News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by Overtonwindow on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:57AM (#11497215)
Negative. Those with money will fight like hell to keep from giving it up. However if by some chance/miracle a guaranteed income is ever instituted, it will become a political football, as politicians and advocacy groups seek to continuously push it higher and higher. Instead of a money handout, I would rather support money in exchange for public works and service. I don't believe handouts without some kind of exchange will ever really work.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by drzaiusapelord on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:28AM (#11497458)
>stituted, it will become a political football, as politicians and advocacy groups seek to continuously push it higher and higher.

This is pretty much Chicago in a nutshell. You have all these handouts to public sector unions in return for union votes and union support. You have further entitlements given to the poor on the south and west sides for votes. You have all these ugly deals done in exchange for staying in power, and no one cares about actually balancing the books. When push comes to shove, you just raise taxes over and over. In other words it won't just go "higher and higher" it'll just be higher for special interest groups who can deliver votes. If you can't deliver mass votes and aren't part of one of these groups, your income will be low or non-existant as you'll be stuck in the 'worker' group and not in the 'leisure' group.

GMI needs an implementation that works. I suspect there really is none that doesn't quickly just become corrupt patronage. GMI and democracy/elections may not be compatible. It may only work under a totalitarian system and sounds pretty close to the USSR's system at that point. The best case scenario here seems to be automation making the cost of living so low that existing welfare systems will just be more than enough to take care of people. If we can vastly lower the cost of everything, then modest payouts will be enough and we'll be able to retain a capitalist and democratic system.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by tonyedgecombe on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:01AM (#11497243)
Politically I don't see it being any different to progressive taxes which many (most?) countries already implement.

Practically I suspect it will need to be quite low to avoid all sorts of distortions.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by BurningFrog on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:20AM (#11497395)
I haven't listened to the episode, but the Basic Income that makes sense is one that replaces all/most welfare programs.

The existing programs are very distorting already, often giving poor people 100%+ marginal taxes.

Sure, Basic Income would be distorting, but far less than that. It should also save a lot of money since it requires almost no people to administer.

This is also the biggest problem with instituting it, since the people holding those jobs will fight to the death to keep them.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by dageshi on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:54AM (#11497714)
I don't believe it will replace all/most welfare programs. I think it will replace some and then politicians will be elected to top it up for select groups. "Fairness" will come into play, "I am disadvantaged compared to this other person, I should get more, it's only Fair". Plus regional top ups, cost of living in different places is higher than others, I expect there will be a demand for a top up based on cost of living on top of basic BI, again that'll need to be enforced and administered.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by Overtonwindow on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:02AM (#11497253)
By politically I'm imagining a politician campaigning on the promise to increase the basic minimum income. Vote for me and I'll get your basic income increased. Don't vote for my opponent because they just want to cut your basic income! It's the tax issue all over again.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by Retric on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:14AM (#11497341)
You forget the US is run by the rich, which is why this does not happen with Social Security. It's all about not having the benefit cut instead of increasing benefits or lowering retirement age.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by twoodfin on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:06AM (#11497290)
Exactly, and just as likely to be gummed up by complexity. After all, how can you be against teachers and firefighters receiving just a little more BI for their essential, thankless jobs?
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by pgeorgi on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:10AM (#11497314)
but such considerations are what their actual income is for.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by lawlessone on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:21AM (#11497403)
it doesn't even exist yet and he's trying to distort it.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by maxxxxx on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:40AM (#11497572)
I also don't believe it can't work long term unless attitudes change dramatically. People who work for a low income will complain that there are people who get almost the same without doing any work. The same wealthy people who lobby for more tax cuts will also not want to pay for people who don't do anything.

There will be a lot of people who will use the freedom granted by basic income for productive means but there will also be a lot of people who won't do anything productive and just live off their basic income.

That will give opponents a lot of material for campaigning against basic income. So my prediction is that this won't work long term. That is, unless our society changes in radical ways.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by pluteoid on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:47AM (#11497638)
The people working for only slightly more than the UBI will get more than twice the income of someone not working at all. Universal basic income means everyone gets the income.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by maxxxxx on Thursday April 14, 2016 @12:33PM (#11498119)
I doubt that. Low end salaries will probably go down unless there is a minimum wage.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by kspaans on Thursday April 14, 2016 @12:10PM (#11497866)
> but there will also be a lot of people who won't do anything productive and just live off their basic income.

Won't do anything productive like spend money on food, housing, and entertainment? They will just sit inside and stare at the walls all day.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by maxxxxx on Thursday April 14, 2016 @12:34PM (#11498136)
Not stare at walls but watch TV all day.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by kspaans on Thursday April 14, 2016 @12:59PM (#11498398)
Sounds like great news for distributors, and content creators.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by maxxxxx on Thursday April 14, 2016 @01:10PM (#11498525)
True . It's a valid way to stimulate the economy :-). My point was that people who do something more will resent the people who just watch TV.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by mc32 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:21AM (#11497408)
I agree on the points of exchange for public good. Even poor people are loath to see others getting by on "freebies". But a progressive system where BI depends on need (age, for example) and commensurate effort (volunteering, helping take care of elderly, studying, training, etc.) I think is doable and will need to be worked out as more jobs get automated and people are left out of the economy either due to mismatch of skills or other handicap.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by WorldMaker on Thursday April 14, 2016 @12:09PM (#11497854)
The systems we have today are the compromise results of such a "progressive system" where system income depends on need (age [Social Security, Medicare], circumstance [Unemployment, Social Security Disability, SNAP, Welfare], etc) and based on "commensurate effort" (previous wages, complicated forms, layers and layers of proofs, ...).

Have you had to file for Unemployment "Insurance" yet, in your lifetime? It's a complicated circus to get back money that you "paid in". You have to prove, and then re-prove, your past earnings and tax amounts that had paid into the programs (plural if working across state boundaries); you have to "be actively seeking work" and prove, every single week, that fact with somewhat embarrassing forms to fill out to get the money that you already set aside for this already embarrassing situation...

These systems treat you as "guilty-by-default" and we've let the worry of possible fraud, however unlikely, turn these systems into giant theaters of "fraud reduction" and complicated terror on the individuals dealing with the system.

Basic Income, by expecting to be unqualified and guaranteed to all regardless of need or effort, is intentionally about simplicity and about avoiding the giant red tape spaghetti that is our current "entitlement" systems. If everyone gets it, equally, then you don't need to worry about "fraud" and you don't need to worry about "proof".

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by mc32 on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:35AM (#11505130)
I see room for a compromise in order to make it more sellable.

Base it on simple things, age, legal status, and positive community involvement. We still need to make people feel useful rather than resentful and entitled. It's an entitlement but some minimum effort should be shown that one is at least trying to contribute to their society.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by WorldMaker on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:34PM (#11506144)
«I see room for a compromise in order to make it more sellable.»

What we have is the compromise. The point of (Universal) Basic Income is that the compromise isn't good enough and we can do better, by going simpler, removing the human moral judgments and encompassing everybody equally.

This is definitely a case where compromise destroys the integrity of the concept. It should be "sellable" enough on its own merits to avoid breaking it.

«We still need to make people feel useful rather than resentful and entitled.»

There are so many assumptions here to unpack. People will feel resentful to get "free" money from their government? People "need" to feel useful? Plus there is obvious so much hate overloaded in people's usage of the words "entitled" and "entitlement" that there's probably a half-dozen PhD theses we could point to.

Do you have moral complaints about Basic Income? Basic Income isn't about policing what people do with it. That's part of the simplicity that makes Basic Income more interesting than the compromises and the other alternatives. Does it concern you what other people would do with their money if they had just a little bit more? Basic Income intentionally doesn't make judgments, that's a part of its beauty. It's a sort of freedom: here's money, do what you will with it.

Yes, there are probably simple things that would still make sense to do, but mostly it should just be "Are you a US Citizen? Do you pay US income taxes?" Curtailing it further than that starts to conflate money and morality in weird ways.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by mc32 on Saturday April 16, 2016 @04:59PM (#11512227)
Personally, no, other than citizenship and age (a one year old does not need the same subsidy/income as an adult). The rest, I think would make it more acceptable to the rest of working people who put in more than they take out in BI.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by strommen on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:37AM (#11497538)
A large part of the Basic Income's appeal is that its simplicity would dramatically reduce government overhead. Existing entitlement programs are complicated as hell, and it takes a lot of work to enforce and refine eligibility rules.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by mercutio2 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @01:21PM (#11498646)
A Basic Income based on need is called a welfare system, and requires gatekeepers to determine neediness. We have various such systems in the US.

Any time you here someone say "basic income", they mean a guaranteed, zero qualifications beyond citizenship and possibly adulthood, income. It is meant as a replacement for many aspects of the welfare system.

It is true, since humans are bad at making many financial/health/welfare decisions, that not all public welfare costs are a good fit for replacement with a BI. But things like food stamps, disability income and section 8 housing all do appear to be good fits.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by mrfusion on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:30AM (#11497472)
Social security is basic income for those over 65.

It is a football like you say but no one has dramatically increased it for decades.

Besides the looming shortfall it seems to be run fairly responsibly.

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by mc32 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:36AM (#11497536)
SS is different in that presumably you have previously contributed to the funds which get disbursed at retirement. Recipients of BI may never have contributed monetarily to the burse.
Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by prodmerc on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:45AM (#11497612)
Because those are money paid for (saved up) by the same people while they were young and employed...

Where would this basic income for everyone magically come from? It maybe would be possible if the rich (millionaires and especially billionaires) and corporations would pay for it with higher taxes, but since they run the world, I'm guessing that's not gonna happen.

Seriously, the current welfare systems are quite ok (pay only those who don't have enough and/or don't have a job), just streamline it and tax the rich a bit more for more money to go into it. Europe seems to do it best so far. But of course that's socialism, etc. (and somehow basic income isn't)...

Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income? by maxerickson on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:59AM (#11497234)
It's not just those with money that will fight it like hell, a lot of people without much money see working for access to resources as a fairness issue.