News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Achievement Porn by sgoranson on Saturday February 27, 2010 @11:02AM (#1155399)
Trying to define what should be meaningful for other people is pretty arrogant and an insular perspective on life.

My personal take on reality is that the whole shebang is a "meaningless treadmill", but I'm willing to accept that it might not be true for the next guy.

Re:Achievement Porn by pringle on Saturday February 27, 2010 @12:59PM (#1155566)
I don't get the upvotes for this comment.

Most of the philosophers we revere did exactly this -- define and put forth universal ideas for what is meaningful in life. No one is forcing these ideas on you, and it's easy to take shots at the "man in the arena" who steps forward to tackle a subject. I found it pretty interesting, as I had never thought much about the impact of this new class of "achievement" modern society has created.

These kinds of reactions only stifle dialogue and debate. I think it's generally understood that this is his opinion, and that he doesn't have designs to become a dictator and make this opinion the law of the land.

Re:Achievement Porn by nostrademons on Saturday February 27, 2010 @11:45PM (#1156452)
A lot of the other philosophers we revere did exactly the opposite - proclaim that nothing is meaningful in life, or that we're all just mistaken and can't express our ideas clearly. Eg. Nietzsche, Wittgenstein.
Re:Achievement Porn by sgoranson on Saturday February 27, 2010 @01:09PM (#1155578)
If it makes you feel any better, I enjoy taking potshots at revered ethicists as well.
Re:Achievement Porn by gcheong on Sunday February 28, 2010 @03:32PM (#1157414)
"...and that he doesn't have designs to become a dictator and make this opinion the law of the land."

Yeah, I think he wants to be the next Tony Robbins:

"My mission is to inspire people to think clearly, to live deliberately, to conquer fear and embrace possibility, to express beauty, and to love completely. Prepare to be scorched then reborn, authentic and complete."

Re:Achievement Porn by afgeneralist on Saturday February 27, 2010 @01:06PM (#1155577)
"Trying to define what should be meaningful for other people is pretty arrogant and an insular perspective on life." - I think this statement is lazy in that it's taking the cultural relativist approach. By this token, we shouldn't make judgment on female circumcision in Africa, or the one child rule in China. In their societies these practices have very important value but I think most of us probably feel like it's morally wrong.

I think we can argue there there is a world where there should exist universal qualities. I certainly wont knock the author for trying to argue video games inherently don't have the same value as say "going for a walk" and helping your family or community...

Re:Achievement Porn by derefr on Saturday February 27, 2010 @04:49PM (#1155897)
The interesting thing about both of your examples, is that they themselves are both examples of people "defining what should be meaningful for other people." Female circumcision is a statement by a culture that sex should not be desired by girls. The one-child rule is a statement by a culture that quality of life for its existing members is more important than quantity of life for its hypothetical ones. In either case, individual members of the culture may disagree, but then will be forced to conform to the culture's mores anyway—that is what we find repulsive about those policies.

As long as, on an individual level, people are free to choose their own utility function (as long as that function doesn't stop other people from choosing and partaking in their utility functions), then nothing else really matters on a grand-er scale. To put it another way: "cultural relativism" is wrong, but only because there is theoretically a perfect culture that allows its individuals to have individual relativism of ethics with a minimum of friction between individuals. The best culture is the transparent one people don't define themselves in terms of.

Re:Achievement Porn by jamesbritt on Saturday February 27, 2010 @02:55PM (#1155718)
'"Trying to define what should be meaningful for other people is pretty arrogant and an insular perspective on life." - I think this statement is lazy in that it's taking the cultural relativist approach.'

And the funny thing is, such statements come off as absolutist claims about how other people should not be making absolutist claims. I mean, isn't it pretty arrogant to declare someone else, um, pretty arrogant? :)

It's hard to criticize someone for criticizing someone, or to judge people for judging people.

Re:Achievement Porn by dx on Saturday February 27, 2010 @10:11PM (#1156343)
"I mean, isn't it pretty arrogant to declare someone else, um, pretty arrogant? :)"

Isn't it then also pretty arrogant to mean that it is pretty arrogant to declare someone else pretty arrogant? ;)

Re:Achievement Porn by nostrademons on Saturday February 27, 2010 @11:41PM (#1156444)
Yup. And it's pretty arrogant to imply that it's pretty pretty arrogant to mean that it is pretty arrogant to declare someone else pretty arrogant.

I think this thread is heading for a stack overflow.

Anyway, I think a lot of these self-referential paradoxes have a simple resolution. Just refuse to play. I'll do what I want, and I'll ignore whether everyone else thinks it's justified or not.

Re:Achievement Porn by zitterbewegung on Saturday February 27, 2010 @01:17PM (#1155596)
What gives you the power to decide what is good and what isn't? People should define themselves by their own merits and what gives them the most utility.
Re:Achievement Porn by sofal on Saturday February 27, 2010 @03:15PM (#1155756)
What? Is someone claiming power over objective definitions of right and wrong? I hope you understand that just because right and wrong are subjective doesn't render the model useless. What if it just so happens that a lot of this marvelous "utility" that you mention comes about through a reasonable consensus on morality, brought about through persuasion?
Re:Achievement Porn by sgoranson on Saturday February 27, 2010 @01:10PM (#1155582)
s/lazy/existentialist

Universal right and wrong just isn't my thing. YMMV

Re:Achievement Porn by mechanical_fish on Saturday February 27, 2010 @11:42AM (#1155450)
I agree. My take on this essay is that it is but an early milestone on the path to enlightenment. It asks an interesting question, but ends in a total cop-out, where the author literally claims that divining the meaning of life is "easy":

The easy part to culling the bullshit is to ask yourself: Is this activity making a positive, tangible difference in my life or anyone else’s life?

Easy for him, maybe.

It's fine to make the limited argument that certain games devolve a bit too quickly into flavorless tickling of the brain's pleasure centers. So long as you are clearly arguing about taste in game design, not about the ultimate meaning of life.

But when you decide to delve further, to the point that you've argued not just that crack cocaine and MMORPGs are ultimately meaningless, but also that education, money, casual acquaintances, success, and writing comments on HN are ultimately meaningless, shouldn't you keep going until you get to the end? Which would be something like:

All achievement is porn; that is, it is ultimately empty.

Although I would never phrase it that way; I prefer a more classical phrasing, like this [1]:

Life means suffering.

The origin of suffering is attachment to transient things and the ignorance thereof.

Now that is a general principle.

---

[1] I cribbed these lines from http://www.thebigview.com/buddhism/fourtruths.html , because that's what came up in Google. There are probably a few other sources... ;)

Re:Achievement Porn by kingsley_20 on Sunday February 28, 2010 @03:58AM (#1156666)
You're right. I play life because it's more fun to pretend that it's real than succumb to the inaction which would be the only logical response to the idea that it's not.

In other words, I seek the coin under the lamp rather than in the dark corner I lost it in, and I'm fine with that.

Re:Achievement Porn by bd on Saturday February 27, 2010 @11:17AM (#1155417)
The world is like a ride in an amusement park, and when you choose to go on it you think it's real because that's how powerful our minds are. The ride goes up and down, around and around, it has thrills and chills, and it's very brightly colored, and it's very loud, and it's fun for a while. Many people have been on the ride a long time, and they begin to wonder, "Hey, is this real, or is this just a ride?" And other people have remembered, and they come back to us and say, "Hey, don't worry; don't be afraid, ever. Because this is just a ride."

-- Bill Hicks

Re:Achievement Porn by jimbokun on Saturday February 27, 2010 @11:28AM (#1155434)
Isn't that just Zen Buddhism? Was Hicks a Buddhist?
Re:Achievement Porn by gruseom on Saturday February 27, 2010 @02:08PM (#1155664)
It certainly isn't just Zen. There are many spiritual traditions that quote could plausibly derive from. It sounds rather more Vedantic to me (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_%28illusion%29).
Re:Achievement Porn by hardik on Saturday February 27, 2010 @01:53PM (#1155637)
Could not help notice that this was also quoted in (in fact, was a subject of) one of Pete's older articles.
Re:Achievement Porn by Confusion on Sunday February 28, 2010 @07:32AM (#1156797)
He's not trying to define what should be meaningful: he simply accepts what people actually claim they consider to be meaningful and shows how their behavior does not lead to the kinds of achievements that they themselves consider meaningful.
Re:Achievement Porn by lsd5you on Saturday February 27, 2010 @01:57PM (#1155647)
You are equivocating. Not all paths are equal, or at least in the completely subjective/nihilistic universe in which they are, the words good and bad have absolutely no meaning. We have to have some value system, if only to maintain our standard of living.

Like most things, moderation is king. Extremely shallow but effective manipulations of behaviour are a bad thing. A lot of people consuming these will agree ultimately that they have wasted their time and post-hoc have prefered to been forced to do something more challenging and fruitful with the time.

Challenge, discipline and delayed-gratification remain virtuous (in my opinion) and good despite technological advances short circuiting reward sensations.