News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by graycat on Monday April 18, 2016 @11:57AM (#11520915)
I've been a prof: Academics is awash in non-objective pushing and shoving that, yes, affects careers. In academics, even high end universities, a lot of the nasty behavior of middle school is still alive and well. Added to that is grown up politics, professional jealousy, professional competition with sabotage, and, also, no doubt, sexual harassment as in the OP.

I can't speak first hand about sexual harassment because I'm a normal male and never knowingly harassed a female. But, gee, right, there were some times: (1) I was chair of the college computer committee, and she was in the administration and invited me to her office to talk about computing. She leaned back in her chair, put her feet up on her desk aimed at me so that I could see under her skirt and said "My husband and I have an open marriage". Well, my wife and I don't. (2) I was a consultant, say, an applied statistician, in a computing center, and a new prof on campus in sociology with some survey data came to see me about processing the data. She started talking about finding things in her data and said that she was "looking for sex". Then she kept saying she was "looking for sex". Gee, those women were trying to harass me sexually? No, I didn't have any "nightmares"!

Similar things can go on in parts of business.

My mother used to say that a young woman should carry a six inch long, sharp hat pin and be prepared to insert it into any man who got too fresh. We're talking an old story. Maybe I should start a Web site to sell long, sharp hat pins with some instructions on usage.

If we could get rid of all the sexual harassment, then we will discover that, once have some good work, others afraid of losing out in competition will start to fight back, with whispering campaigns, sabotage, gang behavior, etc.

I saw one female prof have a nice little tactic: She never said anything about her research. So, she never gave anyone any hint about what she was doing. Then, suddenly, in one 12 month period, she published five nice papers in one of the best journals in the field. Presto. Bingo. In a baseball analogy, she had hit a home run, or call it a grand slam, had rounded all the bases, and was home free. Five papers in one of the best journals one year? Tough to fight with that, i.e., whispering campaigns mostly won't work. BTW, I was the faculty member who proposed hiring her -- her qualifications looked good to me.

Is being a prof a nice job? Not very.

For one, it's super tough to get paid well enough to buy a nice house and do well supporting a family. Even if get tenure, that doesn't mean that your salary has to keep up with inflation. It can seem better just to be in business, e.g., start and own a successful business, where actually make some money and can accumulate it for some real financial security.

Second, really, to get very far in academics, have to pay close attention to money anyway -- have to get grants. So, can begin to feel like are in business anyway.

Third, in business, it's fairly easy to know how to keep score -- the units are dollars. In academics, we're talking numbers of papers, numbers of invited talks, numbers of journal editorships, number of dollars of grant money, prestige, number of citations, etc. So, it's tough to count and/or compare. For a successful business owner, the criteria are simpler to count and compare -- e.g., a bank statement or, if you will, an account's report.

I have always felt protective of girls and women, and I hate to see them have "nightmares" over anything. But, honey, and I say this out of 100% affection, caring, and respect, out in the real world, there is lots of pushing and shoving, and there still will be even without men trying to kiss you, knocking on your hotel room door at 3 AM, sending you suggestive messages, etc.

Or to borrow from and paraphrase E. Fromm in The Art of Loving, "For humans, the fundamental problem in life is responding to the anxiety from our realization that alone we are vulnerable to the hostile forces of nature and society. The first recommended solution is love of spouse." Well, honey, and, again, I mean this with full affection, caring, and respect, one of the "hostile forces of society" is the nearly eternal force of men pursuing friendship, affection, sex, domination, etc.

For such men, part of the solution is a ready supply of clear, loud statements "No. Stop. Quit.". For more, there is that long, sharp hat pin. For more, be in a public place and scream. For more, be with some girlfriends.

Indeed, one of Fromm's other recommended solutions is "membership in a group". It's easy to remember the TV ads for the TV show The Babysitters Club with six or eight very pretty teenage girls walking on a sidewalk close together with each girl trying harder than all the others to be in the center of the group -- it was herd formation, and the TV people believed that it was credible. So, right, females tend "form herds", look like herd animals, and with good reason: They have more safety in a herd, as a member of a "group". So, right, form groups via Twitter, Facebook, fora, one to one e-mail, face to face, etc.

E.g., it was totally clear to a girl I knew of 12, and one of her girlfriends of 11, each about 100 pounds, that they would feel much safer with me, 6' 3" and 14, if they were together and in a public place instead of alone with me in private. Since those girls of 11 and 12 knew about the safety of being in a public place and not alone instead of in a private place and alone, I'm sure the women of the OP can understand that. So, use that tactic.

But, still, honey, that's not nearly the only problem you will face out in the real world. And, again, notice Fromm's first recommended solution -- "love of spouse". That is, have a good marriage with a good husband.

Honey, for a lot of the problems you face in the outside world, sexual harassment is one of the easiest to deal with because (A) it is relatively easy to prove (e.g., smartphone and message recordings), (B) in its more serious forms is very definitely seriously illegal, i.e., you can hire a lawyer, and (C) there is the solution of that hat pin, or just your long, sharp fingernails. But for whispering campaigns, jealousy, sabotage, gang up behavior, etc., defense is more difficult.

Honey, definitely you should protect yourself, and you do have some strong means. But out in the real world some guy trying to get too close to you is not your biggest problem and not what any nightmares, if there are to be any, should be about. Honey, relax; you are overreacting to the wrong thing.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by ksenzee on Monday April 18, 2016 @12:44PM (#11521251)
"Honey"? Who on earth do you think you're talking to? Please tell me this post is performance art and not the way you actually talk to women in your real life.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by graycat on Monday April 18, 2016 @01:04PM (#11521418)
Again, over again, yet again, one more time, once again, this time just for you, I clearly, clearly, clearly, more than once, clearly, very clearly, fully unambiguously, said, fully clearly, right there,

"... honey, and I say this out of 100% affection, caring, and respect"

And I said "honey" with "100% affection, caring, and respect".

100%. Clearly.

> Please tell me this post is performance art and not the way you actually talk to women in your real life.

I wrote this post here in this blog for just the right reason, to be helpful and in response to the OP. The OP was all about personal, feminine, intimate things, and "constant nightmares", and I responded in a corresponding way. That is, the women were having "nightmares" and, as men, we are supposed to be and should be concerned, to be protective, to have sympathy and empathy. And I do, and did, and so posted here.

My response was fully appropriate for and corresponding to the content of the OP -- fully.

Or, again, once again, over again, the OP was about some intimacy and correspondingly so was my response.

For "in your real life", the OP was not much like what women would talk about in real life around an office, which is the professional context of the OP, and neither is my caring, sympathetic "honey". For my post here, there is nothing, nothing, Nothing, NOTHING wrong with "honey" -- instead, "honey" is fully appropriate, affectionate, what one would say to a daughter, sister, niece, or any girl or women having "constant nightmares".

Your response is not against the content I included. You said nothing about my content. That content is not easy to discover, and I posted it to help those OP women with "constant nightmares". My content should help them a lot. I know some things about anxiety in women -- what I posted should help, a lot. E.g., as I posted, I've been a prof and seen a lot in academics, and also in business, IBM, GE, FedEx, and more, and only a tiny fraction of readers here at HN have the advantages of that background to post in response to the OP here. What I posted should be seen as darned helpful. But, you are attacking me, me, personally, not the content of my post, and based on your assumption of something about my behavior in real life and not in my post.

You are extrapolating for no good reason. You owe me an apology and a retraction of your attack.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by nkurz on Monday April 18, 2016 @04:02PM (#11522751)
My response was fully appropriate for and corresponding to the content of the OP -- fully.

I realize you are certain of this, but I'm equally certain that a vast majority of those who would write the original post would consider your suggestions to be "part of the problem". Perhaps they are wrong, but from their viewpoint your response is indistinguishable from parody.

And I said "honey" with "100% affection, caring, and respect".

Assume that we were discussing a post by a older male African-American software engineer lamenting the impact of racial discrimination on his career. Then assume that you kept addressing him as "boy" while proclaiming your sympathy for the "plight of the Negro condition". Although possibly well-intentioned, this is how your response strikes others.

But, you are attacking me, me, personally, not the content of my post, and based on your assumption of something about my behavior in real life and not in my post.

No, 'ksenzee' is offering you valuable feedback on how a majority of working-age Americans would view your approach. It's not extrapolating to actions beyond your post, merely reacting strongly and negatively to the sentiment you express. You clearly disagree, but this doesn't make it an attack, just a major difference in world view.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by graycat on Monday April 18, 2016 @08:10PM (#11524010)
> Then assume that you kept addressing him as "boy" while proclaiming your sympathy for the "plight of the Negro condition". Although possibly well-intentioned, this is how your response strikes others.

I grew up in the Old South: Addressing a US Black, "boy" is always an insult. Since growing up, I've seen a lot of the US: Addressing a woman in distress, e.g., "constant nightmares", affectionately, "honey" is quite appropriate with nothing wrong at all.

For your

> It's not extrapolating to actions beyond your post,

clearly my

> You are extrapolating for no good reason.

was in response to the ksenzee

> Please tell me this post is performance art and not the way you actually talk to women in your real life.

So, the ksenzee "extrapolation" was

> the way you actually talk to women in your real life.

Of course not. Again, yet again, once again, over again, one more time, the OP was not 'the way the women in the OP would talk to people in an office in real life' but was, as I said, over and over, intimate and my post was in that context and similar and also not as in "real life". That is permissible without being too personal due to the OP and the anonymity -- I was not addressing any particular woman.

> this doesn't make it an attack

Some women are suffering in their attempts at professional careers, and I gave them quite a lot of advice to help them in their careers, fairly carefully written, with good information, not easy to discover, e.g., can be attacked and sabotaged from jealousy and competitiveness from doing the work well, and, net, the attacks cost me five points at HN. I was attacked.

The attacks were personal, against my person, and not against the content of my post. That is, the attacks were essentially "for thinking and writing the way you did, you are a bad person". In particular, for my advice to the women, there were no responses at all. So, the attacks were aimed not at my advice but at me, personally.

<rant> A strong suspicion is that the attacks were because the attackers believed that I was violating some of the norms of politically correct gender equality. On that issue, I will note that, as I explained, I, too, was sexually harassed in a professional, office, academic, employment setting. But, of course, as a man, I didn't get "nightmares". And I will quote E. Fromm, The Art of Loving: "Men and women deserve equal respect as persons but are not the same." Right, they are "not the same" -- women "deserve" equality of respect but are not "the same", that is, not 'equal' in all things. E.g., we don't have women playing in the NFL. So, 'gender equality' can't claim that the genders are equal in all respect, e.g., we don't have women playing in the NFL. And, as we can clearly see from the OP, the women are complaining about being sexually harassed while men also get sexually harassed by women and don't complain, that is, there is sexual harassment going in both directions, but the women complain and the men don't -- men and women are not being treated "the same"; full 'gender equality' doesn't hold.

With full 'gender equality', the women in the OP have nearly no grounds for complaint. But I believe that the women very much have very strong grounds for complaint so can't accept the politically correct gender equality fully. So, I am setting aside what is politically correct and being very sympathetic for the suffering women. So, for the way I am treating the women, 'gender equality' would be a big step down for the women. I don't want that big step down for women. So, I tried to help the women. And, in this goal, I was treating women with lots of extra compassion and caring, was being protective, e.g., called them "honey" and was attacked for that. In my post, my record on women was clear -- I was the prof who recommended hiring the woman who did so well. Also, elsewhere my record on women in professional careers is clear: My wife and I both got Ph.D. degrees, but she went to graduate school first, and financially I put her through and she didn't put me through. And during our marriage, until she died, essentially all the money money put into the family checkbook, which she carried, was from me, in particular, from my work, and not from work or anything else from her. So, for my wife, 'gender equality' would have been a big step down. Finally I will quote an expert on US society: "In the US, women are privileged characters." The expert was correct: In US society, in many ways, women are treated much more nicely and gently, with much more in sympathy, empathy, and compassion, than men are -- no small thing and no joke. And I believe that that is just as it should be. Why? Simple point -- men don't have babies.</rant>

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by nkurz on Monday April 18, 2016 @09:52PM (#11524404)
Addressing a US Black, "boy" is always an insult. Since growing up, I've seen a lot of the US: Addressing a woman in distress, e.g., "constant nightmares", affectionately, "honey" is quite appropriate with nothing wrong at all.

I think that's the point of disagreement. Is it ever appropriate to address an adult "woman in distress" as "honey" if you are an older male and not in a relationship with her? Similar to "boy", whether correct or not, many (most?) Americans, particularly younger, currently feel that it is never appropriate.

If your parents and grandparents were also from the Deep South, there is some likelihood that they would call a young black man "boy" without necessarily intending offense. The argument that eventually won out is that regardless of intent, such language is belittling and inappropriate. I think the change was for the better, while also accepting that often no harm was intended.

I was in elementary school in North Carolina in the late 70's, and there was still an "unreconstructed" older generation who proudly clung to an "outdated racial terminology" -- some in spite, and some on the theory that they meant nothing wrong by it. Perhaps at the time they were right, perhaps they weren't, but clearly current society would argue against such usage.

I'm asserting that regardless of your intent, your use of "honey" (and defense thereof, particularly the "protective" aspect) is parallel to the way that "boy" (presumably, depending on your age and culture) strikes you. A web search for "honey sexist" will give you a summary of the current consensus.

The attacks were personal, against my person, and not against the content of my post.

To the extent that your choice of phrasing is part of the content, I think it was mostly about the content. I'd guess that 'ksenzee' (who from other posts I think is female) was genuinely asking if your post was parody. You are probably right that the implication was "if you think that's socially acceptable you would be a bad person", but I think it really was in the context of "but surely you can't think that".

(I personally agree with much of your rant about the inconsistencies of "equality", but this may be because I'm probably midway in age between you and much of the rest of the HN audience. I will note though that your wife's opinion on whether 'gender equality' would have been a "big step down" is an important factor to consider.)

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by graycat on Monday April 18, 2016 @10:28PM (#11524524)
> I think that's the point of disagreement. Is it ever appropriate to address an adult "woman in distress" as "honey" if you are an older male and not in a relationship with her?

Again, over again, one more time, yet again, here on HN I was not addressing any particular woman. Instead, there was full anonymity on both sides. So, there was nothing personal involved. I used no names and, really, know no names of the women, and the women don't know my name. So, what I wrote was not really personal. I never claimed or suggested that what I wrote would be appropriate to say directly from a particular man to a particular woman in a real office, employment context; guessing or concluding that I was so suggesting was an unjustified "extrapolation" and, likely, some hypersensitivity to some of the attitudes of political correctness. So, clearly one should take what I wrote as what a man would tell his wife, sister, or daughter.

In our society, in a case of such anonymity, such use of honey is common. E.g., Trump says in public that he "cherishes women". Well, maybe he does. But that is not the same as him walking up to a particular woman, one of thousands at his rallies, and saying "I cherish you". Everyone knows this difference.

On my parents, my mother was born and raised in Ohio, and my father, in Upstate NY. He met my mother in Ohio, and they got married in Ohio. My father went to the Old South because that is where his employer wanted him. My parents had no sympathy at all for the racial norms of the Old South; my ancestors are from England and Germany, but I hated those norms of the Old South and got the hack out of there ASAP. I'm in NYS and don't want to go back to the US South. My mother's approach was clear: Since she did work, she hired a maid for some of the house work. The maid was Black. Mom was sure to make the maid's US Social Security contributions. That was extraordinary.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by peterwwillis on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:54AM (#11539954)
> Addressing a woman in distress, e.g., "constant nightmares", affectionately, "honey" is quite appropriate with nothing wrong at all.

No. No it is not. Jesus christ. You do not get to call a woman you don't know "honey", "darling", "sweetie", "sweetie pie", "sweetheart", "sugar", "baby", "doll", "angel", etc. If you do know her, you better either be her father or mother, or significant other. I don't care if you're from the South. I'm from the South. Fucking stop it.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by gaur on Monday April 18, 2016 @05:28PM (#11523282)
I think you intended for your writing to be punchy, but it ended up just being hard to follow. I'll pick a passage at random:

> Then she kept saying she was "looking for sex". Gee, those women were trying to harass me sexually? No, I didn't have any "nightmares"!

Is your second sentence actually a question? It sounds more like a statement that was accidentally punctuated with a question mark rather than a full stop or an exclamation point.

Your third sentence doesn't make sense. Who said anything about nightmares? And why is "nightmares" in quotation marks? Is it supposed to be a euphemism for something else?

Overall, I give your comment a 3/10 in terms of readability. Try tightening it up, and make sure that the sentences you're writing actually make sense and are contextually appropriate.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by graycat on Monday April 18, 2016 @08:25PM (#11524073)
> Is your second sentence actually a question?

Basically, yes. It was a rhetorical question in the sense that the reader now gets to ask that question as I had to to myself at the time. And, of course, the answer is, "Yes, she was she was asking me to have sexual intercourse with her". So, one could say that I, in this case a man, in a professional, office setting, actually also an academic one, was being asked for sexual intercourse so was being 'sexually harassed'. So, as in the OP, I should have "nightmares"? Well, I didn't. So, I was sexually harassed in a professional, office, academic, employment setting and had no nightmares. So, by implication, we have: "Women, note that, in public, office, professional, academic, employment settings, men get 'sexually harassed', too".

> Your third sentence doesn't make sense. Who said anything about nightmares? And why is "nightmares" in quotation marks? Is it supposed to be a euphemism for something else?

The third sentence makes perfect sense: I was being sexually harassed, by a woman, but didn't have "nightmares". And the word 'nightmares' was in full, double quotes because it was being quoted from the OP, which was about having nightmares from sexual harassment.

> Try tightening it up

It sounds like the jump from my second to my third sentence was already to large, that is, my writing was already too 'tight'.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday April 18, 2016 @12:41PM (#11521227)
This is what "being part of the problem" looks like.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by adrienne on Monday April 25, 2016 @06:06AM (#11563335)
Yeah, this dude is creepy as shit and if i knew him in real life i would keep as much distance as possible between him and me. I feel really, really sorry for his wife.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by graycat on Monday April 18, 2016 @01:08PM (#11521442)
For "being part of the problem", look at yourself. You are profoundly confused, mixed up, misled. The women in the OP are suffering, from "constant nightmares", and I gave them some powerful, difficult to obtain, wise, helpful advice.
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday April 18, 2016 @02:17PM (#11522009)
Advice like "say no" and "stay in groups" is neither difficult to obtain nor helpful. (And: "carry a hat pin"? seriously? this is the 21st century here)
Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by graycat on Monday April 18, 2016 @02:27PM (#11522077)
Your response makes no sense, is not a reasonable or rational response to what I wrote.

E.g., "say no" and "stay in groups" is VERY helpful.

Of course that advice is not "difficult to obtain". Neither is advice to keep breathing, but all the advice is helpful.

But much of my other advice and descriptions of the real world of work is very helpful and difficult to obtain.

Given your response, maybe you need a remedial course in reading comprehension -- try a US community college.

More likely, you are angry, at me, personally and for no good reason. So, likely you are lost, confused, mixed up, and misled.

Re:For Female Astronomers, Sexual Harassment Is a Constant N... by wellainthis on Thursday April 21, 2016 @11:56PM (#11546972)
Bleating.