News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:01PM (#1148750)
This is a bill that proposes to give US venture capitalists the overt ability to terminate the residency status of founders and their families.

Not only do you have to get sponsored by an effectively arbitrary class of financiers (it is possible that Warren Buffet wouldn't qualify under these terms, depending on whether he has personally made 2 equity investments last year), but even if your company creates 10 US jobs and is cash-flow-positive, if you don't raise $1MM in capital or make $1MM in revenue, you're out.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by lionhearted on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:12PM (#1148781)
> This is a bill that proposes to give US venture capitalists the overt ability to terminate the residency status of founders and their families.

False.

"To make visas available, we would amend immigration law to create a new EB-6 category for immigrant entrepreneurs. We would draw from existing visas under the EB-5 category. The EB-5 permits foreign nationals who invest at $1 million in the U.S., and thereby creates 10 jobs, to obtain a green card. In areas where unemployment is high, foreign nationals only need to invest $500,000 to obtain residency. Though roughly 10,000 visas are annually allocated for the EB-5 category, less than half were used in FY 2009, so the addition of immigrant entrepreneurs should not present an unreasonable burden."

Green card is permanent residency - once they've got it, they've got it. This looks pretty awesome.

http://startupvisa.files.wordpress.com/2010/02/dc-startup-vi...

It was a pdf and I coudln't figure out how to highlight so I retyped it myself - apologies if there's a minor grammar/spelling error.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:16PM (#1148797)
Here's the text of the proposed bill:

‘‘(3) SPONSORED ENTREPRENEURS.—The Sec- retary of Homeland Security shall terminate the per- manent resident status of a sponsored entrepreneur and the alien spouse and children of such entre- preneur if the Secretary determines, not later than 3 years after the date on which such permanent resi- dent status was conferred, that—

‘‘(A) the qualified venture capitalist or qualified super angel investor who sponsored the entrepreneur failed to meet the investment requirements under section 203(b)(6)(A)(i); or

‘‘(B) the entrepreneur failed to meet the job creation, capital investment, or revenue gen- eration requirements under section 203(b)(6)(A)(ii).’’;

The job creation, capital investment, and revenue generation requirements (by the way, this language is ambiguous, with the "or" being more restrictive here and less restrictive earlier in the bill) are:

‘‘(I) create not fewer than 5 new full-time jobs in the United States employing people other than the im- migrant’s spouse, sons, or daughters;

‘‘(II) raise not less than $1,000,000 in capital investment in furtherance of a commercial entity based in the United States; or

‘‘(III) generate not less than $1,000,000 in revenue.

You know more about immigration law than I do. All I can do is read. Tell me what I'm misinterpreting.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by phreanix on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:44PM (#1149056)
Quick glance and please correct me if I got this wrong:

This only affects immigrants with permanent residency status who have been sponsored through this bill/law. You stated:

"This is a bill that proposes to give US venture capitalists the overt ability to terminate the residency status of founders and their families."

True in the sense that if the sponsored entrepreneur was unable to fulfill the job creation, capital investment, and revenue generation terms, then they technically were unable to create a successful enterprise. Any foreign 'entrepreneur' worth his salt should and must know of this requirement and in the awareness of it, must have prepared himself and his family for the consequences.

As for part (A) "...the qualified venture capitalist or qualified super angel investor who sponsored the entrepreneur failed to meet the investment requirements..."

I think this refers to the initial requirements that needed to have been met before the foreign entrepreneur is approved for residency. It could be that the VC committed to the investment (That IS a bitambiguous, but from experience, immigration officials will approve an application and give you a chance to fulfill a financial commitment some time after the sponsored entrepreneur has arrived, provided they are satisfied with whatever guarantee docs you've filed with them.) but was unable to fulfill it, so Homeland Security will start the process of terminating the permanent residency status of the sponsored entrepreneur.

Can this be twisted around by an 'evil' VC? I believe any system CAN be abused around given enough motivation. In this case, if I were an evil VC who convinced Mr. Chatroulette founder from Russia to come to America to blow his idea up 1000x through me, I'd bring him in, dupe him into signing his life away in a 'partnership', promise Homeland Security that I will fulfill my financial commitments, squeeze everything I can from this naive new sponsored entrepreneur in the 6mos-1yr that Homeland Security will take to enforce my commitment, then not pay up. Back to Russia goes 'sponsored entrepreneur' and his concept/resources stay here in the US.

Bottom line for all parties, due diligence. I believe the bill is being put forward in good faith. I believe that they believe it can create jobs. I believe that it is possible it can.

But all things considered, I'd rather concentrate resources on finding the cream of the crop in the US and helping THEM.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:48PM (#1149071)
I believe this bill was conceived with the best of intentions. I believe everybody advocating it, including venture capitalists, are advocating with the best of intentions.

But their intentions don't matter at all. What matters is the law that the bill will create. And, as I read it, the law that this bill creates will have unintended negative consequences both for immigration and entrepreneurship.

Your last sentence? I absolutely, 100% agree.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:53PM (#1149449)
the 3 points are an OR, not an AND. you misinterpreted it.

altho the legislation as proposed is not final, it was clearly drafted and stated with each of the 3 potential rqmts being sufficient on their own, not together.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:02PM (#1149608)
It costs less than $100k per year to keep 5 "full-time" workers on staff. Just pay them minimum wage. This seems well-thought-out to you?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:09AM (#1150057)
so what's your solution? lower the amount?

i think you lose your side of the argument by arguing for any arbitrary amount. i'm happy to argue the merits of what the correct # is, but regardless i think we're just splitting hairs at that point... i've won the discussion.

besides, it's a rather ridiculous amount of hassle in both time & money to raise capital from experienced investors in exchange for hatching some supposedly nefarious scheme to -- wait for it -- hire some low-wage workers.

really, while i fully admit there may be gaming of the system attempted, this supposed workaround is quite a stretch -- it requires the participation of sophisticated investors willing to risk substantial amounts of capital, reputation, effort, and criminal penalty in order to execute.

this doesn't appear to be a rational point worth arguing, you're just being contrarian for the hell of it.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by neurotech1 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:16PM (#1148964)
You did mis-interpret the gist of the bill.

The VC funders have less significantly less control than a employer of a H-1B visa.

Basically they are saying you have a 2 years (max 3 years) to meet the requirements (investment and jobs)of the visa, or go home. A EB-5 visa has a 2 year "conditional status" along similar lines.

A H-1B visa, the employer can terminate your job, and you have 30 days to leave the country. A VC can't do that unless the founders have given up their controlling interest.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by andreyf on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:36PM (#1149027)
You're saying the same thing. To put it plainly, what I think tptacek is saying, is that after 3 years, investors have a strong upper hand in negotiating a round, knowing that "Homeland Security" has set an artificial bar for how much a company must raise if the founders are to stay in the country.

Edit: he said it explicitly here - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1148789

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by neurotech1 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:18PM (#1149176)
My whole point is they don't "have the upper hand" if you've already made $1m in revenue.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:39PM (#1149249)
Yes. It just puts people with viable $900k/yr companies in a ludicrously bad negotiating position.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by alex_c on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:04PM (#1149321)
Which could be argued (by entrepreneurs looking for a startup visa) is still better than nothing.

No, it's not perfect, but what alternative do you propose?

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:16PM (#1149358)
Drastically relaxing green card restrictions.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by kvs on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:08AM (#1150055)
Relaxing doesn't have to mean give everyone a green card. It could mean, I think that's what Tom means, that don't tie it to a set of investors rather tie it to the performance of an individual. Create 10 jobs, make 1MM revenue, get them verified by IRS, you're in the clear.

If we look at H1-B situation, what makes employers abuse it and almost makes H1-B holders useless (for anything other than their current employment) is the tie visa has with the employer. If we make H1-B holders move around freely between jobs then there is less room for abuse. IMHO.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:05PM (#1149471)
perhaps a laudable goal, however: 1) not mutually exclusive to proposed Startup Visa Act 2) politically MUCH more challenging to pull off

feel free to contribute to other efforts to promote your ideas. however, hope you don't feel the need to tear down our (complementary) ones that may be achieved practically & expediently.

light a candle, don't piss on ours.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:32PM (#1149532)
Your idea isn't complementary to mine, and if it can't handle criticism on Hacker News, it certainly doesn't deserve to get a vote in the senate.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:04AM (#1150052)
the criticism here is largely one-sided and poorly argued by a few such as yourself.

if you must make it zero-sum, then i'm quite willing to face the music in the senate.

so be it: have at thee, gauntlet thrown.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by andreyf on Thursday February 25, 2010 @03:01PM (#1151449)
I think we're getting too personal. Both of you make a good point:

Thomas says that there certainly will be companies who will be forced to raise a arbitrary amounts of money at an arbitrary time (in both cases, I mean "arbitrary" in relation to their business), even when they're otherwise doing well. On top of that, the VCs negotiating that round will know that their investment is what determines the fate of the company.

Dave points out that this is the best solution which is politically viable.

Both seem true, in my opinion. Still, and with all due respect, Dave's bio does say he "invests in startups if they let him" (emphasis mine). This law will create a class of startups that are forced to look for investment at a stage that may have make business sense, with the only strategy at a "fair" valuation being to play off investors against each other. This is certainly in the interests of people who invest in startups.

I wonder if bundling the interests of "those who can afford to lobby" into laws is the only way to get laws passed in the US nowadays.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by lionhearted on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:52PM (#1149587)
> light a candle, don't piss on ours.

Hey mate, did you edit that into your comment or did I just miss it the first time? Because I upvoted you since I agree with the not mutual exclusive/harder to pull off thing, but no need to be crass like that. It doesn't help further the position we generally agree on, and clouds the discussion. tpt is a smart and good commentor anyways, even though we disagree some times - it's totally unnecessary to be crass with him like that.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:02AM (#1150050)
um, seriously... using the word "piss" is considered crass?

really, you must not read my blog.

i'm being incredibly civil in this discussion compared to my usual white-trash, immature, profane and loutish self.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by Confusion on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:34PM (#1149021)
You did mis-interpret the gist of the bill.

The gist is irrelevant. The only thing that is relevant is what it actually says.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:23PM (#1148994)
H1-Bs are also bad. And, H1-B's aside, I'm not sure you actually refuted my interpretation of the bill. I cited its plain text.

My question is, is there some other law or propose legislation that mitigates the impact of this bill? If there is, I'll stand corrected.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by neurotech1 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:16PM (#1149168)
The part that I'm refuting is that they HAVE to raise $1m from VCs.

From the legislation you quoted;

"‘‘(II) raise not less than $1,000,000 in capital investment in furtherance of a commercial entity based in the United States; or ‘‘(III) generate not less than $1,000,000 in revenue."

Note that it says OR

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:20PM (#1149184)
I think we're clear that they don't have to raise $1MM from VCs. They can also raise it from customers.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:38PM (#1149410)
it is likely the case that rqmt #1 -- that is, the creation of at least 5 full-time jobs in the US -- will easily be met by most entrepreneurs if they have any shred of competence and/or economic viability.

the rest of your argument is perhaps interesting from a theoretical standpoint, but not likely very relevant from a practical perspective.

it's very simple: create 5 full-time jobs in the US in 2 years time, and you get to stay. if you can't do that, at least get to break-even on $1M in revenue. if you can't do THAT, then find an investor willing to back you for another $1M every 2 years.

the rqmts are quite lenient and reasonable. the fate of the entrepreneur is very much in their own hands (& heads).

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by boucher on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:13PM (#1149494)
There are no restrictions on the kinds of jobs created? In other words, it's acceptable to create 5 minimum wage jobs?

I'm not saying that's a problem, but it certainly makes the requirement easier to satisfy. A full time minimum wage job including taxes is just about $20k a year.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:33PM (#1149541)
Yes, it's acceptable to create 5 minimum wage jobs. In other words, if you are sponsored by an appropriate financier, you can obtain permanent residency for approximately $100,000 per year over 3 years.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:11AM (#1150062)
again you're missing the point of the investor participation in this equation -- it's unlikely that accredited investors and venture capitalists would risk time, capital, reputation, and criminal penalty to perpetrate such a pointless exercise.

while it's possible, it's not very likely.

we did not draft legislation to cover all possible edge cases, but rather to reasonably address common scenarios.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by boucher on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:43AM (#1150100)
completely agree. moreover, even in this edge case, you're still pumping several hundred thousand dollars into the economy.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:55AM (#1150111)
That's great. We should let anyone who can create 5 jobs into the country, regardless of whether a clique of financiers will "sponsor" them. We should let them in regardless of whether they wear pants.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @02:01PM (#1151291)
well why not?

obviously we've let you into HN comments, & you're doing the equivalent of not wearing any intellectual pants... ;)

--

why are you quoting "sponsor"? why use "clique"? you're just trying to use specific questionable punctuation to indict a broad group of people w/o any real analysis of why their motives or ethics are in question.

job creation is likely to be a good thing. if you have specific solutions / suggestions on better ways to measure job creation effectiveness, please state them.

again, happy to argue about these topics rather than you simply ripping on the general proposal. at least we can get to constructive criticism, rather than whether you or anyone else aren't wearing pants.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Thursday February 25, 2010 @06:21PM (#1151872)
I think you misinterpreted my "pants" comment. My point is, if you can create 5 jobs in the US, you shouldn't need anything, except perhaps a clean criminal record, to get a visa. You certainly shouldn't need the "sponsorship" of a "super angel investor".

Please stop taking this so personally. I'm not. How could I? I have no idea who you are.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Friday February 26, 2010 @03:30PM (#1154042)
actually, i was trying to make a joke there... wasn't taking it personally at all. (srsly, i just have a terrible bedside manner).

that said, when you cast disparaging comments on the entire class of VCs not treating entrepreneurs well, it's hard not to take it a little personal (altho i've been on both sides).

when you're stereotyping, it does hit home a little harder.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by icey on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:08PM (#1148773)
By "overt ability to terminate the residency status..." you mean that they can opt to not further invest, right?

I couldn't see anything that gave them the ability to otherwise control the status of the visa holders; but it's possible that I missed some nuance in the bill.

I think the goal is to prevent abuse of loopholes as much as possible - stopping corporations from becoming "investors" in order to circumvent the H1-B hiring caps.

I agree with you about the requirements for continuation being overly lofty though.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:14PM (#1148789)
Yes. If you start a company that employs 5 Americans and generates $900,000 in revenue, any VC you negotiate with gets to factor "deportation" into their terms.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by neurotech1 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:11PM (#1148943)
From the senate statement; " a minimum of $250,000 -- into the immigrant's startup venture. If after two years the immigrant entrepreneur can show that he or she has generated at least 5 full-time jobs in the United States, attracted $1,000,000 in additional investment capital, or achieved $1,000,000 in revenue, then he or she would receive permanent legal resident status."

My personal thoughts are that it should be possible to start a company overseas, get far enough along to secure $250k in VC funding. Also, I would be surprised to find a successful startup that can't get $1m in revenue within 2 years.

While a VC can control additional investments, they have less control over revenue than most founders. A successful start-up should not be dependent on VC funding after 2 years unless it grows exponentially and needs the funds for growth.

Also the terms after 2 years are less than for an existing EB-5 visa.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:27PM (#1149002)
Have you beat $1MM in revenue within 2 years of starting? We did.

(a) It wasn't easy.

(b) Before we beat that metric, we were still --- by virtually anyone on Hacker News' metrics --- a successful enterprise: growing, in control of our destiny, working on meaningful things, creating jobs.

The metrics in this bill are arbitrary (to put it charitably; there's an uncharitable interpretation too). A Thai entrepeneur who can create 5 viable US jobs should be granted a visa without an "angel investment". A Thai entrepreneur who can create viable jobs should be granted a visa without a postage stamp.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ajju on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:09PM (#1149148)
Isn't it true that it is $1MM in revenue within 2 years of getting a visa?

So you could apply when you had $500K in revenues.

Also, I don't know for sure if the qualifying clauses for not being deported have an "and" relationship or an "or" relationship.

Do I need to raise a million dollars AND generate a million in revenue AND generate 5 jobs? Or is one of these enough?

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:15PM (#1149162)
If you're at 500k already, you can probably pull off an EB-5.

Regardless, I'm not all that concerned about the 500k entrepreneurs.

I'm unclear on the "and" and "or" thing, too, but I think it's equally arbitrary to deport someone with 4 full-time employees for missing a $1MM mark, and I think 5 "full-time" employees is extremely gameable.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by zmmmmm on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:52PM (#1149446)
> I think 5 "full-time" employees is extremely gameable

That's what strikes me. What kind of employee do they need to be? If I employ 5 full time janitors on minimum wage do I get to stay?

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by neurotech1 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:37PM (#1149245)
EB-5 says $1M investment NOT $1M revenue

My interpretation is that you have 2 years to preform, and if you don't by the 3rd year - then you are deported, and not for missing the 2yr marks. You have 12 months of latitude if your heading in the right direction with employment.

I do agree that there is going to be some gaming of the system.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:41PM (#1149252)
I read the EB-5 rules before I commented. I stand by my comment.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by odeoncg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:58PM (#1149107)
True. Until that 1$ in revenue is reached, the company still makes revenue and ensures jobs for people, some might have even more than 5 employees.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:02PM (#1149130)
5 American employees. Maybe they'll move to Singapore when the founder is forced to relocate the company?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:18AM (#1150072)
please... your arguments are circular.

if the new visa class doesn't exist, these folks won't have jobs anyway. now you're claiming we should be worried their jobs might be taken away?

decide which part of the argument you wish to discuss.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:01PM (#1149464)
no, you're absolutely incorrect.

if you create 5 US jobs, you get to stay.

if you don't create 5 US jobs, but can generate EITHER $1M in revenue (at break-even or better), OR raise $1M in additional capital from ANY qualifying investor (doesn't have to be the original one), you get to stay.

please read the language carefully -- it does cover the situation adequately.

we did take quite a bit of time to consider the exact language, and worked hard to get it to be functional.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jbooth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:16PM (#1148794)
So, in your estimation, would that be "better" or "worse" than "you cannot get a visa to come to the US and start a company at all, ever" (the status quo)
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:20PM (#1148808)
Worse. I think it will be somewhat unfair to visa aspirants and that it will distort the market.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by shawndrost on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:13PM (#1149493)
I'm baffled. Should this bill pass, visa aspirants will be in a strictly better position. They will have all their old options, plus one. Can you explain how that is worse?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @07:10PM (#1149630)
Unused EB-5 visa numbers spill over to EB-1, and EB-1 to EB-2, and EB-2 to EB-3. This bill would eliminate the EB-5 -> EB-1 spillover, which has the effect of reducing the number of EB-2 and EB-3 green cards available per year.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:15AM (#1150068)
please point out the information that supports your conclusion above. i'm not convinced unused EB-5s contribute to solving for other backlogs.

regardless, it's also not the case that all other backlogged visas are of higher priority than new visas. if there is a zero-sum game to be played, priorities could well be reviewed for all types of visas.

your argument for not approving this legislation seems to revolved solely around the backlog issue. there are other better ways to solve that problem than by simply stonewalling all other visa legislation.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by briansmith on Thursday February 25, 2010 @11:58AM (#1150979)
Google for "EB-5 spillover", and/or have the lawyers that wrote the proposed legislation post their professional opinion.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jbooth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:21PM (#1148812)
Do you think it will be less fair than "You can't even have an application form"?
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:25PM (#1148831)
Yes, though not by much. There are two issues at play here: whether you can move to the US to start a business, and, regardless of where you run your business, how your business will operate. I think that the first issue is slightly less fair (it's more arbitrary and more ambiguous, but it's also more flexible). I think the second issue is much less fair.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ThomPete on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:36PM (#1148861)
It seems to be overly complex and unfair for sure.

Why not just say.

As long as you can pay for your self and your family in the US you are welcome to stay.

If you can't same rule as any other H1 H1B etc applies.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:38PM (#1148868)
Note that the H1-B visa also created a raft of unintended negative consequences. I don't know if it's gotten better since I worked with BigCo's in the Valley in the late '90s, but it was appalling back then.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by ThomPete on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:52PM (#1148903)
Yeah I worked there too at that point, pretty bad. But at least the rules where simple.

Out of sponsor, out of the US.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by neilc on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:18PM (#1149905)
This is a bill that proposes to give US venture capitalists the overt ability to terminate the residency status of founders and their families.

US employers already have this power over employees that hold visas. Why do you trust employers but not VCs? (Or put another one, there is potential for abuse in either arrangement, but I'm not convinced that VCs are fundamentally worse than employers.)

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:35PM (#1149927)
US employers shouldn't have that power. That power distorts the market. It's unfair for aspiring residents, and it's bad for taxpaying US citizens.

Adding yet another class of people with unfair power over immigrants, and yet another distortion to the market, seems like a very poor response to that problem.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by neilc on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:44PM (#1149942)
US employers shouldn't have that power.

Perhaps not -- but if we're debating a realistic change to the visa system, an argument that begins with rejecting the basic principle under which most visas operate seems pretty impractical.

Adding yet another class of people with unfair power over immigrants, and yet another distortion to the market, seems like a very poor response to that problem.

According to what standard would this give VCs "unfair" power over immigrants?

As for "distorting the market", any substantial change to the visa system would distort the market in one way or another. The practical question is whether the startup visa improves the situation, not whether it is the globally optimal immigration policy.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by GFischer on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:14PM (#1148790)
This new visa sounds good in theory, but the requirement is too steep... 1 million in either VC or revenue?

I'm looking into emigrating, but I guess the US still has too-steep requirements for it to be a country to immigrate to.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jbooth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:17PM (#1148801)
Sorry -- in between the "dey took our jawbs" crowd and the blatant nativist crowd, any common sense approach to visas in the US is fighting an uphill battle.

But we're trying.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:21PM (#1148813)
I'm no better than this in most HN arguments but will hypocritically observe that you opt out of reasonable debate about immigration policy when you imply that your opponents are South Park caricatures.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jbooth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:24PM (#1148824)
It's an abbreviation. I'm not writing a sociological treatise here.

How's this:

Group 1) We feel immigration hurts us economically and are generally opposed regardless of specifics (50% liberal, 50% conservative)

Group 2) We feel immigration hurts us culturally and are generally opposed regardless of specifics (95% conservative)

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:28PM (#1148833)
I'm in favor of drastically relaxed immigration policies for professionals. I object to this bill. I fit neither of your groups.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jbooth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:34PM (#1148855)
Yeah, but your objection makes no sense and is probably rooted (apologies, and read this in a courteous tone) in the fact that you saw Kerry's name and had a gut reaction + ipso facto (FYI, Lugar's a republican).

The legislation proposed moves us from "no way, no how" to "imperfect system" -- if you're primarily for relaxing immigration policies for professionals, you should support the bill in principle, favor it over nothing, and probably have quibbles. This bill would mean more professional immigration for the purpose of starting companies -- along with the requisite amount of BS, hassle, unfair playing field etc that apply to all visa situations as things stand now.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:42PM (#1148880)
I canvassed Toledo for Kerry in '04. I got chased off someone's property for knocking on a door doing GOTV for ACT without noticing that the guy was flying a Confederate Flag. I donate to liberal political causes. I'm not just liberal: I'm a Democrat.

You're doing your argument a disservice by engaging with personalities (rightly or, here, wrongly) instead of ideas.

This isn't a personal criticism, because I demonstrably don't occupy the high ground on this point on HN. But you may want to be aware of it.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jbooth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:02PM (#1148920)
Well, I suppose I'm just massively misunderstanding your objection here.

It seems that we share the goal of increased immigration of professionals and enabling them to succeed in america, shared prosperity and all of that..

This bill, to me, is incremental progress towards that goal but flawed on some specifics.. do you agree?

Is your opposition a case of "not good enough and hold out for better"? The specifics about VCs controlling the visa are the deal-breaker for you? How is that so much worse than H-1B where the employer controls the visa?

Honest questions, I really don't understand the argument.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:18PM (#1148970)
There are two specifics to this bill that I object to.

The first is giving venture capitalists this role in public policy.

The second is carving out visas for a form of entrepreneurship modeled on VC-funded tech startups.

If a business creates jobs, I don't see how it's relevant to public policy that it hits a $1MM revenue threshold or (even more weirdly) a $1MM capital investment requirement.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by jbooth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:59PM (#1149112)
Well, they need to have some sort of criteria to prevent gaming the system. I think we'd both agree that you can't open the floodgates by investing $1 each in 50 paper businesses in order to get 50 visas.