I remember how great email was before GMail:
1. Every few days I had delete emails so that I can get new email.
2. Delete sent mail immediately to make space for new emails.
3. More than 50% of emails received are spam.
Yeah right GMail was one that stopped progress of email :)
Gmail hasn't had nearly the stifling effect that one might assume!
Such as?
My morning routine involves marking at least ten emails as spam on my gmail account. They really aren't the be all and end all of spam blocking.
My non-gmail account (on an address that has been around for almost a decade before gmail existed) running a more modern anti spam solution, not nearly as bad.
Why can't they sell products and be
like an Apple, Oracle, Microsoft.
Econ 101 on HN again.Aside from what Google's doing. You're assuming that the value someone personally derives from using something is the value other people derive from pushing it to them.
I.e. you have ads on Google, some of which cost >$10. To the companies paying for them that makes sense, because they might be selling a product that costs $500-1000, with say 10% conversion.
But a user is never going to be persuaded to pay >$10 simply to click a link.
So yes, there are some things Google does for free that they could be selling, but a) they may not be easy to sell directly b) even if people bought them it wouldn't make up the difference they make from ads, because the value isn't on the consumer side, it's on the advertiser's side.
(for the people who don't want to eat them)
Expected value of a class-action asbestos lawsuit = Millions? 10s of millions?
For mesothelioma, an in-person referral from a doctor to an attorney is worth well over $10,000. Of course the doctor doesn't get paid until after the successful suit - but even discounting the time value of money, it's easy to see how advertising at $50/click could work out.
Google could not just become a wildly profitable Apple-style "hardware first" company overnight (or, arguably, ever).
Conversely, we have all seen Apple struggling to deliver cloud services that are reliable and desirable (beyond their integration into Apple's ecosystem) since the days of iTools and MobileMe..
Do you feel like the NFL will be a better company once it rids itself of that pesky "football" dependence ?
Will McDonalds finally break free of the hamburger racket and flourish as a company ?
Google isn't some company that just happens to make a bunch of money from ads - they are an advertising company. Period. The end. Online ads stemming from search results is the thing they do.
It sure sounds neat to bootstrap a world-beating conglomerate and dominate all market spheres with your plexes full of big brains, but it's not going to happen.
It's not going to happen.
They will live and die with the search ads. They will not disrupt the car industry. They will not launch rockets to mars. They will not solve homelessness.
The other option is to make your product hard to copy by network effects or data collection, but again, here it's natural for the cheapest guy to win.
And good products that didn't have ads like google reader get shutdown :/
Why can't they sell products and be like an Apple, Oracle, Microsoft. I am guessing it's too much work to grow in such a massive pace without ads. Ads are a marketers/sales persons dream and these marketers are very likely to spend money.
This ad economy is so very sad and it's killed many nice things. Everyone is just giving out things for free and nobody wants to pay for anything thanks to this whole ad economy. News reporting has gone to the dogs because nobody wants to pay. Email will no see decent progress thanks to gmail.
Anyway, I feel Google will be a much better company if it can get rid of dependence on ads but I guess it's too late now since it has to answer to shareholders and show never ending growth.