News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by dcposch on Friday April 22, 2016 @08:42PM (#11553541)
> ve has lots of vis personas

Are those typos?

You touched on the cyperpunk fantasy: using multiple online identities, all kept carefully separate from each other and from your real identity. (There's an excellent short story called True Names that explores this idea.)

For the majority of ordinary, nontechnical people, there are lots of simpler solutions.

* Use cash. In Berlin, many ordinary people have an awareness of and distaste for government surveillance. People remember East Germany. One result is that lots of people will just pay for everything in cash. In most other western countries, the norm is to leave an electronic trail of every single shop you visit.

* Use Signal or WhatsApp. WhatsApp rolled out strong end to end encryption to a billion people--most of whom have no idea what a "key" is and only the faintest sense of what "encryption" means.

The lesson I take from those projects is that whenever we can ship transparent, easy to use encryption that our users dont have to worry about, its a massive win.

If your app allows users to talk to each other privately, consider adding E2E encryption. It's the future.

If your app has some kind of cloud backup, like a password manager or a photo app, make sure that it's encrypted with a key that you don't have access to.

E2E comes with product tradeoffs. You may have to charge your users money, because you cant target ads against data you cant access. You'll need to make an installed app rather than a webapp. But its worth it -- and I think someday, hopefully soon, users will demand it.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by mirimir on Friday April 22, 2016 @09:59PM (#11553755)
No, they're gender-neutral pronouns:

ve = she/he

ver = him/her

vis = hers/his

I encountered them in Greg Egan's Diaspora.

And yes, True Names :) An inspiration.

With a decent host machine, one can run numerous Whonix instances, each with one or more personas. They can be long-term or throwaway.

I do nothing at all private on smartphones. Signal and WhatsApp are cool and all, but radios are untrustable black boxes. Even if the data is secured at rest.

Edit: In Egan's Diaspora, one of the protagonists is a software-generated entity, which literally has no gender. In my case, I'm referring to invented personas, which have whatever gender I fancy.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by Semiapies on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:58PM (#11553916)
Tangentially, I prefer the Spivak pronouns sets. They feel more "natural" to me than spiking the distributions of X and V.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by rwallace on Saturday April 23, 2016 @04:21PM (#11557251)
Personally I like David Brin's solution from the Uplift novels. Most of the things we want to say have nothing to do with sex and apply regardless of gender, so if we aren't going to let the same words double for male and gender-neutral usage, keep the traditional, simple words for the latter usage and move the former to something else. Thus, in Brin's novels, 'man' refers to any human with no implication of gender, and the words for a specifically male or female human are 'mel' and 'fem'.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by randommodnar on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:09AM (#11555397)
It's definitely more natural. You'll never hear any significant number of English speakers saying bullshit like "ve, vis".
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by mirimir on Saturday April 23, 2016 @06:57PM (#11557772)
Yeah, I get that. I normally use they/them/their. But then I'm stuck in plural. That does generally flow better, but sometimes... Anyway, I used to like s/he, but there's nothing elegant for him/her and his/hers.

Edit: Oops, this was in the wrong subthread, so now I have maybe a duplicate. Damn.

[dead]
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by roywiggins on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:37PM (#11553858)
Languages do exist with gender-neutral pronouns. Is Hungarian full of "sjw" crap? Adding a gender neutral pronoun to English isn't a crazy idea- "sibling" is a gender-neutral 20th Century invention and it fits in fine. I'm partial to "they" as the easiest option (it has a long history of being used in the singular) but constructed pronouns would work too.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by randommodnar on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:06AM (#11555385)
It's not crazy. English speakers tend to use "they" when they need a gender-neutral option. This just sounds like some edgy teenager... ooh look at me, I'm using some invented new pronouns because of the injustices I've never actually faced myself.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by intopieces on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:56PM (#11556314)
Why does someone have to face injustice themself to do something about it? White people faught for abolition and in the civil rights movement, straight people are the reason we have gay marriage...

Or is it just that you fundamentally disagree with the "need" for gender neutral pronouns and this is your way of ridiculing it? I'm afraid I don't follow your logic at all.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by komali2 on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:53PM (#11553899)
They is the easiest, and already fully adopted, option. Why bother trying to add another?
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by ajkjk on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:11AM (#11554118)
Are you unable to think of an argument? It's not hard to list some ways in which using 'they' as a singular pronoun when gender is ambiguous is confusing and undesirable. It's not a stretch to then argue we should have a better alternative.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by stephengillie on Saturday April 23, 2016 @02:05AM (#11554368)
It's like how some languages don't have ternary operators. We just have to muddle through and sometimes "take the long way" to describe someone without implying a gender or sex or other attribute.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by return0 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @04:51AM (#11554754)
"They" has a logical connotation that it translates to "either he or she" (hence the plural). Something like "ve" seems to imply "neither he nor she" , as if, "something else". That's why it may alienate ppl.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by mirimir on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:05PM (#11557802)
Doesn't "they" mean more than one person, without specifying gender?
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by xg15 on Saturday April 23, 2016 @04:00AM (#11554638)
That might be, however languages usually evolve on their own.

Simply inventing a new word and expecting that suddenly everyone understands it feels arrogant and leads to discussion derailments like this one.

I would also agree that "they" is the best choice.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by roywiggins on Saturday April 23, 2016 @04:16PM (#11557232)
I would argue that languages evolve when someone needs to express a concept and reaches for a word, finds nothing, and improvises. The first person who does it always stands out, but if other people around them have the same need, the word catches on. Eventually, the perception of arrogance mellows and it becomes an ordinary word.

I don't like artificial pronouns either, they stick in my mouth and feel weird, and I'm lazy so I use they. But other people have other preferences or needs so I try to tamp down any unproductive instinctive reaction in myself- who am I to say in a hundred years we won't be using them? After all, our post-singularity AI offspring won't have the same idea of gender as we do...

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by randommodnar on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:18AM (#11555421)
Also, sibling is not a 20th century invention in gender neutrality. Sibling is an old English word meaning a kinsmen or relative. It simply saw a revival in the 20th century and had its meaning narrowed to mean only brother or sister.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by roywiggins on Saturday April 23, 2016 @03:57PM (#11557152)
You're right, but when people began to hear it again in the 20th century, they didn't think "ah, I know that word! It's Old English." It wasn't, at the beginning of the 20th Century, an English word at all.

I'm not sure reintroducing a word from a long-dead language (even if it's an antecedent to your own) is much different from just making a new word up, other than it might sound a bit better if the language is related. Words can come from anywhere; why not invent the ones you need? Laser radar quark...

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by mirimir on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:38PM (#11553860)
Hey, you don't think that all of my personas would profess the same gender, do you?
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by komali2 on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:52PM (#11553897)
Why is your OP getting downvoted? Are we assuming they're an SJW because they informed us of the popular meaning of those words?

I knew what those words meant and would have shared as well, despite how much I detest the SJW movement.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by mirimir on Friday April 22, 2016 @11:06PM (#11553951)
Damn, I don't even know what SJW is, without googling it ;)

Edit: Oh, social justice warrior. Meh. Me, I'm just an old anarchist ;)

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by nickpsecurity on Saturday April 23, 2016 @01:11AM (#11554245)
It's a person suffering from Saint John's Wart per Google. Apparently, it's been going through the bloodstream into the brain to have mental effects that are hard for scientists to characterize. Suffice it to say, it may be responsible for a good chunk of non-video traffic on the Internet and its victims may not even understand why they involved themselves. DARPA and the FDA are said to be teaming up to deal with the epidemic but the results remain to be seen so far.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by solipsism on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:48PM (#11553885)
The thing that's infesting the net is the kind of dbag comment you just posted. You apparently don't even understand the purpose of gender-neutral pronouns, and yet you feel the need to express your opinion about an irrelevant subject.

You should try to stay on topic around here, and take that kind of vitriol elsewhere.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by ashitlerferad on Saturday April 23, 2016 @12:28AM (#11554158)
Most cash is easily surveilled as it has serial numbers on it. Only coins are a safe form of cash but have a huge disadvantage of being exceptionally bulky.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by shabble on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:50AM (#11555157)
That would assume a comprehensive system of serial number scanning at point-of-sale in order to track the movements and actually connect it with people/purchases.

The technology is probably available, and it's entirely possible that ATMs could be recording serial numbers of dispensed cash and tying them to the account used, but it's (presently) deeply unrealistic that every possible (or even most) places that accept paper money have the ability or desire to record serial numbers of incoming & outgoing bills.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by sievebrain on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:48AM (#11555503)
You're falling victim to the same trap as what Snowden is talking about.

Serial numbers on bills are routinely scanned and tracked. There's a discussion here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/3ou4h4/e...

It's not done at the point of sale. It's done when the money is returned to the banks themselves, and when they're dispensed at ATMs. Cash doesn't circulate for long and anti-money laundering laws prevent payment for many expensive items in cash, so this can provide important clues about where the money goes.

For instance, withdraw money from an ATM, pay for food at your local grocery shop, and the bank/govt can see "withdrawal from account Herr Schmidt at 7:03pm Thursday, deposited by a grocery store down the road the next day" and conclude the money was used to buy food ... or at least had at most one hop in between.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by mirimir on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:22PM (#11557855)
Yes, and that's problematic for mailing cash anonymously. It's not so easy to accumulate large denominations, and may attract attention. When possible, I like to mail gold. It's easy to clean, too.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by ashitlerferad on Sunday April 24, 2016 @07:24AM (#11559316)
We need people operating mixes for cash and SIM cards.

Dump $50, get a random bunch of notes that add up to $50.

Dump a prepaid SIM, get a new prepaid SIM.

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by 1stop on Friday April 22, 2016 @09:48PM (#11553722)
You can't E2E with a web app?
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by MichaelGG on Friday April 22, 2016 @11:10PM (#11553964)
No, not really. Until there's a standard that allows doing crypto in the browser, enforcing a higher security level for the page, and somehow verifying the hash of contents (so sites can "publish" an app) then web apps are basically useless for security.

I know this is as pathetic as "why aren't scientists working on cancer instead of X", but we have WebXXX including Bluetooth and USB, you'd think we'd have "WebVerifiedApps" or something. Even content-addressable URIs aren't being allowed.

It's funny, given the rise of things like Tutanota, which provide basically zero security over Gmail. (In fact, probably worse, since Google's sec team is way better.)

Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by losteric on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:13PM (#11553803)
To some degree yes, for example you could use something like https://github.com/openpgpjs/openpgpjs to encrypt from one customer to another across even your own infrastructure, but (afaik) the browser VM is an incredibly insecure platform to run a "secure" application.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by detaro on Friday April 22, 2016 @10:53PM (#11553905)
It's even harder than with a normal application for a user to verify that you didn't change the code to one with a backdoor.
Re:Edward Snowden: The Internet Is Broken by happyslobro on Saturday April 23, 2016 @05:13AM (#11554799)
I wonder, would it be possible to build a secure P2P client using encrypted Media Extensions and WebRTC? Going to check to see if EME supports encryption as well as decryption...

update No. EME is only intended to be used by content consumers; even if it could be hacked to encrypt uploads / outgoing transfers, that use case wouldn't even be considered important as the spec evolves. Super lame.