News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by rayiner on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:20AM (#11502122)
The complaint has two major theories:

1) There was an actual agreement between Guillory and Vogt that they would be a 50% owners. The YC application is a memorialization of the fact that this agreement existed.

2) Even if there wasn't an actual agreement, Cruise is using IP that Guillory developed.

The relevance of the YC application is this: Oral contracts are in general perfectly valid, unless they apply to a specific situation that requires a writing. A YC application listing the parties as 50-50 co-owners is at least strong evidence that an oral contract exists with those terms. It's reasonable to infer that if people have a writing proposing to do X, then they actually did X or have already agreed to do X.

While a vesting schedule might be typical, it's not going to be implied into existence unless there is some evidence the parties intended for there to be a vesting schedule. For similar reasons, questions of how much Guillory actually contributed will be relevant to (2) but not (1). A 50-50 joint venture is like marriage. Come the divorce, the assets will be split 50-50, even if one party earned all the money. The law won't come in and try to value peoples' contributions after the fact. That would be impractical. The law trusts that people say what they mean and mean what they say.

This case will turn on whether Vogt has any evidence to counteract the inference that may be made from the YC application. It will also turn on legal issues such as whether a writing, not just an oral contract, is required for the sort of arrangement Vogt and Guillory allegedly made, and if what's in the YC application is a sufficient writing to meet that requirement. IIRC stock issuance requires a signed writing in Delaware so that could be a stumbling block depending on how the agreement is framed.

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by AndrewKemendo on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:34AM (#11502185)
FYI for any readers, rayiner is an accomplished appellate lawyer.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by absherwin on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:37AM (#11502196)
Given that the company had been incorporated prior to the YC application, there are two possibilities: The original incorporation paperwork shows a 50:50 split or it contradicts the YC application. In the latter case, assuming that one party handled incorporation but made the other believe it said something different, wouldn't that constitute fraud?

Of course, it's also possible that they discussed resolving the equity when they split but never put it into writing...

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by henrikschroder on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:59AM (#11502279)
In the countercomplaint, Jeremy says that he and Kyle first met in the beginning of October 2013.

Elsewhere in this thread, someone found that the company was incorporated in September 2013.

So a possible timeline is that Kyle creates the company with himself as the sole owner first, and goes looking for a technical partner. He finds Jeremy, they talk, they hit it off, and they decide to apply to YC together, and Kyle offers to split the existing company 50/50. But they don't put anything in writing, so on paper the company is still 100% owned by Kyle. Things go sour between them, and Jeremy leaves/is kicked out without the ownership of the company ever changing on paper. And then things move on, other people are brought into the company, shares and vesting schedules are formalized, and the whole thing is forgotten/buried. Until now.

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by p4wnc6 on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:09AM (#11502323)
> He finds Jeremy, they talk, they hit it off, and they decide to apply to YC together, and Kyle offers to split the existing company 50/50. But they don't put anything in writing...

One of the major questions is whether the YC application and any stated intent for a 50/50 split in it would be that writing.

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by henrikschroder on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:46AM (#11502461)
Kyle fired(?) Jeremy after a month, was that a valid withdrawal of the verbal promise to give Jeremy 50% of the shares? Jeremy left, and did not in any way indicate that he still thought he had 50% of the company, is that an implicit acceptance of losing his promised shares?
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by p4wnc6 on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:01AM (#11502683)
That all sounds complicated and open to debate. Was Jeremy an employee? Did Kyle have any standing to fire him? What were the circumstances under which Jeremy left? Did Kyle use any primary IP contributions from Jeremy, like architectural designs?

Also, if there is sufficient evidence to declare that the 50/50 partnership existed, then Jeremy did not have to do anything to explicitly declare or let Kyle know that he (Jeremy) understood himself to still possess a 50% stake. There would be no such thing as an "implicit acceptance" of losing equity.

Basically the points you raise are not at all obviously addressable, and there are many ways they could play out that actually do support a significant award to Jeremy, regardless of whether that is a popular outcome.

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by zekevermillion on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:09AM (#11504925)
The original paperwork might not have issued stock to anyone. It is quite common for people to organize a corporation while neglecting to issue any stock until a later date (often when an investor's lawyer first reviews the file). As you can see this creates a host of problems, which could be avoided if people would stop telling founders that the first thing to do is form a Delaware corporation.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by hoodoof on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:23AM (#11502139)
With the final irony probably being that the acquiring company may lose its taste for the acquisition given the dispute, meaning they are just fighting over who gets half of the ashes of a bonfire of money.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by davemel37 on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:33AM (#11502180)
I suspect large corporations are no strangers to these lawsuits and if they really wanted the IP, they wouldn't be scared off by debacle...although they would likely double down on any due diligence they planned.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by onebot on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:53AM (#11502494)
This is not uncommon. The deal will have an escrow where money is held for a time period to protect against such claims.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by ghshephard on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:47AM (#11502462)
Well, at the very least, moving forward if there is a mention of another founder on a YC application, that later leaves, I'm sure YC will probably suggest that the departure is formerly written/signed/witnessed to avoid this type of issue in the future.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by wastedhours on Friday April 15, 2016 @09:12AM (#11503967)
Thanks for the summary - perhaps a slightly more philosophical Q: if applying to YC implied an intent to split the company 50:50, then would the notion YC usually asks a company to have a vesting schedule of that sort imply that it was intended?
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by rayiner on Friday April 15, 2016 @10:49AM (#11504733)
The fact that it's a YC application as opposed to some other type of writing is mostly irrelevant.[1] What Guillory is relying on is the statements in the application:

> [The YC application] described repeatedly that Guillory was a founder of Cruise Automation and states unequivocally in response to a question asking “who are the shareholders and what percent does each own?” that “Cruise Automation is a Delaware C Corporation created in September 2013. 50/50 split between Kyle and Jeremy.”

That writing is evidence of the agreement. Commercial practice, like what YC usually requires in terms of vesting schedule, may also be evidence of the agreement, but obviously it's weaker evidence than the words on the page. And under certain circumstances,[2] it might not even be permissible to invoke external evidence such as commercial practice to add terms to a contract.

[1] It's relevant to the extent that a YC application is the sort of thing you'd expect to contain accurate and true statements written down with some care. Besides that, it's value is its contents, not any inferences that you may make from what you know about the YC process generally.

[2] Under the parole evidence rule, when a contract seems complete on its face, you can't invoke external evidence to add terms to the contract. Although it's hard to say that in this context you have a contract that's complete on its face.

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by hoodoof on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:34AM (#11502186)
Apply HN: due diligence as a service
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by birken on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:40AM (#11502206)
When you raise a Series A or later funding there normally is an extensive amount of due diligence done before the deal is closed. Sometimes you pay for it, sometimes the VC pays for it, but it happens.

Before that point spending extensive time or money on due diligence is probably a waste. By all means keep accurate documentation of what is going on and follow best practices, but if there are a few minor issues it probably doesn't matter and will get cleaned up later if your business is doing well enough (note: this situation is obviously not a minor issue).

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by p4wnc6 on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:42AM (#11502214)
I propose the name for 50% equity: DDaS Attack!
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by hoodoof on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:44AM (#11502226)
I hereby name you my co-founder. 50/50. I shall now go find a buyer.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by jsprogrammer on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:25PM (#11505524)
Isn't that a bit of an oxymoron? If you just trust some people you pay, how is that different from trusting the other people you pay?

'Due diligence' must be performed by the buyer, otherwise it is something else.

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by leelin on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:00AM (#11502512)
Interesting, so if the case hinges on the YC application as evidence of the equity split, then we also know that YC requires all founders to sign an employment agreement with their company and restricted stock purchase agreement, following a very standardized YC template, that would include a vesting schedule. Other requirements include an employee incentive pool and of course enough common shares for YC to purchase their portion.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by beambot on Saturday April 16, 2016 @03:58PM (#11512019)
I know that YC has a standard RSPA... but I'm also fairly certain that their template is not used universally by all YC companies (eg. Quora, who probably already had other RSPA docs [1]). Therefore, the standard YC RSPA cannot probably be deemed binding after the fact. (IANAL)

[1] http://techcrunch.com/2014/05/11/quora-y-combinator/

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by CPLX on Friday April 15, 2016 @08:37AM (#11503758)
Could you comment on the cause of action that references the existence of joint venture? Being somewhat familiar with that area of law it seems like that's a great catch-all for any claims that Jeremy doesn't have any equity in the company specifically. That's an apparently somewhat sound doctrine that would imply that even if he has no shares in the company, there is a "joint venture" consisting of himself and that company which he still has a share of, and that said joint venture is subject to partnership law.

Am I reading that right?

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by rayiner on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:12AM (#11504948)
So creating a partnership (a form of joint venture) is extremely easy: if you get together as co-owners and operate a business enterprise for profit a partnership arises, whether or not you intended to create a partnership.[1] So if Guillory and Vogt operated as co-owners of a for-profit business, there might be a partnership. The partnership probably wouldn't be around today. It probably would have been terminated when Vogt "fired" Guillory. But if Guillory was a partner, he was entitled to some distribution of the partnership assets that existed at the time.

Guillory's allegation here is basically that he never got that distribution, and Vogt took the IP that was among the partnership's assets to Cruise. The partnership claim isn't going to get him equity in Cruise. What it does get him will depend mostly on what IP he contributed and the harm to Guillory from Cruise not returning that IP.

[1] At least in California, which follows the Uniform Partnership Act.

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by theoracle101 on Sunday April 17, 2016 @03:56AM (#11513841)
I think the biggest thing everyone is glancing over is the wording of the app:

"If you have not formed the company yet, describe the planned equity ownership breakdown among the founders, employees and any other proposed stockholders."

Planned != official, no ? Couldn't cruise claim that the stock was never awarded

Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by zekevermillion on Friday April 15, 2016 @08:40AM (#11503779)
Surprisingly, CA statute of frauds does not seem to require a signed writing for this type of contract...
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by toomuchtodo on Friday April 15, 2016 @10:48AM (#11504731)
Quite a few states don't require a signed, written contract for agreements.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by zekevermillion on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:13AM (#11504956)
CA law does require that a sale of personal property for more than 5k be evidenced by some form of writing. However, does not have to be signed. Thus the key function of the ycombinator application form as evidence. This is practically a law school or bar exam question in the making!
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by theoracle101 on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:44AM (#11502447)
So if the issue of stock wasn't in writing for a Delaware company, then his 50% claim is not valid as he was never issued stock? I'm sure #2 is a non issue for Cruise
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by rayiner on Friday April 15, 2016 @09:38AM (#11504156)
Maybe. Guillory doesn't need to show he was issued shares to win. If Cruise promised him 50% equity, and didn't issue him any shares, that would be a breach of contract. Guillory would get damages not because he actually owned equity in Cruise, but to compensate him for the equity that was promised to him but never issued as shares. Contract damages put you in the place you would have been had the other side kept their promises.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by bewatson on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:19AM (#11505003)
On top of what @theoracle110 said, would other contracts in previous investment rounds (in which Jeremy did not speak up) have any power/relevance?
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by theoracle101 on Friday April 15, 2016 @10:16AM (#11504448)
Isn't there a statue of limitations for this? It's been over 2 years and he never lodged a complaint
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by possibility on Friday April 15, 2016 @12:44AM (#11502223)
This is trivial, but my favorite part of your post is the use of "a writing" as an expression.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by zekevermillion on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:15AM (#11504966)
It's a term of art.
Re:Jeremy Guillory's Counter-Complaint against Cruise Automa... by possibility on Friday April 15, 2016 @06:43PM (#11508153)
Ha! "Term of art" is another good one.