News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by Domenic_S on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:25PM (#11472709)
It's a shady and powerful system.

The logic goes something like this: the credit reporting agencies simply provided facts (reported to them by others) to the mortgage company, who made their own decision about your creditworthiness.

Who is at fault in your situation? The mortgage company? No, they took your report at face value and then made their own decision. The reporting agencies? No, they just barf back data fed to them by individual creditors and run it through their arbitrary algorithm. The individual creditors? Perhaps, or maybe they sent an accurate report but somewhere along the line two numbers in an SS# got flipped (innocent mistake) and now you're carrying someone else's bad credit.

Scores of companies each have these tiny slices of responsibility, making it really hard to pin one actor with all of it (ie, to name a defendant).

The incentives are perverse. The worse your score the more expensive to borrow. Best case for a lender is to have a customer who should have a high credit score but doesn't because of mistakes like these -- you get the credit risk of a AAA borrower, but can charge subprime rates. Best of both worlds.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by jedberg on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:37PM (#11472842)
> the credit reporting agencies simply provided facts (reported to them by others) to the mortgage company, who made their own decision about your creditworthiness.

That's not true. They reported the information, and a number they came up with on their own. That's new information they created. It is their responsibility to verify any data they use to create that rating.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by Domenic_S on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:00PM (#11473087)
The number is their arbitrary summary of the "facts" contained in the report for easy digestion. If you feed in the same facts to the algorithm over and over, you'll get the same number over and over. Notably, the number has no intrinsic value -- every lender everywhere uses it to score creditworthiness, yes, but it's the lenders who do that. The agencies give them a number and say "do what you will with this information."

I'm the first in line to say the system is horribly broken. I spent years cleaning up inaccuracies on my reports in order to buy a house. Credit reporting is opaque, unfair, and inaccuracies are nearly impossible to correct. It's what makes me wary of automation controlling everything -- manual underwriting used to be a thing, but now almost all of it is automated based on arbitrary numbers and reports that may or may not be true, with no good way to ensure accuracy.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by presidentender on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:50PM (#11474565)
> every lender everywhere uses it to score creditworthiness

SoFi doesn't.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by falcolas on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:50PM (#11472976)
They didn't necessarily create a number - in my experience working with a company who implemented and ran automated credit checks against business criteria, few companies actually pull your FICO; they simply create their own number from the data provided by the credit unions.

Your FICO score costs money to pull, which is why it's not an actual part of the credit report.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by toomuchtodo on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:31PM (#11472764)
> Who is at fault in your situation?

The credit agency. If they're reporting inaccurate information, that they haven't verified, that's libel.

This is something the CFPB [+] needs to clamp down on hard.

[+] http://www.consumerfinance.gov/

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by pc86 on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:56PM (#11473034)
> If they're reporting inaccurate information, that they haven't verified, that's libel.

No it's not, even a little. They are under no legal obligation to independently verify every piece of data sent to them.

In fact, the #1 easiest way to remove a negative mark on your credit is simply to request documentation validating the debt. Even with legitimate debts it's not a foregone conclusion that they will provide any verifying documentation within the required time frame.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by toomuchtodo on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:57PM (#11473048)
> No it's not, even a little. They are under no legal obligation to independently verify every piece of data sent to them.

Verify what they receive about you? Sure, don't verify all of the data. Verify the data they're publishing about you? Yes, they do.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by Domenic_S on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:49PM (#11472961)
I'm no lawyer, but I have a hard time imagining a successful libel suit here. I would guess the reporting agencies have some set of terms & conditions that say something to the effect of "You (the reporter) certify that this report is true and correct to the best of your knowledge".

I mean, come on -- they're aggregators. They can't go investigate every single report they get; they have to depend on reporters to tell the truth.

Importantly, the reporting agencies do not make claims of creditworthiness about you. They present your "credit history" (accurate or not) and the lenders themselves make their own determination. It's an awful catch-22.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by jedberg on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:55PM (#11473020)
> agencies do not make claims of creditworthiness about you.

Which is a load of crap. They present a number and even say "above 750 is excellent". It's in their own marketing materials. How is that not making a claim of creditworthiness?

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by rlucas on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:13PM (#11473230)
You are lumping together a number of players under "they."

The number itself typically comes from Fair Issac -- who traditionally sold a black box algorithm to project a multidimensional vector onto a single scalar.

The data itself comes from a Credit Reporting Agency, who lumps together payment histories and public records.

That data in turn came from creditors and public sources.

I'll happily agree, though: the entire keiretsu benefits from the general public thinking it all sort of just happens and is authoritative and predictive in that single scalar.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by Domenic_S on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:06PM (#11473154)
Ok, you may be technically correct. Experian, for example, says "Higher scores represent a greater likelihood that you'll pay back your debts so you are viewed as being a lower credit risk to lenders."

Even so, lenders still decide what to do with that information. Some credit cards may approve you at a 500 score. Others may not. Many lenders will tier your rate based on score. Ultimately the decision of whether or not to extend credit and what rate you get is up to the lender.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by toomuchtodo on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:08PM (#11473177)
> Even so, lenders still decide what to do with that information. Some credit cards may approve you at a 500 score. Others may not. Many lenders will tier your rate based on score. Ultimately the decision of whether or not to extend credit and what rate you get is up to the lender.

If you're providing factually incorrect information on a person, that someone is then going to make a financial decision around, you should be held liable if your business is to provide factual information on someone regarding the credit worthiness.

Unless we're just going to say that credit agencies have no requirement to verify the data they collect. In that case, let's just rule them illegal through legislation and allow them to dissolve (most of the first world does not have credit agencies for consumers).

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by Domenic_S on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:30PM (#11473421)
Their business is to aggregate what others have told them. It's consensus + automation at its purest. If you have a lot of different companies saying you've been a good boy for a long time, you get a high score. If a couple companies say you're garbage (true or not) you get a bad score. The agencies simply aggregate this information. I guess a lender could cut out the middleman and call each of your previous lenders themselves, but who's to say the result wouldn't be the same (+ the added cost of having to do that).

Conceptually I have no disagreement with you, and I'm certainly no reporting agency apologist. I spent a lot of time on my own report correcting an unfortunate combination of youthful indiscretion and erroneous reporting and I guess I realized that the rage is wasted. There's just no one place to pin the blame, the whole thing is a complex system (intentionally) with perverse incentives (intentionally) and you can either play the game or resign yourself to a life of credit denials.

I hate it too, but I can't see a better way that serves the same scope and scale at the same price. The only place to fight, I think, is 1) for better corrections process, and 2) penalties for companies that incorrectly report.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by jedberg on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:28PM (#11473400)
> most of the first world does not have credit agencies for consumers

Interesting, I didn't realize that. How does credit work where they don't have the agencies? Like if I want to buy a house in Germany or get a credit card in France, does the bank just do all their own research?

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by toomuchtodo on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:53PM (#11473629)
I don't want to generalize too much, but yes, the lender does the majority of the legwork in other countries.
Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by germanier on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:20PM (#11473882)
I don't know about most other countries but both France and Germany do have credit scoring agencies. The difference is that it mostly deals with negative entries, i.e. you don't build credit by repaying loans but rather by never falling behind on your payment schedule (the German system uses a few additional factors). Banks usually don't care if you ever successfully repaid a loan nor do they ask that question.

I don't know what US banks do apart from getting a credit score if somebody applies for a loan but I don't assume it's much less than banks do here: Assessing your income stability and looking at your large fixed expenses.

I also don't think there are any, say, OECD countries without such credit scoring agencies.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday April 11, 2016 @01:38PM (#11473510)
There have been cases in the UK where individuals have successfully sued a lender and/or collection agency because inaccurate or questionable credit records generated costs and/or inconvenience for them.

I'm not aware of any cases where the agencies themselves have been sued.

Re:John Oliver on the ugly state of credit reporting and bac... by Navarr on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:37PM (#11472843)
I think it's pretty clear that it's the reporter who is at fault. Your only defense is that it might be a mistake on their part - but that still puts them at fault.

Possibly legally too? IANAL