It's not like "booking places to sleep in foreign countries" was waiting for a new technological innovation; rather, the existing regulatory frameworks in play placed a cost floor and a high barrier to entry for competitors.
Much the same way that a municipality artificially constrains the amount of cabs on the road, a municipality artificially constrains hotels by zoning specific parts of town for hospitality use. Most cities won't let you open up a bed and breakfast in any given residential neighbourhood.
--
In this view, as articulated by TFA, both Uber and Airbnb owe their success to a) being cheaper and b) having greater supply, both artifacts of their ability to _skirt existing regulation_ their competitors can't avoid.
Can you think of a different successful 'Uber for X'?
Also important to note, that Uber does a few things exceptionally well that most other "Uber for X" companies fail with at least one or more:
1) Dramatically increase convenience / quality of service
2) Lower or comparable costs to alternative (esp UberX vs Taxi and vs your own car)
3) Have a demo-able product. Viral word of mouth is so simple when you can literally take your friend for a ride.
Most other on-demand services fail at one of these. Spoon rocket in your example, first started as a more expensive convenience play, then as they tried to scale up, lowered quality (violating #1) in order to compete on price (#2). This is why I stopped using them and also why I don't use their competitors like Sprig and Munchery, just too expensive for what it is.
Uber/AirBnB just straight up ignored laws regulating their industry. They bet that regulators wouldn't crack down too hard and they were right. But not every industry is regulated like taxis/hotels. Imagine a food startup that violates health and cleanliness regulations, or a finance startup that ignores the SEC.
Looks like in 2012 Georgia was "pending." I'm in Atlanta, so there were no regulations in place when my friend started.
But what Uber did was notice that due to regulation, the taxi drivers were receiving wage X, while there existed a lot of people that would be more than happy to do the same job for less than X. Find some loophole in the legislated price floor that allows you to employ that section of the supply curve and you've got a big profit opportunity. You can't cut corners in an existing, fairly efficient market, and call it the same thing.
1. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/28/upshot/under-pressure-from...
Agree. "Uber for X" should really mean "Supply and Demand clearing house/exchange for x".
Uber: the x is personal transportation. Demand = people that need to be transported, Supply = people that have room to transport people. Uber provides a technology based solution - a clearinghouse that pairs the demand to the supply for a fee.
AirBnB: the x is short to mid term rooming/housing. Demand = people that need housing, Supply = people that have extra rooms / houses. AirBnB provides a technology based solution - a clearinghouse that pairs the demand to the supply for a fee.
If you find a market that has excess supply and excess demand, but no modern software / technology based clearinghouse that VC hasn't tried, you should go for it - chances are you'll be able to corner the market and become very successful. (Just how much will depend on the size of the market...)
PS. If anyone makes this a business, please just credit me for the idea :)
http://www.upi.com/Business_News/2016/04/19/UberEats-to-end-...
What are the essential differences? Uber delivers a simple product, a car ride, that even a minimally skilled contractor can complete. SpoonRocket delivers pre-made meals. Complication is added in having to design, cook, and package pre-made meals.
For SpoonRocket, overhead costs exist in the forms of delivery fees: for Uber, no such fees exist. The delivery itself is the product. For SpoonRocket, the real product is the (instant) meal, not the delivery. SpoonRocket had so many costs that in order to turn a profit, they ended up trying to save on meal quality -- and in turn promptly lost their userbase.
SpoonRocket cannot meaningfully differentiate itself from its competitors: who really wants to try another service for delivery meals when you could just order GrubHub or Seamless? The folks at SpoonRocket were effectively trying to start a restaurant, which is a hard business with tons of near-equivalent competition. On the other hand, Uber clearly and meaningfully beats taxis, both in terms of price and experience.
We know that on-demand businesses are hard. We know that food businesses are hard. Combining them, guess what? Not easy.
Let's talk about an actual "Uber for X" companies that is doing well: take Airbnb. Airbnb allows you to take your existing property (spare room, couch, whatever) and with extremely little effort begin renting out access to that property, but only when you want. This is similar to Uber, which allows you to take your existing property (car) and make some extra money by driving every now and again.
The conclusion here is that Uber is an on-demand service from the customer side only. From the service-providing side, Uber is among the very first of its kind (you can tell that from the fact that Uber has completely subverted the employee/contractor distinction -- there's extremely little legal precedent for a business like Uber).
Thus, it is a severe mistake to look at other businesses that provide on-demand services from the customer side, and to conclude that such a business is "Uber for X". It's only "Uber for X" if it's similar from the service-providing side, which very few businesses are.