Re:Tesla launches new Model S with updated design
by state on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:44PM
(#11483842)
Does anyone else find the Tesla design to be its worst feature? I want to want one. Really, I do. But when I look at them (this update included) it just looks like a Lexus from 2005 or something. Not that I have something against the Lexus owners out there - it's just that the look doesn't seem to represent what's inside.
I wish it weren't true, but I think design is going to keep me burning fossil fuels for a while now. Am I the only one?
Re:Tesla launches new Model S with updated design
by vvanders on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:46PM
(#11483851)
You might be, anecdotal evidence but I've taken mine to quite a few car shows. Overwhelmingly the feedback has said that their design is something people like as opposed to something crazy like the i3.
Re:Tesla launches new Model S with updated design
by state on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:51PM
(#11483886)
Yeah, I'm not really in the market for the i3. But if the Model S looked like an S3 or an M3 I'd be perfectly happy. I can't quite put my finger on why though.
Since I'm getting downvoted above, I'll take that as evidence that I am in fact the only one. Ha!
Re:Tesla launches new Model S with updated design
by bhauer on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:58PM
(#11483944)
It's funny that people are downvoting you for your opinion. I don't share the opinion, but downvoting is not for matters of opinion. Whatever.
In any event, I was about to add to my earlier reply that the modern M5 looks quite fantastic. I for one would love a Tesla-like experience in the body of the M5. But I think that speaking of design only, the Model S is at worst mid-pack among the mid- and large-size luxury sedan segments.
Re:Tesla launches new Model S with updated design
by state on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:03PM
(#11483963)
Yes, that's fair. Maybe I sound too negative. It's definitely mid-pack, but it's an incredible car! It ought to look like the sexiest, most desirable thing available.
Re:Tesla launches new Model S with updated design
by vvanders on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:53PM
(#11483901)
Yeah, to be fair the design of the S is to have one of the lowest cD of any production car. A traditional grill generates a ton of turbulence so that's a contributing factor to the nosecone/grill-less design.
Re:Tesla launches new Model S with updated design
by bhauer on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:53PM
(#11483910)
To my eye, the overall body shape of the Model S has since its initial conceptual renderings and then at its launch appeared similar to the Jaguar XF. And in my opinion, that's a good thing. I'm not thrilled with this change to remove the false grill, but it's fine. I think this is a matter of not yet being used to the notion of cars with no grill, but over time it may seem more familiar and comfortable.
I am a Tesla advocate, so I am biased, but for what it's worth I feel the conservative styling is an upside. I leased an electric Mini (the "Mini E") for two years and really appreciated that aside from some special paint colors and a couple small graphics, it was basically a Mini Cooper. It wasn't a "Hey, look at me in this electric car!" design. I agree with Musk's opinion that electric cars don't need to stand out—they don't need to look goofy or extreme.
I think the Model S looks classy. Mainstream, yes, but classy mainstream and not boring mainstream. I prefer it to the modern bulbous Mercedes-Benz motif and the Predator-grill Lexus motif.
I wish it weren't true, but I think design is going to keep me burning fossil fuels for a while now. Am I the only one?
Since I'm getting downvoted above, I'll take that as evidence that I am in fact the only one. Ha!
In any event, I was about to add to my earlier reply that the modern M5 looks quite fantastic. I for one would love a Tesla-like experience in the body of the M5. But I think that speaking of design only, the Model S is at worst mid-pack among the mid- and large-size luxury sedan segments.
Even the three-box Lexus LS of 2000 could achieve 0.25.
I am a Tesla advocate, so I am biased, but for what it's worth I feel the conservative styling is an upside. I leased an electric Mini (the "Mini E") for two years and really appreciated that aside from some special paint colors and a couple small graphics, it was basically a Mini Cooper. It wasn't a "Hey, look at me in this electric car!" design. I agree with Musk's opinion that electric cars don't need to stand out—they don't need to look goofy or extreme.
I think the Model S looks classy. Mainstream, yes, but classy mainstream and not boring mainstream. I prefer it to the modern bulbous Mercedes-Benz motif and the Predator-grill Lexus motif.