(2) Who is having a glucose spike from broccoli? I don't believe this is a real thing. A glucose spike implies a significant amount of absorption in a short period of time. I doubt that broccoli digests quickly enough or suddenly enough in anyone's GI tract to cause a blood sugar spike.
They speculate that it may be due to differences in gut bacteria, but still aren't sure why people react differently to the same food.
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-gut-bacteria-h...
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/06/health/gut-bacteria-from-t...
Surprising how complicated the whole weight loss thing can be
Whereas a cheap soft drink is inert from a nutritional perspective, it probably has a load of flavouring and colouring that's out-of-place too.
None of the orange juice on the shelves is even made from squeezed oranges. They add flavor packs (often made from oranges so they can get away with it being 100% juice; and yes this goes for the natural/organic brands as well).
When you consume oranges, the fiber helps your body feel full. The fiber also helps reduce the insulin response and changes the absorption process. In juice form it digests very differently.
Orange juice is not healthy (and really, neither are oranges in large quantities).
'a high intake of fructose (>20% of energy) can have a deleterious effect on lipid levels.'
[just like alcohol]
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2682989/
Small point: fructose is a ketose sugar so fruit juice is indeed 'sugar water' - confusing bearing in mind the different metabolic fates of glucose and fructose.
From what I've heard, what happens to your liver when you process fructose isn't so great for you. It taxes your liver in many of the same way alcohol processing taxes your liver.
http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/86/4/895.full
Also, here is the relevant Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fructolysis
Seems like the choice is between more work for the liver or more insulin tolerance.
Fruit was given to us in a high-fiber package, and should be consumed that way. The fiber also ensure we don't over consume. You might be full after 1 apple, which is like 1/8th a glass of apple juice.
So eating real fruit, you'll get less sugar, and the fiber helps with digestion and getting the other nutrients that are in fruit.
Haven't most if not all of the commonly available (popular) fruits today been refined through selective breeding to be more appealing to us? What was lost vs. gained in this process?
(I have no idea, I'm not trying to be rhetorical. My guess is lots of more sweetness and perhaps less fiber, in a much larger fruit.)
Don't really know if there is a difference though.
[1] http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:320...
(2) unfortunately reality is complicated. Most of what you care about is the glucose curve after consumption. You are correct in that different foods cause different curves. This will change per person, and some people will spike on soda, and some (smaller group)/actually will do the opposite on broccoli. It also depends on what else you eat around the same time. Interestingly, you can often see a change over time, or if you travel (presumably different gut bacteria)
4) there is a reason it tastes good. Getting fat is good for not starving in the winter, and it is easier to get energy quickly if you need it, but point taken.