News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by pg on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @08:08PM (#1146958)
That was alarming. We try to make the interview as low stress as possible, believe it or not. But unfortunately we end up having a lot of questions and only 10 minutes to ask them.
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by dood on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @08:19PM (#1146979)
I find the 10 minute limit quite odd. I assume you've thought it through, but it seems to me that the cost of spending a little more time interviewing would likely pay for itself many times over in better decision making. Especially after watching your Mixergy interview, where you emphasize how poor you consider yourselves at choosing who to invest in.
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by pg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:51AM (#1147534)
If we spent more time on each interview, we couldn't interview as many startups in the same period. 10 minutes seems the optimal tradeoff in that respect.

We are trying to engage more with people in the application phase now. That should improve things.

Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by wheels on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @09:09PM (#1147056)
YC did long interviews at first and they've evolved to the shorter form. Presumably this is because they're interviewing so many teams and don't want to change the interview-weekend format drastically to, say, span several weekends.

Plus, honestly, there are only so many hours of pitches the brain can endure before shutting down and wanting them to be over more than for them to be exciting.

Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by AndrewWarner on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:30AM (#1148170)
That sounds shockingly low to me too, but I keep hearing in my interviews with YC-backed entrepreneurs that they got some of their most productive insights from these meetings.

I used to think they were making it up because pg is such a hero in this community and they wanted to make YC look good. But after wasting time disbelieving the process, I now accept that it works, and I spend more time in my interviews trying to understand out WHY it works.

Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by DTrejo on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @08:32PM (#1147001)
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by Robin_Message on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:17AM (#1147737)
Ah, bless Gladwell. You say thin slicing, I say gut instinct or intuition. I'd say Gladwell is not worth reading. He takes an obvious, folksy thing, adds a bit of a twist to it, presents several anecdotes as dramatic stories illustrating his point, then slaps on some "science" to make it seem like its true. It's not. He's just making stuff up that sounds plausible but surprising.

As an example, in Blink he refers to the mostly excellent work of John Gottman [1]. Gladwell's thesis is in Blink is that by "thinking without thinking", i.e. intuition, experts make better decisions. Now Gottman has developed a technique that can predict if a couple will stay together with frightening accuracy, simply by watching them argue. However, the longer he watches, the more accurate his prediction are. And it's not an instinctive thing; it's measuring expressions using a system [2].

Gladwell writes well, and seems believable. That doesn't make him right.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Gottman [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_Action_Coding_System

Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by daeken on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @01:58AM (#1147454)
I'm reading Blink right now (highly recommend it -- very interesting so far), so perhaps there's more said on this later, but I'm not sure thin slicing will help here. pg says they're not very good at choosing people yet, so it's possible that they're thin slicing successfully without knowing about it (as is talked about in Blink), or that the format just isn't successful. Without a whole lot more information (which is tough to get in such a situation), I don't think you can really make a call one way or another. Regardless, it's an interesting idea.
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by ryanhuff on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @08:21PM (#1146981)
Do you think that this is because, up to the point of the YC interview, most founders haven't left the safety zone of "friendly feedback", and therefore haven't encountered a serious vetting of their business idea?
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by pg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @02:46AM (#1147529)
Our questions might be slightly different than people are used to, but I suspect the main problem is simply that there are so many of them, approaching the matter from many directions at once.
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by TheTarquin on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @11:15PM (#1147244)
It may also be (may not, dunno) that a lot of YC applicants are first time entrepreneurs. Many may come from a technical background where they're used to being the topical expert in most of their meetings with "business types". So, they become business types and suddenly that's no longer the case.

So maybe it's not that they've never had constructively critical feedback before, but rather just that they haven't yet had much of it outside their area of expertise?

Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by webwright on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @11:30PM (#1147271)
Heh-- well, I figured it would be better to over-prepare them for stress. We just did a YC panel at a local startup group in Seattle (with a bunch of YC founders) and to a man they all agreed that the interview was a meat grinder. Of course, much of that isn't your fault-- there's a lot of preparation and a lot riding on that 7-10 minutes :-)
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by icey on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @09:34PM (#1147091)
No matter how friendly you try to make it, there will always be people who are nervous in interviews. It's amplified by the fact you're asking questions they probably haven't thought about before. There's not much you can really do to stop the feeling of dread that some people are bound to feel.
Re:Considering Applying to Y Combinator? by jmtame on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @09:50PM (#1147117)
i had fun with our interview. i think the author is referring to the interview as being more of a dialogue and less of a monologue (steve jobs just talks at you).