First and foremost, your credit report/score is not a measure of how likely you are to pay back a debt, or how much money you have. It's a measure of how well you can manage and maintain multiple lines of credit simultaneously. That's why you get higher scores for higher account age, for number of accounts (to a point), and for a mix of multiple accounts (revolving, installment, etc).
So by definition if you are not showing that you can maintain and management multiple lines of credit simultaneously, you are higher risk.
And rbobby is wrong, getting a card and cutting it up will do you very little good.
To start you will probably need to get a standard credit card with no rewards, likely one with a small yearly fee. Buy your gas and your groceries and pay off the statement balance in full before the due date every month. Let your credit build slowly. When you can, get a card that offers rewards. Cash back cards are typically best, I have a Chase Freedom card that gives 5% back on rotating categories (gas, groceries, book stores, Amazon, etc). I have a Capital One Venture as well but I rarely use it because the miles accumulated on it (2 miles/year for a $60 annual fee or 1.5 miles/year for no fee) are roughly equivalent to 0.5% cash back if you attempt to do an account credit, and you need 60k+ miles for any flight I would be interested in.
You will still not have top tier credit unless you have some sort of installment loan like a mortgage or car/student loans.
Do you have a relative or friend who would cosign for a relatively small loan for the same purpose?
In fact there's an older banker's maxim that says "never lend money to someone who needs it."
My recommendation: As long as you are disciplined then start using a credit card for your purchases. Google around and find one from a mainstream providers that provides lots of points and no annual fee. At least 1% back on all your purchases. My Citibank card gets me about 2% back on everything I purchase. So basically I get a little discount on all my purchases for having good credit.
Start using it immediately to build up credit. Like it or not, you're only going to encounter more situations like you did with the apartment. And the older you get, the more suspicious it looks.
If you don't feel you can be disciplined enough to pay it off every month, then just use it for handful of recurring purchases and nothing else, then at least you'll start building a credit history.
I'm not even sure what to do to fix the situation, since I'm not interested in credit cards or a new car right away. Any tips?