The "8 out of 10 startups fail in a year" claim also rings hollow without a citation, even if restricted to "tech startups". Is there some source that demonstrates that 8/10 high-growth startups fail within a year or is this as unsupported as the more general claim?
I've only ever heard of startup used to refer to a new business that hopes to become extremely scalable. In my opinion, starting a burger restaurant isn't a startup, unless you're hoping to be on every streetcorner competing with McDonald's in the next 5-10 years. It's just much easier to scale with a tech/software company.
The 8/10 claim is still baseless any way you define it though. The Forbes article this presentation links to only cites "Bloomberg.com" as the source, not linking to any specific article.
I think the recent popularization of the Facebook story, Google rise to dominance, and Apple's romanticized origin story have all contributed to many people thinking of "startups" as isolated to tech or to high growth scalable business. But before this, the term "startup" was used to refer to many things. A chemical company goes through iterations of plant "startups", even while railing many hundreds of millions in capitol, that will only pay off after a decade of plant operation for example.
Personally I don't like to think I'm starting a "startup", but rather founding a business.
As a software engineer working nearly 2 decades, prior to discovering HN some 5 years back I always just thought it was a small, relatively new tech company that was designed to grow beyond a lifestyle business. I never thought about the hypergrowth factor. I still use the term in that fashion.
Interestingly enough, my gf works in commercial finance and they use the term to apply to any new business where there is no like prior for the applicant. In your example above a brand new burger business is certainly a startup until they open up a second location. IOW, they're no longer a startup once they've proved successful enough to grow to a second location with the ability to use the first as collateral reducing their inherent risk.
It's still unverified that even high-growth tech startups fail 80% in the first year. How many "Facebooks for {foo} and Uber for {bar}" actually fail in the first year? If you define a high-growth tech startup from the time it takes investment or the time it incorporates, I bet you still don't hit 80% failure rate in the first year. (If you count abandoned ideas that were never meaningfully pursued, then sure, but in that case I've got a dozen failed startups under my belt and a similar number of failed restaurants.)
I heard it only for the business you describe, but lately every newly created design/tech-consultancy here calls itself a start-up.
I get a job offer from people who say "We are a start-up" and then they are just another dumb agency. If I want agency work, I freelance.
What's "significant growth?" That's one fuzzy area. I'm not sure you have to be aiming to become Fortune 500 in less than 10 years, but the aim should be for at least one or two standard deviations above normal for the sector.
The best definition I can think of is that a startup aims to deviate significantly from the industry norm through the application of technology or higher order conceptual reasoning about process.
https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-truth-behind-9-out-of-10-s...
sama also posted some stats here a while ago about yc companies that were wildly different from the "8/10 startups fail" myth.
Example: You work for company X and build wordpress blogs for companies A,B,C since 5 years. Now you think it's not reasonable to have company X in the middle since your relationship to A,B and C is good enough. So you quit and work with them directly as a freelancer. At that point you started a business and the risk of failure is as low as your estimation of the relationship to A, B, and C is as good. If you are not too unrealistic you only do this when it is very likely to succeed. But your business value may stay about the same the next 5 years.