Re:Fixing C
by paulddraper on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @01:22PM
(#11481528)
YOUR ACTIONS SPEAK SO LOUD I CANNOT HEAR WHAT YOU ARE SAYING.
Stupid shitty broken software. </s>
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Oh, stop :p
"$ find git -name .c -type f | xargs fgrep '{' | wc -l"
19288
"$ find linux -name .c -type f | xargs fgrep '{' | wc -l"
1408368
I'm confused, this is just counting starting braces no?
I think the idea is that Linux has two orders of magnitude more loops, so one order of magnitude more 4-level-indentations is actually an improvement over Git's code, by ratio.
It's not as if Torvalds wrote the entire codebase by himself, anyway.
Re:Fixing C
by paulddraper on Thursday April 14, 2016 @01:44PM
(#11498865)
?
Git and linux were both written (originally) by Torvalds.
And both use a fair amount of deep indentation.
Right. I wasn't really commenting on whether git/linux were coded "correctly" in either case, just that it's not a very helpful metric for the larger conversation.
Re:Fixing C
by paulddraper on Thursday April 14, 2016 @11:41PM
(#11501937)
Fair enough. And my (flippant) comment was on two very large, very successful projects written predominantly in C with thousands of contributors.
Whether >3 level of indentation is "good", IDK. But it happens a lot. And I'm a practical man.