Blithely pronouncing a radical view to be "scientific consensus" on the most divisive of topics is a form of trolling. I've noticed that users who do this invariably display how far from dispassionate science their interest in this subject really is. There's also some irony in how fixated they are on the topic of intelligence—a quality that somehow never seems to distinguish these threads.
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11539519 and marked it off-topic.
As a suggestion - do you know that "18" means "Hitler" in some circles? Like, 1=A (because it's the first letter of the English alphabet), 8=H (the 8th letter). A and H - A for Adolf, H for Hitler. Do you think this is going to make people more likely, or less likely, to support the building of this society you propose?
As if that weren't enough, you're on a hiding to nowhere with this in general, I'm afraid.
Suppose you are right. What then? You'll have to stir up so much shit to prove it that there'll be no profit. Sometimes you have to accept second best in the interests of peace. This is especially true when people are involved. "But but but" - no, shut up. There is no "but". This is how people work, and you're stuck with it.
Or suppose you are wrong. And then everybody is justly ignoring you.
This is so untrue, I'm not sure if you're being sarcastic or not. The overwhelming consensus by scientists at reputable top universities don't allege this at all. But I'm sure you can find it at fringe or less reputable state universities.
https://jaymans.wordpress.com/hbd-fundamentals/#Race-IQ
Much effort has been made to minimize the effect of poverty, stereotyping, and other non-hereditary factors in much of the literature.
Most people downvoting the parent are likely doing so because this research is uncomfortable, not because it is wrong.
Like who? Stephen Jay Gould?
a cursory glance
Maybe you should give it a closer look so you're not resting your worldview on confirmation bias.
Lots of groups develop their own consensus. That still does not mean it's correct.
The main problem is that they want to find an arbitrary metric and then prove that there is a racial variance to it. I would claim that this is a variant of P-mining[0].
They take the concept of "IQ" within the context of the tests to be a scientifically concrete measure like height or weight (which it isn't) than then search for datasets which supports their racial superiority hypothesis.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_dredging
Also, Any list that contains the name "Tatu Vanhanen" should be immediately suspect. He's one of the known "racial IQ" crackpots.
This is a false statement: The overwhelming consensus by scientists at reputable top universities don't allege this at all.
As was commonly noted at the time... few who signed it were measurement experts. Note the lack of prestigious programs of the signatories. This is the Wall Street Journal fringe. Certainly not the mainstream of top researchers in the field.
Who are these "non-fringe" you speak of? People who tell you what you want to believe? HuffPo bloggers?
Or are you just blowing hot air, totally ignorant of this field in general, and decided to call some people you've never heard of "fringe"...
You mean men right? I'm sure there's no bias in that process...
So this seems like a wash... Except that it doesn't take much to observe that it's very hard to be raised in the same circumstances when you're of different races in the US. There are very real differences in people's behavior towards people based on race, and those shape that environment.)
very hard to be raised in the same circumstances when you're of different races in the US.
Adopted siblings...
And these differences don't only present themselves in the US.
Science does not require trust. The wonder of the scientific method is that any old nutty crank (given the ability to convince a small panel of his peers of the merits of his crank cred) can get an article published. Then it's up to the community of malicious and slightly less nutty cranks to gleefully prove him wrong.
That's why the method goes wrong when you trust someone. Which is really hard when it's not your field, and you're just looking for someone with authority on the subject. But the reality is that the loudest voices with a lot of media time often also tend to be the nutty cranks, rather than the slightly less nutty cranks.
Holy fuck. Yeah. I'm calling you out for being a racist fuck. Your "human biodiversity" aka "scientific racism" is a pseudoscience that has no basis at all. All your ideas better explained by economics.
So in conclusion, fuck you.
[META] Not due to the content of the response, but the fact that dang, who is rightfully vigilant about enforcing standards of civility all over HN (with detachment, warnings, and bans), willfully ignores blatant violations of said standards where ideology aligns.
Still, i upvoted you, and hopefully you won't get banned.