We are trying to engage more with people in the application phase now. That should improve things.
Plus, honestly, there are only so many hours of pitches the brain can endure before shutting down and wanting them to be over more than for them to be exciting.
I used to think they were making it up because pg is such a hero in this community and they wanted to make YC look good. But after wasting time disbelieving the process, I now accept that it works, and I spend more time in my interviews trying to understand out WHY it works.
As an example, in Blink he refers to the mostly excellent work of John Gottman [1]. Gladwell's thesis is in Blink is that by "thinking without thinking", i.e. intuition, experts make better decisions. Now Gottman has developed a technique that can predict if a couple will stay together with frightening accuracy, simply by watching them argue. However, the longer he watches, the more accurate his prediction are. And it's not an instinctive thing; it's measuring expressions using a system [2].
Gladwell writes well, and seems believable. That doesn't make him right.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Gottman [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_Action_Coding_System
So maybe it's not that they've never had constructively critical feedback before, but rather just that they haven't yet had much of it outside their area of expertise?