of autopilot has reduced plane accidents dramatically, yet every time one fails it's a huge thing, thousands of planes get recalled and people get fired over bad code.

People disproportionally care about things we think we should control. Like that fire of a Tesla that happened some time ago - people didn't care that all in all, statistically, electric cars are a LOT less likely to catch fire than regular ones, but media wouldn't shut up about it for weeks, highlighting how dangerous it is to drive around with a huge battery pack(even though it's nonsense). If an automatic car has an accident, it will be a huge deal as well - because people will expect computers to be flawless, and if they make a mistake they will want the head of whoever made the computer.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by Retric on Monday April 25, 2016 @06:44PM (#11567996)
Bad press != major issue. Sure the FAA grounds aircraft for a little while after defects are located untill they are fixed. They don't scrap the aircraft or ban autopilots. They also do the same thing for mechanical issues.

In tesla's case it got press as tech news, and they kept selling cars just fine. Safty issues can impact sales, but that's rational and it takes a lot more than a one off.

IMO, none of these actually support your viewpoint.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by CM30 on Monday April 25, 2016 @03:08PM (#11566505)
" If something can enter the road and you can't stop in time then you have already failed. Driver-less cars should never drive at a speed where they can't stop in time."

So, what happens if something blows into or falls on a motorway? A car hurtling down the road at 70mph is going to have a hell of a time stopping for an unexpected obstacle, human controlled or otherwise.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by Retric on Monday April 25, 2016 @03:41PM (#11566767)
Not sure what your point is? Cars are not going to be dodging bullets or anything.

But, on a highway where it's safe to do 70MPH a deer running across the road is plenty slow enough to be stopped for. In terms of birds and bunny's just hitting them is the normal human response.

IMO, getting out into the once per year in the US edge cases is kind of missing the point. Ok, if your driving in a hurricane and a roof falls onto your car then yea your going to have a bad day meh.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by cc438 on Monday April 25, 2016 @02:44PM (#11566333)
3 Things:

1. "Driver-less cars have vastly shorter stopping distances at all speeds"

I can understand your expectation of reduced stopping distances due to the near-0 reaction time made possible by sufficient computing power. However, I wouldn't describe the computer's advantage as anything close to a "vast" one. There is no mechanical advantage to braking that is inherent for a driverless car and the difference in stopping distance due to reaction time is less than 1 car length (~10ft) at 30mph assuming the human driver has an average reaction times (0.25s). The advantage is still limited to roughly ~25ft at 60mph. That advantage is simultaneously significant and insignificant in that incredibly common outside factors will more than account for that disparity if not controlled for in the AI's programming. Tire pressure, tread depth, brake pad thickness, rotor wear, alignment, etc are all capable of individually accounting for a ~25ft reduction in stopping distance which leads me to my second point.

2. "Driver-less cars should never drive at a speed where they can't stop in time."

Real world driving conditions present so many uncontrolled variables that a speed considered "safe" by that logic will be pathetically slow. The current state of the art in driverless cars is Google's purely autonomous design which is limited to the pace of a golf cart (25mph). The number of variables introduced by vehicle condition and maintenance alone are so great that any vehicle capable of accurately accounting for each one would be impossibly expensive to buy and crushingly expensive to maintain. While all of our cars are capable of measuring speed (the legal maximum is +/- 5mph @ 50mph in the US, but +/-1-2% is most common) and most cars can measure tire pressure (+/-15% for the most common systems which measure indirectly with the ABS sensor), they don't measure either of those things accurately according to manufacturer specs and things only get worse over time. Personally, I can't see driverless cars ever growing past that hurdle, winding up limited to inner-city commuting/taxi duty.

3. "Same is true of balls and other small fast moving objects, they are not going to ping as kids."

This is actually one of the best examples of why speeds will have to remain slow enough to guarantee a negligible stopping distance.

If a human sees a ball roll into the street from behind an obstruction, they will reasonably deduce that there is a likelihood that a kid is chasing after it and slow down before the danger presents itself. An AI will see the balloon or ball and it will have to treat it as either a complete non-issue or as a mortal danger. If it treats it as a non-issue, it will have to be in a constant state of readiness to stop in the smallest reasonable distance, that means limiting speeds to a relatively glacial pace. If it treats it as a mortal danger, it will constantly produce false positives which leads to frustrated passengers when it brakes hard for every trashbag that blows across a 70mph highway.

That's one of my main criticisms of driverless cars in their current state. They are measurably superior in the areas in which human drivers are most flawed, yet their logic leads them to make decisions that no human would ever consider as logical. Even the most state of the art AI isn't even close to being able to account for the nearly infinite number of exceptions that stem from the chaos of the real world and which require an action contradictory to a principle of placing safety first. Just look at the first "unforced error" reported by the Google program where the AI's logic misjudged the actions of a bus due to logic which defined exceptions around the distance needed to merge on to a road. It just went for the merge, turning straight into the side (pretty much in the middle) of a bus moving at 15mph. No human would have made that decision.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by Retric on Monday April 25, 2016 @03:25PM (#11566647)
1. Don't confuse optimal human reaction times with real world conditions. Drivers don't have unwavering focus on the path ahead. Accidents are the exception when things go wrong, so the median accident reaction time would be far higher than under optimal conditions and really hard to measure. If a self driving car can't safely stop then it really should complain and just slow down. I can see "Speed reduced Tires balding" really would get most people into the shop and my car already tracks tire pressure and breaking. Add GPS for absolute location and it will notice if there is a problem. Listing for weather reports is also a no brainier.

2. Google is being conservative with several cars being tested at much higher speeds, don't forget in the computer world being 1/3 as fast is really far less of a jump than you might think. In terms of accuracy GPS can auto correct distance traveled over time to get much higher accuracy. Much like how most computers clocks are far closer to the correct time than their cheep HW clock would suggest.

3. Your thinking like a human. Kids are really really slow at 10mph (which is fast for a kid) 7.5 feet is over 1/2 a second. So, your car can drive like there is always someone about to jump out from every intersection and sprint across the road without being all that slow. Depending on sensor location they can also see under other cars. ED: the Front drivers side headlight is a much better location to see around parked cars than where a driver sits.

Worst case self driving cars might drive slow when stuff is right next to the road. But, if I can be productive and safe it's a non issue as most driving is not in those conditions and I should slow down anyway.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by intopieces on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:52PM (#11565525)
>A computer is going to make an algorithmic choice, and that's what the article was about - who makes the choice as to how the car should react?

Google has already said that this kind of decision making will not be a part of their cars' system. The car's reaction to situations is based on the rules that we all agreed on when we passed laws surrounding how humans are to behave on the road.

If the car encounter as obstacle, it will brake. It will not calculate death probabilities. It does not need to.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by mikeash on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:50AM (#11565009)
Uncontrolled intersections are a thing. Driverless cars will have to handle them as a matter of course, simply to be competent on the roads in the first place. They won't be able to simply assume that "no stop sign" means "no stop." This scenario is just an intersection which became uncontrolled through vandalism, rather than being built that way.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by galdosdi on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:34PM (#11565401)
Yes! This. Some commenters have never heard of driving defensively it seems. Do they really just barrel through uncontrolled intersections if they don't see a stop sign? For that matter, do they really just unthinkingly barrel through greens, always? If so, it probably means you live outside of the city, where you can grow accustomed to trusting that nothing unexpected will happen.

In the absence of any signage, there is always an implicit "Yield." -- ie, no requirement to stop, but you should look for conflicting traffic, and preemptively slow down enough so you could stop if there turns out to be conflicting traffic.

Heck, in some places even a green light is worth defensively treating as a Yield. In Manhattan, when driving, I barrel through green lights when crossing streets while going up avenues (in center lanes), but treat it more like a Yield, slowing to a quickly-stoppable speed, when going crosstown on streets across an avenue intersection. So what if you have a green light? In practice all three road user types, pedestrians, cyclists, and motorists run reds all the time. You're supposed to drive defensively, and a good driverless car should too.

Anyway, I think driverless cars have an implicit advantage here in that their reaction times will be substantially lower. Hopefully they can use statistical evidence to figure out rules like the above ("Treat greens on 3+ lane roads as "No Stopping" sign, but on smaller roads, treat them as yields")

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by JoeAltmaier on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:42AM (#11564945)
I don't see any issue whatsoever with a car carrying around terabytes of data. That's old-think. It will never again be difficult to put startling amounts of data into devices.

And the only data that needs to be kept updated, is the local environment. The car is in one place at a time. So bandwidth should not be the issue it would seem.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by gambiting on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:49AM (#11565002)
You are talking about a vehicle that would have to carry dozens if not hundreds of terabytes of data. The boot would literally have to be filled with hard drives. If you are in the US you should be able to tell it to drive from one coast to the other, or if you are in Europe the car should be able to drive from Warsaw, Poland, to Aberdeen, Scotland. And what do you mean only local data needs to be updated? Why? Updating a "dumb" TomTom map takes hundreds of megabytes a month just for one country, and we are talking about much more complex data, not just a 2D map.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by jameshart on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:55AM (#11565061)
"dozens of terabytes" aren't as big as they used to be: http://www.amazon.com/12TB-Desktop-External-Drive-WDBLWE0120...
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by peejaybee on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:00PM (#11565106)
Why do you need data for somewhere the car may never go? The car knows where it's going; it can get the data it needs when it needs it.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by drewmate on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:16PM (#11565235)
The car could have some sort of wireless (4G, WiFi, etc...) to download updated/detailed data for new routes when it needs it, and store locally what it will likely need again in the future. Since the car knows where it's going, as long as it has some idea of when it will be in range of a wireless access point, it can plan when and how it will download the rest of the trip information on the way.

As long as the car has basic route information and knowledge about where it will be able to connect to servers with updated information. Cars could drive anywhere with basic road info, and download updated and more detailed information (intersection metadata, possible closures, etc...) only as needed. It doesn't always need to be in wireless range, it just needs to know when it will be so it can plan accordingly.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by JoeAltmaier on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:51AM (#11565024)
It needs one large read-only copy of data, plus one hard drive with updates. Those updates are limited to say a 1000 mile range (most people don't travel 100 miles from home in a month; in any case most people travel the same routes)
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by gambiting on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:55AM (#11565067)
Sure, but if we want automatic cars to eventually replace manual cars we need to make sure they cover 100% use cases, not just most of them. Some people drive 10 miles to work and back, some people do 1000 miles a week driving through multiple countries. You need to deal with both, because nothing is stopping me from hopping in my car right this second and driving across the continent if I wish to do so. I wouldn't want an automatic car to hinder that freedom either.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by macjohnmcc on Monday April 25, 2016 @12:28PM (#11565354)
Before I go on a trip I download the latest map to my GPS. I'm sure cars can do the same.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by utexaspunk on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:48AM (#11564996)
Obviously any driverless car is not going to rely on street markings and signage alone. It's going to have sensors in all directions and see that a vehicle is headed toward the intersection at a speed which suggests it will not be able to stop in time to avoid a collision. That doesn't require some magical machine learning algorithm, and it will probably watch for this better than humans do. We tend to assume everyone else is following the rules and often don't notice when someone is about to run the stop sign and hit us.
Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by stormbrew on Monday April 25, 2016 @03:12PM (#11566537)
This is not the issue with that statement at all, and for the record I'm skeptical of cars sharing data to augment what they see (because this leaves them open to attacks that are unique to self-driving cars).

The problem with the statement is that it, as the GP post says, ignores the fact that a human driving a car is no less likely to barrel through an intersection with a missing stop sign.

There are a few other low level problems with this scenario as well, mostly hinging on the weird idea that self-driving cars are just going to barrel into an intersection without a stop sign as if there are no other cars going through it. This is why they have radar/lidar/whatever else.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by rayiner on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:39PM (#11565859)
And a sufficiently smart compiler could optimize Common Lisp to run as fast as c: http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?SufficientlySmartCompiler

The fact is that GPS navigation is a mature field (I.e. unlikely to get much better very soon), and is still very failure-prone. I just took an Uber this morning and twice the GPS got confused between the street I was going to and the on-ramp to the highway (the two roads were narrow and unusually close together). Twice, the driver followed the GPS instead of looking with his eyes at the road (the on ramp clearly looked like an on ramp). I run into these sorts of things 2-3 times a month.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by logfromblammo on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:54PM (#11565969)
An uncontrolled intersection means yield to traffic approaching from your passenger side for intersecting roads of equal importance, or vehicles on the minor road yield to through traffic on the major road. Yield signs usually just formalize this implicit intersection control. Taking out one stop sign is usually not an imminent hazard to traffic, but taking out two from perpendicular approaches might cause a problem. Removing all of them would actually be slightly more safe than a bad configuration of signs.

I expect my driverless car to be able to disobey signs when I indicate that it would be appropriate or necessary to do so.

I may one day enforce this by carrying around two poles that bear "stop", "do not enter + wrong way", "no u-turn", "do not reverse + severe tire damage", and "no stopping any time" signs on them, and creating pop-up paradox traps for unwary driving AIs.

Re:Why Cities Aren’t Ready for the Driverless Car by dsp1234 on Monday April 25, 2016 @01:01PM (#11565602)
Indeed, there is an intersection near where I live where the stop sign is removed and then later replaced (seemingly randomly, but probably not) every few weeks.

When there is a stop sign, I stop. When there is no stop sign, I don't stop.

Those are the rules of the road. Stopping for a stop sign that doesn't exist is breaking those rules, and thus putting other people in danger.