Having such a small percent _earn_ such a huge share is toxic.
I don't see anything broken, other than a state government that taxes people too much for too little value in return. (Either add value, or tax lower).
Inequality is getting bigger and again reaching historic highs, if you don't see anything broken then your eyes are shut. The only thing that stopped the inequality which occurred around the great depression was WWII and entering into a pseudo-planned economy. So it's a problem that can correct itself, but the outcomes aren't always welcome... or peaceful.
These studies also leave out all of the good jobs created by the 1% and the massive amount of taxes going back into the state from these employees.
If you counted this, they are responsible for nearly all of the taxes.
In truth, we are getting to the time where there will be too many people for the amount of work required by the whole humankind to possibly satisfy its needs. We should all embrace this new reality and think of a way in which people can live without working, or in other word, we should solve the economic problem [0].
We already have a population that does not work. As of Mar 2016 there are 16.6 million men age 16 to 65 not disabled not in labor force, and 28.2 million women. (44.8 m total) (from: http://www.bls.gov/webapps/legacy/cpsatab6.htm) A lot of those are probably those who gave up though.
Many though are retired or in school. In 2014 ages 55 to 64, 13.8% were retired. (http://www.bls.gov/opub/btn/volume-4/people-who-are-not-in-t...) (Note I consider home responsibilities as working as you would probably have to hire someone to do those if you didn't do them yourself). In 2014, both genders age 25 to 54, 1,479,000 were retired!
It needs to be a huge paradime shift. It also involves some huge technological barriers to be overcome: solving the energy problem, dealing with resource scarcity, etc. But I think if humanity is going to survive another 10,000 years -- we need to see an end to money in general.
In the short term, more automation and guaranteed minimum income are a start. Not everyone needs to work. We should be able to focus more on art and culture rather than polluting the world with more plastic shit.
The millionaires and billionaires of today are betting that this breaking point won't happen in their lifetimes. They're probably right.
The first step may be realizing that there may not be any disequilibrium per se.
I'm still thinking about it, but I watched "All Watched Over For By Machines Of Loving Grace" by Adam Curtis and it totally appealed to my skepticism fetish about these things. If our models are wrong ( and to some limit, all models are wrong ) , the it's (solopsistic) Hubris to complain that the world is incorrect.
(ObDisclosure: I have a child who did graduate work in ecology and left it in disgust, so I'm extremely biased. I also believe firmly in Adam Smith's "Man of System" to keep myself from thinking I can solve certain problems, as a self-defense mechanism ).
So here's my solopsism on the subject:
- this state of affairs represents our collective revealed preferences to some fraction of 0...1.
- If it is much less than half, then what makes up the rest?
- we have significant policy, legal and outright cultural boilerplate to protect us from this. Why doesn't it work?
- Saying "it's because people cheat" seems to me to abdicate the field. "Double down on the rule-making." But based on what?
- Given the Pareto distribution, what can actually be done? This one scares me but it reeks of mathiniess. But what if it's true?
At the core of it, does emergent phenomena exist or is that yet another "I give up" thing?Maybe we need a rich and operational model of rents, and base all taxation on that. Doesn't seem to even begin to address finance and financialization at all, though.
If we did that, we would all pay less taxes (both low income and high income earners).
When you look at health care as an example - the US seems to have a rather inefficient system when compared to single payer (government) in other western countries.
I think we need to give up our dogma (capitalism == good, government == bad) - and look at the objective evidence.
There is no one story for the present apparent concentration fo wealth. We've had capitalism before such that there wasn't a lot of concentration of wealth - and the tax system wasn't always the reason.
I think the reason is economic rents, and rents are specifically not capitalist.
The short version is that capitalism has a moral founding. What we now call capitalism can be pretty amoral, but that's our doing.
I'm hoping that a better understanding of rents can enable us to have a better capitalism. Principally, because I don't much think collectivism can be demonstrated to work, and collectivism is frequently seen as the answer to the excesses of what we call capitalism.
If we see income from rents as less morally defensible than income from work then that's possibly a method for getting closer to what we want. As it is now, they're simply "profit". Rather than taking two binary positions - pro and anti capitalism - perhaps the work that needs to be done is a better critique of it , and a refinement of terminology.
Finally, the ways in which we are unequal are much less ... physical than in the past. Capital itself has become more and more ephemeral, and it may be that returns to what I'd consider "real" capital - think a building full of lathes - is just as low as that to labor. So much inequality is due to the abstraction of control of capital.
Having a such a small percent pay such a huge share is toxic. I've heard people who pay high taxes say incredibly entitled things about "paying for" things. It destroys a sense of shared investment and purpose.
Clearly the solution has to be to ensure income is more evenly distributed, though I don't know how to do that exactly. Education and learning skills necessary for high paying industries would certainly help, but every time I hear that it feels like kind of a weak solution. That said, I don't really have a better one.
What are some interesting off the wall ideas for reducing income disequilibrium?