Re:Are Geeks The New Alpha Male?
by EliRivers on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:34PM
(#1149545)
No.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Why is this comment at -1 while another comment with the same content posted a few minutes later is at 18?
Re:Are Geeks The New Alpha Male?
by noonespecial on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:06PM
(#1149623)
I've seen this happen a couple of times and wondered about it. This is a particularly good example of it because there are so few comments, its likely that both are visible to most readers. "No" should universally get 0 because it adds as much to the discussion.
All I can offer is shalmanese is an old account with much karma and EliRivers is a new account with none. Also the higher scoring one was posted 4-5 minutes earlier.
Usually "no" adds nothing to the discussion. However, in this context I read it as "Obviously, no. The post author clearly hasn't put much thought on what they wrote, so let's not even bother dissecting it". In a way, it is a constructive comment in the sense that it prevents fruitless discussion.
Of course one could just flag the post but that isn't as visible.
From here it looks like shalmanese posted first.
Re:Are Geeks The New Alpha Male?
by quellhorst on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:05PM
(#1149620)
Because the guy who posted second down-voted the guy who posted first?