News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adding JavaScript modules to the web platform by Kudos on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @03:48PM (#11491574)
> It is entirely possible to eliminate unused code with the commonjs/amd/umd way with a slightly more intelligent bundler.

How can you do it for this?

require(someRuntimeVariable);

Re:Adding JavaScript modules to the web platform by awalGarg on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @03:58PM (#11491670)
If the `someRuntimeVariable` is statically evaluate-able, then some compilers (uglifyjs, for instance) support limited inline evaluation at compile time, which could be enhanced by community effort.

If not, then it won't :) But you still would have the same benefits when requiring stuff with plain string literals, and additionally you'd have the freedom to require dynamic stuff on the cost of lesser optimizations. You don't lose anything.

Re:Adding JavaScript modules to the web platform by jahewson on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @06:23PM (#11492821)
Nope. If we're talking about tree-shaking (which we should be as it's the entire point in having static modules), you loose everything. That's because require(someRuntimeVariable) can refer to any module. So there's no way to exclude any of the node_modules, or any portions of any of them.

So all code in all modules must be kept. No tree-shaking for you.