Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ...
by brianwawok on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @10:04AM
(#11534430)
The average person sees maybe 600 ads a day asking them to buy something, and maybe 2 ads telling them to save more (using overpriced financial advisor X).
Not saying people have no responsibility, but the odds are kind of stacked against you - it is an uphill battle to survive.
Re:Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 ...
by SilasX on Wednesday April 20, 2016 @04:42PM
(#11537585)
But the Ponzi scheme aspect of SS is (mostly) orthogonal to its "forced savings" aspect. If the revenues from its taxes had been invested like a sovereign wealth fund, even very conservatively, it would be in much better shape.
Instead, it was "invested" in government bonds, which is equivalent to saying, "oh, I'll just raise the money later". But that's courting disaster: if you have these unfunded obligations that come due, you have to gore an increasingly difficult amount of taxes out of your base, which can become rapidly impossible if and when people start fleeing from the burden.
We could have kept the forced savings but given people back more than a real dollar per dollar forced to contribute.
> The author isn't mysteriously broke. Money is not being stolen from his account. Rather, he's spending a lot of money on things which he believes are necessities (like paying for a child's wedding), and sacrificing a lot of things which he believes is optional (like having retirement savings). Some would suggest both categorizations are wrong.
Bingo.
As much as I think of social security as a ponzi scheme, one thing I do like about it is that it forces people to contribute and they can't touch their contributions. Sure you might only get $.60 back for every dollar you throw in there but hey at least you'll get something.
It's sad to say it, but the majority of people are not financially savvy enough to make sound decisions. Left to their own devices most people wouldn't save diddly squat, work till they're fired, then be destitute. And they probably won't have kids to take care of them anymore either because "Kids are expensive ... you can't afford that!".