If there were a study that suggested similar conclusions, what would the result be? More lying?
It seems to me that the proponents of the law should have the burden of conclusive proof, not the opponents.
Speed limits are a major imposition on drivers. They would have to have a significant effect on fatalities to be worthwhile. What about spending the same effort on other life saving approaches, such as mandating safer vehicles? Is that more efficient?
Why? It seems like the norm is speed limits, I thought that the burden of proof rested with those contesting the norm.
Similarly if the tables were turned, the proponents of removing the speed limits should have the burden of proof placed on them as well.
Anyway, this generalization
> The lower–than–US fatality rates on the German Autobahn (where flow management is the primary safety strategy), and now Montana's experience, would indicate that using speed limits and speed enforcement as the cornerstone of US highway safety policy is a major mistake.
is totally out of line in an article that doesn't even address the technical question of statistical significance or deal with potential biases Montana's or Germany's automotive demographics put on the data.
If you want to do a real study, start walking through some data covering a wider range of years, like the 2003 reports here (which covers fatalities by county going back decades):
http://www.doj.mt.gov/enforcement/highwaypatrol/annualreport...
Then you also have to consider improvements in auto safety over the years and how many of what kind of car and driver demographics were in the fatalities.
Edit: More traffic and fatality data:
http://doj.mt.gov/enforcement/highwaypatrol/forms/annualrepo...
http://doj.mt.gov/enforcement/highwaypatrol/forms/annualrepo...
http://doj.mt.gov/enforcement/highwaypatrol/forms/annualrepo...
http://doj.mt.gov/enforcement/highwaypatrol/forms/annualrepo...
http://doj.mt.gov/enforcement/highwaypatrol/forms/annualrepo...