Conceptually I have no disagreement with you, and I'm certainly no reporting agency apologist. I spent a lot of time on my own report correcting an unfortunate combination of youthful indiscretion and erroneous reporting and I guess I realized that the rage is wasted. There's just no one place to pin the blame, the whole thing is a complex system (intentionally) with perverse incentives (intentionally) and you can either play the game or resign yourself to a life of credit denials.
I hate it too, but I can't see a better way that serves the same scope and scale at the same price. The only place to fight, I think, is 1) for better corrections process, and 2) penalties for companies that incorrectly report.
Interesting, I didn't realize that. How does credit work where they don't have the agencies? Like if I want to buy a house in Germany or get a credit card in France, does the bank just do all their own research?
I don't know what US banks do apart from getting a credit score if somebody applies for a loan but I don't assume it's much less than banks do here: Assessing your income stability and looking at your large fixed expenses.
I also don't think there are any, say, OECD countries without such credit scoring agencies.
If you're providing factually incorrect information on a person, that someone is then going to make a financial decision around, you should be held liable if your business is to provide factual information on someone regarding the credit worthiness.
Unless we're just going to say that credit agencies have no requirement to verify the data they collect. In that case, let's just rule them illegal through legislation and allow them to dissolve (most of the first world does not have credit agencies for consumers).