News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:44PM (#1148883)
This would just allow the rich and connected to choose thousands of people to budge to the front of a 3-5 year long line that other green gard applicants (EB-3) are waiting in. If there are resources available to process more EB-5's and EB-6's, then put them to use accelerating the process for the people that have already waited years for their applications to be approved. Accelerate that process and you'll accelerate the creation of startups by our friends that are already here.

Edit: Above I said "a 3-5 year line," which is inaccurate. The current line is 7-9 years long.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by pg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:08PM (#1149144)
That's such a dishonest way of describing the situation that it's hard to believe it wasn't deliberate. You describe this bill as if it merely allowed powerful people to get their friends into the country, and it's not like that at all. Startup investors are not identical with the rich and connected. Angel investors are generally fairly rich, but not all VCs are. And they're not choosing people at random to bring into the country. They have to invest money in someone's startup to do that.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by adw on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:41PM (#1149420)
To be fair, you can turn that round; my reading of what Brian said was that he thought this bill was open to abuse, which could make your reading seem disingenuous.

Neither interpretation's fair to either of you, though.

(I have no horse in this race; living in Europe, the idea of a visa seems a bit anachronistic, really.)

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ojbyrne on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @08:55PM (#1149785)
As other people have commented, when you say "anachronistic" you really are being chauvinistic. I.e. you're assuming that there's no such thing as non-EU citizens who actually want to work in Europe. Those people face similar hurdles to those wanting to work in the US.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by adw on Thursday February 25, 2010 @05:15AM (#1150386)
There are barriers, and it sucks that people can't do that. I'd be overjoyed if we had full freedom of movement across borders.

That's what I mean; living in Europe you think about visas so rarely, despite crossing borders and looking at jobs overseas, that the whole idea begins to look archaic and paranoid.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by randallsquared on Thursday February 25, 2010 @07:55AM (#1150547)
That's true in the US as well, except that we no longer think of other states as "overseas", and a generation or two into the EU, neither will you guys. ;)
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tsally on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:06PM (#1149621)
(I have no horse in this race; living in Europe, the idea of a visa seems a bit anachronistic, really.)

I can understand why visas might seem obsolete from a European perspective, but from an American perspective regulation is a necessity. Per year we already accept the highest number of permanent residents in the world. In 2008 we naturalized a record number of people. And most importantly, per year we grant the highest number of people political asylum. These numbers, combined with the fact that unemployment in the US is the highest it's been since the early 1940s, makes accepting large number of immigrants impossible.

I'm not defending this bill or the current system; I know there are areas that need improvement. But fundamentally the US needs some sort of visa system.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jseliger on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @08:34PM (#1149762)
"And most importantly, per year we grant the highest number of people political asylum. These numbers, combined with the fact that unemployment in the US is the highest it's been since the early 1940s, makes accepting large number of immigrants impossible."

This claim is specious: the high-end immigrants who are likely to start tech companies and earn PhDs are enormously employable and likely to employ others. If you want more employment, bring in people who are likely to make jobs; notice the high number of tech startups with founders who are immigrants or the children of immigrants.

Still, I doubt that these visas are going to have any noticeable impact on unemployment because the rate at which they'll be granted isn't going to be high enough.

As for immigration more generally, see James Fallows' comments here: http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/201001/american-decline . Allowing immigration is one of the relatively few things that America does right.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by Yrlec on Thursday February 25, 2010 @05:10AM (#1150379)
I still think you are able to accept more people into the country. In 2007 the Swedish city Södertälje (with about 80 000 cititzens) accepted more Iraqi refugees than the US & Canada combined: http://www.sweden.se/eng/Home/Work/Life-in-Sweden/A-multicul...
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by blackguardx on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:19PM (#1149505)
I currently live in the US. Can I just move to Europe and get a job? Or, do I have to do some sort of paperwork first (like get a visa)?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by henrikschroder on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:45PM (#1149571)
If you are not a EU citizen you need a residence permit and a work permit. I don't know how different the rules are between the EU countries, but it's roughly the same everwhere. A work permit is typically tied to an employer, and a residence permit is typically tied to a work permit.

Here's the different kinds for Sweden: http://www.migrationsverket.se/info/1074_en.html

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ohashi on Thursday February 25, 2010 @04:43AM (#1150356)
Easiest to get a student visa here in Sweden (I know, I am on one!). They are also a lot easier to deal with once you are in the country and trying to extend... just show them you have money/income and won't be leaching off their system and they are happy.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by eagleal on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @09:34PM (#1149843)
Once you have a Visa/Residence permit (work) in one country you can freely move between all the EU countries. (I live in Italy with residence permit, so I know)
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by wheels on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:43PM (#1149939)
Usually you need a permanent residence permit (Greencard equivalent), and then it has to be a fairly recent one as the laws were only harmonized in the last 5 years. And even then, the permit for most of the EU isn't valid for the UK or Ireland.

In Germany the first permit that you get (an H1B equivalent) is tied to one job, and hence, tied to the place where you have that job. After 5 years of working full-time (and a long string of other checklist items), you're eligible to begin the application process for permanent residence (which I now have).

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by eagleal on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:34PM (#1150016)
My fault, I don't know why I confused the permit to stay (expires every 2 years) with permanent residence. Well, in Italy you just need a home and revenue to obtain a permit to stay (work related). The permanent residence or permit to stay doesn't lock you to the first job it was issued for, though.

However you can still (with the permit to stay) move between UE countries, just get back to Italy and declare revenue (as entrepreneur).

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davidw on Thursday February 25, 2010 @04:23AM (#1150339)
Whereabouts are you in Italy? You don't have any information in your profile. I'm in Padova.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by eagleal on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:13PM (#1151010)
Sorry for replying late, I just saw it. I'm in Perugia (Umbria, Central Italy).
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ig1 on Thursday February 25, 2010 @11:42AM (#1150958)
In the UK almost all professional level visas (tier 1, old HSMP) are person based rather than employer based, so you're free to change jobs
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by fierarul on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:32PM (#1149666)
>(I have no horse in this race; living in Europe, the idea of a visa seems a bit anachronistic, really.)

Heh, there are still people in EU countries (Romania, Bulgaria the least) that need visas to work in another EU country. So it's not all rosy within EU borders either.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by Kliment on Thursday February 25, 2010 @01:22AM (#1150144)
As a Bulgarian citizen working in Germany, this is only partially the case. Germany does require work permits for Bulgarian citizens EMPLOYED here (except for certain exempt categories, such as scientific staff) but this does not apply to self-employment. In fact, there are no nationality restrictions for self-employment within the EU, and such restrictions would be illegal. So Bulgarian/Romanian citizens do need a permit to be employed within the EU countries that are still paranoid about their employment market, but don't need one to work there if self-employed.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by smallblacksun on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:38PM (#1149552)
I'm pretty sure that visas are required to work anywhere in Europe (if you are from outside the EU). I know that the UK, France and Germany require them.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:17PM (#1149174)
What does it matter if there are good, hardworking, "non-rich" VCs? There are also bad, lazy, well-connected VCs. You're evoking the intentions behind this bill as if they mattered.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by pg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:23PM (#1149196)
In this particular case the reason it matters is that it makes briansmith's comment false.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:40PM (#1149250)
Why is anything I said false? Because I used the word "just"? Take out the word "just" and everything we both said is true: there are VC's that aren't rich, and rich people will be able to abuse this to get their friends green cards, while those without connections have to wait and work for 7-9 years to get their green cards.

Look at http://travel.state.gov/visa/frvi/bulletin/bulletin_4659.htm.... It says that the US government is just now processing applicants who filed under EB-3 back in 2001 and 2002.

Put the "EB-6" people in the same line as the EB-3 people and the proposed legislation becomes a lot more fair, but useless. Speed up the EB-3 process and lots of people stuck working under a H1-B would quit their jobs and start their own businesses. The could do so with the money they've saved, or negotiate fair deals with investors.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by breck on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:51PM (#1149443)
> rich people will be able to abuse this

I'm sure they will. However, rich people are such a minority that in 90%+ of cases this law will be used for its intended purpose.

Rich people can also "abuse" speeding and parking ticket laws(you can speed and park anywhere if you can afford the tickets), tax laws, etc. Just the way of the world. I wouldn't lose too much sleep over it.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by pg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:59PM (#1149305)
Ok, if what you meant to say was that the bill could be abused, let's examine that. What protections does it have against abuse, and why do you feel they're inadequate?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:24PM (#1149654)
It effectively reduces the number of EB-2 and EB-3 visas available per year. That is my main objection to it. (I explained how in my two most recent posts in other threads of this discussion).

I recommend everybody to read the proposed change to the law. It is a very small "patch" that is easy to read and understand, especially once you've read the rest of the discussion on this topic.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by TheTarquin on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:29PM (#1149391)
There's hardly a regulation that's been passed in the past century that hasn't opened up opportunities for abuse. If the potential for abuse is enough to make a law a bad idea, then there would be precious few laws ever passed.

Which, I must confess, appeals to me personally, but if we concede that we need the ability to legislate, then the simple potential for abuse can't be showstopper for any individual piece of legislation.

Rates and/or severity of abuse maybe, but not the simple possibility of it.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ajju on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:39PM (#1149412)
Speed up the EB-3 process and lots of people stuck working under a H1-B would quit their jobs and start their own businesses.

Why can't H1-B's do that right now? AFAIK there is nothing stopping them from moving to an EB6. I would.

I don't think that is an argument against speeding up EB-3. I think that should happen as well, but is obviously much harder politically.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by blizkreeg on Thursday February 25, 2010 @01:13AM (#1150132)
Not every startup and entrepreneur out there is able to raise funding. Many are bootstrapped. Of those many, some will definitely go on to become businesses that raise money later, make money, and/or create jobs. EB6 rules out all such aspiring entrepreneurs.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:25PM (#1149384)
obviously the issue of how fast the INS is able to process legitimate green card applications is an issue, however i don't feel that it's a legitimate reason to exclude this new proposed legislation.

we can attack the problem by focusing on improving INS processing times, rather than excluding other valid applicants (of any type). we are certainly not suggesting StartupVisa green card applicants "move to the front of the line" ahead of anyone else, simply that their application be considered fairly & reasonably along with others.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:41PM (#1149937)
My friend's applied for her green card 1.5 years ago. The best estimate for her getting the green card is 2017--about 8.5 years from the start of processing. That is the typical EB-3 wait time.

Are you saying you'd have EB-6 applications also take 8.5 years?

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:42PM (#1150023)
i'm saying that solving INS processing times by not introducing new visa legislation is a rather ass-backwards perspective.

furthermore, the job creation / economic output benefits don't need to wait for green card processing to be solved.

there's being practical, and then there's simply being defeatist.

i'd rather be part of trying to provide solutions to INS processing times than to wait on innovative solutions to job creation & immigration reform.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by kvs on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:49PM (#1150026)
Why couldn't your friend apply in EB-1 or EB-2?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Thursday February 25, 2010 @11:00AM (#1150868)
She is trying to find a way to "upgrade" to EB-2 or to get a National Interest Waiver. Although she has a master's degree from a US university, her profession (high school foreign language teacher) doesn't usually get job postings requiring more than a BA. Also, at the college level, they generally make you wait a long time before they even start the green card process (or even H1-B).

However, besides her, I've met others in similar or worse situations, stuck in the EB-3 queue. Even if my friend got her green card under EB-2, I'd still be advocating for the EB-3 workers.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by netcan on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:36PM (#1149240)
I don't think so. He says "this would just allow." Maybe he didn't qualify it with "the unintended consequence of this bill" or similar but its pretty clear what he means.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by rms on Thursday February 25, 2010 @05:28AM (#1150396)
I of course agree with you that the startup visa is a great idea, but I think Brian's other point is that US immigration as a whole is so fundamentally flawed that there are lots of areas that need large amounts of additional funding. This is a true political point, but there's not much we can do about it. As a political issue, the average American doesn't care about immigrants except for knowing that they want less of them.

I give you and startupvisa.com for actually taking a political issue to the point where one of the power-holding senators was willing to introduce legislation. And maybe if it comes to a vote while attached to the military funding bill or something it will pass! I don't think populists have enough power to speak out against the bill, so whether or not it passes probably comes down to random DC "inside baseball".

META: I ask that if you (anyone reading this) do not have something profoundly interesting to say that you not reply with any political discussion.

US immigration is so unbelievably messed up that there is little productive we can say. Like... there are actually networks of secret immigration prisons that lose people regularly. http://www.thenation.com/doc/20100104/stevens

Also see http://www.amnestyusa.org/uploads/JailedWithoutJustice.pdf but note that there is a much stronger political message.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by rms on Thursday February 25, 2010 @08:38AM (#1150605)
To correct myself, Fred Wilson points out in his blog post that it will be anti-immigration people against this bill, not specifically populists, and the anti-immigration people will be against the bill... so this doesn't come to inside baseball, and people writing to their elected representatives might make a difference.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by albertcardona on Thursday February 25, 2010 @05:44AM (#1150419)
US immigration as a whole is so fundamentally flawed that there are lots of areas that need large amounts of additional funding

Fixing the world one step at a time is not a bad approach.

Starting by steps that have great potential for generating wealth is a sensible strategy if you are thinking of taking any more steps.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by rms on Thursday February 25, 2010 @06:05AM (#1150436)
I agree.

META:

Lest someone else respond to me, I don't mean to imply that there aren't many more viable strategies for fixing the world! If you think you can save the world, I would prefer to discuss it with you via email rather than in this thread.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by sdurkin on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:48PM (#1149277)
"Never attribute to malice what can be explained by stupidity." I think the grandparent is just looking to score a few cheap karma points by stirring up some populism.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by fnid2 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:54PM (#1149097)
It's entrepreneurial servitude. You come in and build a business to our specifications, making a certain amount of money for the rich investors or you lose your rights to live here.

When the entrepreneur is booted out because (s)he was unable to generate $1M in revenue a year after 2 years in business, what happens to the business? Do the investors retain ownership? What legal rights does the entrepreneur have over the business (s)he created?

There are no laws in America protecting the rights of these entrepreneurs who are not citizens. They are here to build a business, hopefully, but if they miss the marks, they lose everything! Their home, their business, their employees, and potentially the rights to any revenues, IP, or equity in the company they founded. Do you think some rich investors who have the ability to have our nation's laws changed to their favor are going to stop taking money out of a business because its entrepreneur isn't allowed to live in the U.S. anymore? It'll be business as usual for them, with or without the entrepreneur who created the business.

This bill is good for no one but rich investors. It's definitely not good for entrepreneurship. Entrepreneurship has absolutely nothing to do with venture capital or investors or people with at least $10M in the bank. It's about creating businesses with the sweat off your back. If we are going to reward something -- reward that -- no strings attached!

Especially not strings attached to the fingers of the same rich folks who have caused so many problems in our nation already!

This is so horrible. What is happening to our country??

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by anamax on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:03PM (#1149133)
> There are no laws in America protecting the rights of these entrepreneurs who are not citizens. They are here to build a business, hopefully, but if they miss the marks, they lose everything! Their home, their business, their employees, and potentially the rights to any revenues, IP, or equity in the company they founded.

Where are you getting this from?

Non-residents can own things that happen to be in the US. They can sell them. They can even buy them.

Even if you're deported, there's no forfeiture.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ajju on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:32PM (#1149221)
This is true, but you are forfeiting any active management position, authority and likely control, which is basically the same as being fired as CEO. Not something you want to risk.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by anamax on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:08PM (#1149983)
> This is true, but you are forfeiting any active management position, authority and likely control, which is basically the same as being fired as CEO.

Again - no, being deported doesn't cause any of those things. The owners of the biz are the ones who make that decison.

Since we're assuming that you're being deported because you're not satisfying the conditions of the startup visa, what are the odds that said owners would have kept you on anyway?

Advocates of the startup visa said that they wanted to bring folks into the company to create biz. Fair enough, but what should we conclude when they complain about deporting folks who don't do what they wanted?

And, what should we conclude when they make up stories about the consequences of deportation?

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ajju on Thursday February 25, 2010 @07:19AM (#1150517)
You are using an unrelated but true argument to make your case by attacking my supposed criticism of the visa rules. I am not criticizing the rules, only pointing out that the deportation clause of the visa has consequences on control.

Yes, there have to be measurable metrics to gauge traction. Yes, I agree that 2 (3?) years is an acceptable time to create 5 jobs OR earn a mil OR raise a mil. Yes, unless those who don't meet these rules are deported, the rules won't have teeth.

But neither of those points has anything to do with the argument that deportation is synonymous with losing position, authority and likely control.

Maintaining control of a startup that is funded is a challenging job even when you are in the country. It should be. In my opinion, it would take a genius to remotely manage a startup. Even if you continue to be a majority owner after an investment, it would be very tough at best and foolish at worst to try to manage it from another country. That is assuming that it's a decision you alone can make, and your investors have no actual say in the matter.

The bottom line is that at the end of 2 (3?) years, if you don't meet these metrics, you will be in a different country than your company and very likely unable to control it without large scale changes in business model and/or structure.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by anamax on Thursday February 25, 2010 @10:59PM (#1152319)
> But neither of those points has anything to do with the argument that deportation is synonymous with losing position, authority and likely control.

Deportation is not syonymous with any of those things.

Those things are decided by the folks who control the biz. They're free to keep the person on after deportation. They're free to do those things even if the person isn't deported.

Yes, deportation may be a good reason for them to make certain decisions, but since they're free to ignore that reason, it isn't synonymous.

As to "nothing to do", the only reasons to discuss this are (1) if we let someone in on a startup visa, we shouldn't deport them if they fail, (2) folks who succeed on a startup visa might be deported, and (3) random cussedness.

Regardless, it's simply not true that being deported necessarily has the effects claimed.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:58PM (#1149105)
That's a good question. What happens to the Americans working for the company when its founder is forced to leave the country?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:44PM (#1149268)
They take all the intellectual property to the investors' other, wholly-owned company.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:29PM (#1149388)
entrepreneurs are no stranger to risk. yes, there is a risk they do not meet the basic qualification to remain in the country. however, they are fairly basic: can you create a minimum of 5 jobs in the US within 2 years? (or reach break-even on $1M in revenue, or raise subsequent financing of $1M or more).

entrepreneurs who fail to meet the bar are not being unfairly punished by investors, rich or otherwise.

these rqmts are simply the proposed bar for qualification. meet them, and you can stay. nothing more, nothing less.

this is a considerably better situation than what we have currently.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ericb on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:38PM (#1149036)
Speaking from a country's self interest, don't rich people benefit the country more than poor? Isn't the US better off tax-wise, and wealthier, if it is able to tax a millionaire than a cab driver? Is there something morally objectionable about trying to attract "desirables" or is it just that we need to see the visa process in some way as "fair?"
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by potatolicious on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:00PM (#1149123)
Speaking as a Canadian who immigrated from Asia, and know a large number of rich Asians who have also followed the same path, the situation is really not as simple as you put it.

The rich are in no way obligated to share their wealth with you - as the Canadian government has unfortunately learned. Our immigration programs have three paths: skilled labour, investment, and entrepreneurial. Skilled labour is simply letting people in who have skills we need, investment expects that you invest a $HIGH_AMOUNT into the Canadian economy (with the expectation, not requirement, of more), and entrepreneurial requires that you run your own business for $TIME before you qualify for citizenship.

The first category is usually a win for the country, since these people seek employment and are taxable, not to mention you didn't have to pay for their education.

The second and third categories are fundamentally broken - I personally know many families who do the absolute bare minimum to hit the permanent residency requirements, and keep all of their wealth off the books in Asia, bringing them in literal suitcases of cash (staying just under the declaration limit each time). Heck, I know families that are receiving government benefits for low-income families even though they have millions in property overseas.

My point is, unless you require rich immigrants to give up a huge chunk of money just to get in, expecting that the rich will contribute to your tax base is IMHO misguided. These people are already rich, for cryin' out loud.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ericb on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:43PM (#1149424)
Are they bringing the money in suitcases for the purpose of spending it? Wouldn't that be taxed in the recipient of the spending's income?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by holygoat on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:28PM (#1150008)
And in sales taxes.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by nzmsv on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:23PM (#1149652)
Many countries, Canada included, have bilateral agreements on only taxing income once. So, if these people you know make money off foreign property, they pay taxes on it in the country where it is located. They do not have to pay taxes again in Canada. Which I think is fair: would you want to pay double taxes on your income?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by btilly on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @08:41PM (#1149768)
Double check the relevant treaties. They are often written to say that where double taxation exists, the secondary country may collect their usual tax minus what was paid to the primary. Therefore if the secondary country has a higher tax rate, there is an incentive to keep it off the books.

That said, Canadian law tends to tax people on Canadian earnings. (Or at least it did the last time I paid attention, which was admittedly 15 years ago or so.) Which contrasts to US law that taxes US citizens on worldwide earnings (though the US does give a large exemption for foreign sourced income that keeps this from affecting a lot of people).

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by potatolicious on Thursday February 25, 2010 @01:40AM (#1150171)
This is not about double-taxation - but rather that taxes in Canada are higher than just about any place in Asia (for good reason: Canada has considerably more social assistance programs than most Asian countries).
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by chime on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:43PM (#1149054)
> don't rich people benefit the country more than poor?

Questions like that cannot be answered in any definite manner. If the rich use their capital to create wealth, then it benefits the country. If the rich use it to alter public policy to their advantage, then it harms the country. A new visa process should not enable the rich to game the system unfairly to their advantage at the expense of other prospective applicants.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by fnid2 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:08PM (#1149333)
Honestly, this is a philosophical question that I can't offer an answer to without the potential contamination of lots of personal bias, but I'll tell you how I think about it.

A lot of countries have a lot of rich people at the helm and aren't really, what I would call, benefiting from that. It could even be argued that a lot of the problems in countries are caused by the rich.

I think about it kind of like this: We all want to keep getting richer. I just take that as the rule from which I derive a couple more points on this topic.

First, to be a noticeable increase in wealth, that increase must be appreciable. It must be felt by the wealthy person. I think to appreciate it, it must be a certain percentage change. We probably wouldn't notice a 0.05% increase in our wealth, but we would notice a 50% increase.

Second, assume rich people and poor people desire an equivalent feeling of wealth growth. If I make $10k a year, $1,000 more next year will feel great. I'll have almost $100 more to spend a month. Someone making $100k desires an increase in wealth of $10,000 a year.

Now, if we spread that $10,000 worth of wealth created to make the rich person feel better to the poor people who only needed $1,000 additional a year to feel better, we could have made 10 people happier, instead of just one person happier when that money went to the rich person. $20,000 worth of wealth could make 20 people happier, instead of 1 rich person and 10 poor people = 11 people.

If you believe in Greatest Good for the Greatest Number anyway, but not all subscribe to that philosophy. I do I think. If one person experienced elation at the expense of the whole world, would that be good? Not to suggest that I would offer to harm a minority to bring joy to the world. But I do wonder if growth is beneficial. I think it may not be. It could be bad.

So, I am not sure how to answer your question. I do not know for a fact if it is in a country's self interest to encourage the growth of the investor class with at least $10M in the bank. It may take a lot of stagnation or depression among the working class or creative class to create additional wealth for an already rich minority.

Further from that, if you raise the foundation, quantified as the poverty line perhaps, then it increases the quality of everyone's lives, even the rich. There's less crime, less blight, and people are simply much more pleasant to be around than when there are huge disparities between the rich and the poor.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by lionhearted on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:18PM (#1149500)
> If you believe in Greatest Good for the Greatest Number anyway, but not all subscribe to that philosophy. I do I think.

This is a bit tangential, but I think it's quite important - Greatest Good is a very important belief for someone to consider, and you've written really thoughtfully and introspectively. Here's my perspective, which is a little different:

Sometimes I voluntarily do things to make other people happier. I donate to St. Jude's Children Hospital in the USA, and I've run two small charity events for Great Ormond Street Children's in London, raising a tiny bit of money for sick kids and their families. When I was younger and Catholic, I also volunteered for the Catholic Arts Festival, and I've volunteered at soup kitchens. I spend lots of my time teaching pretty much anyone who cares at all whatever they want to know, including last month teaching a really nice 26-year-old kindergarten teacher how to negotiate for better pay after she got an offer at a great school but they were offering below market pay. I spent three hours teaching her how to negotiate, see others' points of view, and leave it open for them to raise their offer without increasing hostility. I did this just because I like to do good things, I didn't get anything in return except a feeling of doing something good.

So, I really like helping people. But once someone says, you need to help this person, or you're in trouble - my skin crawls. I hate it. It sends every signal to me to resist, to fight, to fight back, to counterattack, to throw off these mandates and chains people would place on me. They want my resources by force? They want my time by force? They want to restrict freely where I can go, and what I can do, and who I can trade with, and what I can buy for myself, and what I can do in my own home, in my own company, with my own friends, and so on, and so on?

To that - to that I say no. Or rather, if they've got me out-gunned, I submit, but I grit my teeth and submit. You see, I think I aim to make myself overwhelmingly a net positive anywhere I go. I try to be polite and respect local culture, share the best things from my culture, teach people, learn, work, prosper, and make others prosper. But frequently people say, "We could do even more good!" And so, with that justification, they limit my mobility, or give a regulator the authority to regulate a transaction between me and another person, or pass a tax, or conscript, or close borders, or so on.

I'm against that all tremendously. So this is an alternative perspective on Greatest Good for Greatest Number. I'm against it, because I know I do right by people, and I feel comfortable ethically with how much I contribute. I feel pretty good about what I do, actually. And I think anyone who isn't a criminal and can support themselves should be largely allowed to do what they like, without fear of being beaten down if they don't do what authorities say is right. It doesn't particularly matter to me how legitimate the authorities believe they are - whether they've got a divine right of kings, or are blessed and anointed by the head of the church, or are elected through direct democracy, or representational democracy - maybe their governorship is more or less legitimate, but if they start saying, "We must do the greatest good, you must do this, you can't do that - in the name of good" I get very upset and believe that's wrong. I submit, because they're much much stronger than me, but it's with a mix of teeth gritted, sadness, and indignation. This isn't a right or wrong perspective per se, I just wanted to take a moment to share an alternate one with you. It's a little bit tangential from the investor discussion, but I think it's really important to think about.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by fnid2 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:48PM (#1149577)
I'm not suggesting we take the $10,000 from a rich person and give it to 10 poor people, rather I'm saying, "We have a surplus of wealth equal to $10,000 and must decide what to do with it. Someone is going to benefit, how do we distribute the surplus such that it creates the most good?

I would suggest distributing the wealth equally among all is the best route to the greatest happiness, rather than giving most or all of it to one individual for whom it may not even be noticed.

I'm not sure, restricting freedoms of the innocent or demanding individuals work to benefit others at their own expense could create a net positive. The "badness" of that might be infinity.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by dtby on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @08:53PM (#1149783)
Whence comes this wealth? Government is not a wealth-creating enterprise. It's (arguably, entirely; verifiably, primarily) in the wealth redistribution business.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by fnid2 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @09:48PM (#1149863)
The wealth comes from within the borders of a given country. Government might not be in the business of creating wealth, but it is in the business of controlling who gets to be within its geographical borders.

If you look throughout history, it's never really worked out well to allow a rich minority to determine what happens to people and the land. Since time immemorial, a rich few have been abusing the property rights of others. Even America was founded by a rich minority who took the wealth of the land from the majority incumbents.

It's the same thing as always.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by dtby on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:16PM (#1149900)
Without arguing the points above one way or another:

Unless I misread your initial message, you suggested that the government was not "taking" wealth from anyone, but rather it somehow had "surplus" wealth to be distributed. My question is more finely tuned to "where did this 'surplus' wealth come from, if it was not 'taken' from someone at some point?"

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by fnid2 on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:59AM (#1150120)
You could say it was taken from the native americans. Indigenous people or that it was in the ground, the result of decayed dinosaurs and random locations of minerals and plants and weather.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by matrix on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:18PM (#1149366)
"The current line is 7-9 years long."

Only if you are on a low-priority employment-based visa and are Indian or Chinese born (i.e. waiting for priority date to become current). The process is still much too long though, even in other cases.

Not that I want to defend the US immigration and employment visa processes. Far from it. The system as it stands is completely and utterly broken. It turns away many of the very people the nation needs to keep its competitive edge in the world.

Realistically though, it will be quite some time before any politician will be willing - or even able - to show the kind of leadership that is necessary to tackle immigration issues, regardless of the merits of doing so.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:45PM (#1149944)
I think EB-3 is "normal" priority. The Indian/Chinese EB-3 backlog is 9 years. The current "rest of the world" EB-3 backlog is a little over 7 years. See http://travel.state.gov/visa/frvi/bulletin/bulletin_4659.htm....
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by dgallagher on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @09:31PM (#1149840)
According to the letter submitted by Senators Kerry and Lugar, it would only affect resources for EB-5 visas (no mention of EB-3 visas):

To make visas available, we would amend immigration law to create a new EB-6 category for immigrant entrepreneurs. We would draw from existing visas under the EB-5 category. The EB-5 permits foreign nationals who invest at least $1 million in the U.S., and thereby create 10 jobs, to obtain a green card. In areas where unemployment is high, foreign nationals need only invest $500,000 to obtain residency. Though roughly 10,000 visas are annually allocated for the EB-5 category, less than half were used in FY 2009, so the addition of immigrant entrepreneurs should not present an unreasonable burden.

http://startupvisa.files.wordpress.com/2010/02/dc-startup-vi...

This merely branches a new visa off from EB-5, which is separate from, and has different intentions than, EB-3. EB-5 visas are not all being used up anymore, so both Senators are attempting to put those waisted EB-5's to good use. They imply that the proposed EB-6 visas "should not present an unreasonable burden" on the system.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:43PM (#1149940)
That's not how it works. Whatever EB-5's don't get used eventually trickle down to EB-1, EB-2, and EB-3. They don't just go unused. If EB-6's start using them up, then there will be fewer EB-3's available every year.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:49PM (#1150027)
i'm pretty sure that's incorrect, as the existing EB-5 visa allocations have a specific target of 10,000 visas (which are currently not even close to being used up, only ~1,000 are used every year).

if anything, prioritization is likely to work the other way: EB-1s first, then EB-2s, EB-3s, etc. see language below for EB-1 priority visa workers (with "extraordinary abilities"): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EB-1_visa

note: i am not an immigration lawyer (IANA[I]L).

you may also wish to review language for the Immigration Act of 1990: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Act_of_1990

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Thursday February 25, 2010 @11:11AM (#1150896)
You are correct about prioritization.

The question is what happens to those "extra" 9,000 visa numbers that are pre-reserved for EB-5. Everything I've been told says that whatever numbers aren't used by EB-5s gets "spilled over," starting at the top (EB-1), instead of going unused.

Also, I am not a lawyer either.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by rms on Thursday February 25, 2010 @05:26AM (#1150392)
Brian, if you want to start your own lobbying group to fix any of the flaws in US immigration policy, I sincerely wish you the best of luck.